I love u but u hate me maa-Naira

Page

Next Last

CaptiveFreedom

@CaptiveFreedom

Dazzler

Posted: 7 years ago

Still didn't forgive me maa...still u consider me responsible for Shubham's death..I didn't committed that huge crime for which I was punished..forgive me atleast now...I know how I survived those two years...I found a mother after losing my mama but lost her too..we never talked in these two years...but I still love and respect u...BUT...u thrown me out of ur life...u showed hatred instead of love..ur hatred overpower love to an extent that it will destroy everything...I don't blame Karthik as I can understand his condition...I can understand he has to choose one...everything seems to demolish..everything changed and what didn't should also..

Many of u might be considering it all her selflessness only...where people may focus on I still love and respect u I focused on BUT...I focus on the complain...her speaking about dissatisfaction and disappointment...Naira is truly the finest and strongest FL who is stupid at times...annoys me at times..hasty and impulsive at times...but never chose self-pity...she know she didn't commit crime for which she was punished...she has much clearer perspective...

Edited by CaptiveFreedom - 7 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

AnyaRSingh

@AnyaRSingh

Dazzler

Posted: 7 years ago

That scene had me in tears.

Naira deserves better.

I really dont think anything kartik can do for her or suvarna will be enough...Even though she will accept it and probably forgive them... But i really dont think anything will ever be enough...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

parvs

@parvs

Rocker

+ 3

Team Armaan (Gen 4)

Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: AnyaRSingh
That scene had me in tears.
Naira deserves better.
I really dont think anything kartik can do for her or suvarna will be enough...Even though she will accept it and probably forgive them... But i really dont think anything will ever be enough...

exactly... they will never be able to redeem themselves... they have insulted her to such a point that she is so broken... honestly whatever the writers are trying to portray just makes it seem like there is nothing left in their relationship so i dont understand the point of the 6 month thing... usually when that 6 month period is granted there is something to salvage... but here their relationship is so broken and toxic that i dont understand what they are going to try to save😕

and felt really bad for naira when she was like i lost my mom but i thought i found her in you, yet you havent forgiven me for something i didnt do... shivangi was so good in that scene

Edited by Henriette - 7 years ago

Quote

rose2015

@rose2015

Voyager

Posted: 7 years ago

I didn't see a need for this scene. It actually made me angry to see Naira in front of worthless and selfish Suwarna. Naira is too good for their family and she deserves some respect. You throw all responsibilities on your DIL and act like you are retired so that tomorrow you can blame her when you are not happy with the results.

I want Naira to stop crying and have some backbone and self respect. The family doesn't care for your tears rather it will make Suwarna happy to see you suffer. (she wants to see you rot in hell)

There comes a point when you say I can't fix entire families problems without losing my own sanity. It is not Naira's problem to solve Goenka issues. She needs to get as far away from them as she can. Forget another city in India. She needs to go abroad and start a new life.

Quote

Charu

@Krinya

Trailblazer

+ 8

Team Critics

Posted: 7 years ago

I dun consider her as the strongest and finest..She may be disappointed or dissatisfied but at the end of the day if she can't do anything about it , and have a grip of her life , how.is she strong ? Yeah it takes a lot to forgive , that way naira is great..she still loves and respect the one who is causing so much suffering to her , that's our regular tvpur heroine..ye rishta yahi toh kehlata hai..itni gaaliyan deke aur sunke , nafrat leke how they still love and respect each other ...I won't credit anyone with any honour in yeh rishta as all of them had their "suvarna" moment , they are so used to living with each other like that..Naira did the same with akshara , she too didn't listen to her...Bhabhi ma acted the same way, kartik too, and now suvarna..No matter how much we rant, suvarna won't be considered also for redemption ..She will be forgiven in half a minute . Yeah there may be some heated dialogues that's it..You failed me blah blah..And we will have a very strong na-su bond coming up ..

Edited by _charu_ - 7 years ago

Quote

CaptiveFreedom

@CaptiveFreedom

Dazzler

Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: _charu_
I dun consider her as the strongest and finest..She may be disappointed or dissatisfied but at the end of the day if she can't do anything about it , and have a grip of her life , how.is she strong ? Yeah it takes a lot to forgive , that way naira is great..she still loves and respect the one who is causing so much suffering to her , that's our regular tvpur heroine..ye rishta yahi toh kehlata hai..itni gaaliyan deke aur sunke , nafrat leke how they still love and respect each other ...I won't credit anyone with any honour in yeh rishta as all of them had their "suvarna" moment , they are so used to living with each other like that..Naira did the same with akshara , she too didn't listen to her...Bhabhi ma acted the same way, kartik too, and now suvarna..No matter how much we rant, suvarna won't be considered also for redemption ..She will be forgiven in half a minute . Yeah there may be some heated dialogues that's it..You failed me blah blah..And we will have a very strong na-su bond coming up ..

As I said a few will focus on I still love and respect u portion of her dialogues...for me disappointment and dissatisfaction is what mattered...till now she has been strong (my POV)...but I have been repeating it and I know that Suwarna-Naira maa beti milan will be penned down with lotss and lotts of tears and promises...even thinking about it irritates me, I know this yrkkh is kkkg version 2...half minute?...mata will be forgiven in nanoseconds...Naira will be the first one to forgive her...I can bet on that...

