Week 11 TRP - YRKKH Out Of Top 10 - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

42

Views

5.1k

Users

12

Likes

93

Frequent Posters

Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8

Team Critics

Posted: 7 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: CaptiveFreedom


Before getting Shubham married or make him find his love interest they should have focused on Suwarna-Shubham bonding and Karthik-Shubham bonding...there was no need of new characters as of new...the screespace wasted on Suhana and her bf could be utilized in a proper way...on scenes like Naira-Naksh taking care of their papa and spending time with him to reduce his depression, they can show very good scenes in this regard all three of them remembering good old days a few simple scenes can be good...Kaira oriented doesn't necessarily means Kaira's romantic scenes though they are more refreshing than entire episode...it also involves their bonding with pivotal characters...bonding does't mean they have to be saviors for others...I want to see their conversations with pivotal characters...them doing something productive in company of pivotal characters...I would have loved to see KD's perception changing even 10% on baby girl being sufficient for Kaira...even 10% change in her her perception that she will be happy without pota would have been a change in true sense...


Maine toh suhana shubham ke baare mein poocha dear


If dadi will change they will have practically nothing to show . They must have strong gray characters.. ..Not like. Suhana and her brother ..Shubham had the potential but now he is reduced to a joker
CaptiveFreedom thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: A HUGE FAN

The thing is YRKKH has run out of ideas! Even if you put Kaira in the front burner storylines & they've had WAY too many, it is the same old: fight, loose trust, back together/romance & so on! This baby track should promote Keesh but instead will focus on Kaira where as Kaira already had the baby track where Naira was falsely thought she's pregnant and Dadi G wanting a boy child, not a girl and etc. Too much focus isn't good either but a well balance characters/scenes should be the focus & formula!


Bur her low fertility was never highlighted right? Low fertility is a common issue these days and yes I've seen many woman not being able to conceive and are shattered hearing it...few couples handle it with maturity the way Kaira will do...the way Naira did by not losing hope...even 2% chances are enough...sometime woman who is 90% fertile isn't able to conceive...

@bold In my opinion their pregnancy is forced the way their marriage was forced without any development...Its early for them to have baby with zero development in their bonding...also Kaira never had a full fledged pregnancy track...initially it was more of false alarm track the only track during Keesh ki Shadi with 2.7 before Bahu Beti ki Bidayi and than KD's orthodox believes were highlighted when she wanted a baby boy for them...yesterday's episode had 12-15 minutes longg Shubham attempting to suicide scene...they could have accommodated it with Naksh-Keerti feeling happy...but Naksh's mind is stuck over that one thing Keerti has hidden and he is not talking about it...Keerti on being confused about fast and getting panicked over this small issue should have directly asked elders or could have refused politely...few women fast during pregnancy too specifically when fast is of short duration...

CaptiveFreedom thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: _charu_


Maine toh suhana shubham ke baare mein poocha dear


If dadi will change they will have practically nothing to show . They must have strong gray characters.. ..Not like. Suhana and her brother ..Shubham had the potential but now he is reduced to a joker


@bold that's the point! marriage is not solution for everything but writers consider marriage the only solution...Keerti had troubled marriage get her married again immediately without development in her character...I would have liked to see her becoming independent woman who is successful in her career and starts believing in herself before getting married...similarly for Shubham they could have given him education by online education system or hiring tutors at home before introducing characters like Suhana and her brother with whom people can't connect...with getting him educated they could have highlighted on Suwarna-Shubham or Karthik-Shubham bonding...I miss Karthik-Manish, Naira-Manish, Suwarna-Naira, Swarnish bonding too...why not show Goenkas having family moments?...
CaptiveFreedom thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: _charu_



Ditto ! I really dont get the skewed perspective of the Cvs..If kirti is pregnant , it's all about naira is not pregnant , naira is worried for kirti, naira is announcing for kirti , kaira is dancing for kirti, naira cannot conceive , naira will hide the truth then kaira will hide the truth ...If it's shubham, it's all about how naira will be suspicious, how naira will bail him out ..And then they say cvs focus on other characters and trps go down 😕 koi track ko theek se toh dikhate nai..Why did they bring in Naitik's depression story ? To see others reaction to his hiding the truth and his illness ? Sorry..kairas reaction ..Kairas stand, kairas trust on him..In naksh kirti wedding focus should have bee n on their characters, their thinking , their delimma, and not kaira fight and separation...Sab gadbad yahan hai..derailing yahi se shuru hua..why did they show naksh forcefully saying yes to marriage..there could have been a mature love story too between them or arranged match with willingness..bec then kaira separation kaise hota ?


suvarna shubham was so poorly handled I have said this so many times . Now what if they show bonding ? It will look fake..again, the focus in this track was kartik and suvarna reunion instead of suvarna shubham story..Ulta suvarna ko hi justify kar diya...In a story every character should be important even though they are supporting ..As u said balance is the key. ..Isse acha toh they can apply the good old formula of theirs..Festivals/shadi followed by gharelu problems followed by festivals shadi..


@bold Wasn't it same during Naitik Akshara's time? their issues and their problems weren't highlighted through their bonding with other characters? Varsha's character was a lott stronger than Keerti's character...similarly Maheshwari's considered their daughter important too than doing gun gan of their DIL only and babysitting her 24/7. Akshara's bonding with Maheshwari's didn't disappear like