Quote

CaptiveFreedom

@CaptiveFreedom

Dazzler

Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: rose2015
I didn't see a need for this scene. It actually made me angry to see Naira in front of worthless and selfish Suwarna. Naira is too good for their family and she deserves some respect. You throw all responsibilities on your DIL and act like you are retired so that tomorrow you can blame her when you are not happy with the results.

I want Naira to stop crying and have some backbone and self respect. The family doesn't care for your tears rather it will make Suwarna happy to see you suffer. (she wants to see you rot in hell)

There comes a point when you say I can't fix entire families problems without losing my own sanity. It is not Naira's problem to solve Goenka issues. She needs to get as far away from them as she can. Forget another city in India. She needs to go abroad and start a new life.

@bold well I think Naira cried the least I mean she firmly took that decision without much rona dhona I loved the way she told Naitik that they should leave with determination on her face even after been broken...I want her emotional outburst...if she had no self-respect she won't have gave up on Karthik 2 years back...if going away is going to break her silence and give her peace and happiness than that's the best thing to do...I know lots of people think after divorce people should never look back...complete their education...build their career...be successful...that's right thing to do...but sometimes not every time though those scars are never healed...sometimes people regret losing their marital bliss (kill me for saying this)...here she lost her dream too...and only he gave her hope...he knew what was that dream to her...she won't ever dance after divorce...she might not cry as much as expected but she will be a living corpse...she had to decide...for her...for him...that was a tough decide even if it was to relieve him...but that's the best decision...Will the memories be faded if she start living in abroad? Not making a choice to be blamed again is saner decision...

Edited by CaptiveFreedom - 7 years ago

Quote

CaptiveFreedom

@CaptiveFreedom

Dazzler

Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: Henriette

exactly... they will never be able to redeem themselves... they have insulted her to such a point that she is so broken... honestly whatever the writers are trying to portray just makes it seem like there is nothing left in their relationship so i dont understand the point of the 6 month thing... usually when that 6 month period is granted there is something to salvage... but here their relationship is so broken and toxic that i dont understand what they are going to try to save😕

and felt really bad for naira when she was like i lost my mom but i thought i found her in you, yet you havent forgiven me for something i didnt do... shivangi was so good in that scene

@bold there is a lot left in their relationship if they think beyond "maa ka dard"...they left their facades behind for few moments...being their original selves...but they are in this situation due to their fault...specifically its his fault...to give up on her...than blame her...his unreal expectations and confused state of mind is mostly because he doesn't know entire story...he doesn't know what exactly happened 2 years back with Naira...he didn't even bother to know and try to mend things...they chose stagnancy...

Quote

Charu

@Krinya

Trailblazer

+ 8

Team Critics

Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: CaptiveFreedom

As I said a few will focus on I still love and respect u portion of her dialogues...for me disappointment and dissatisfaction is what mattered...till now she has been strong (my POV)...but I have been repeating it and I know that Suwarna-Naira maa beti milan will be penned down with lotss and lotts of tears and promises...even thinking about it irritates me, I know this yrkkh is kkkg version 2...half minute?...mata will be forgiven in nanoseconds...Naira will be the first one to forgive her...I can bet on that...

Yeah both are facts . Anyways I don't think naira should be hating her , after all its just a passing emotion which suvarna is going through ..She is not scheming against naira, she wants her out of sight...But to me, naira is strong only for others (tanvi, her blast from the past friend , the orphans , her college friends etc) but never for herself . We have been debating on it for quite a while 😆 yeah this time she tried to be strong but that was before kartik reentered her life..Thereafter she was the same old naira. ..And I sincerely belive , one has to find happiness and contentment within , we want to see naira happy, till the time her happiness depends on others , she will never be happy ..Her life may revolve around kartik and suvarna but that's not the beginning and end , at least they can show that much..Ke she finds happiness without them too ! She is such a bright smart girl ..I really admired her post aksharas death, how she matured in a day ..Kya reverse gear laga diya..Kartik kartik rona dhona..When it's not her fault she must not waste a thought over it..Kartik will come to her if he loves her..She doesn't have to do favors to them , even divorce ..Let him decide let them do it..

Edited by _charu_ - 7 years ago

Quote

AJS

@Ajscinesonadar

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 7 years ago

#10

I agree with you more than any selflessness talk it was more like a complaining I found.

So far we have only scene how naira affected by kartik blaming, and what she has on her head for kartik, today they opened new perspective of naira on swarna's blaming. And it clearly state she loved and respected her consider her as her own maa but maa turn out to be a disppoinment.
That scene was nuch needed now we know atleast naira dont consider her as a failed daughter to infront of matha.

Everything well and good so far, like many even I have question isn't naira going to forgive that one hell of a selfish mother easily? After all its yeh rishta.

Least expectation I have is kartik boy should realize this first and he should speak up for naira to matha without any fear.
Kartik should make her realize what she has done to her beta and his wife.
Naira shouldn't have any word with that lady when reconsile happens. Matha doesnt deserve that.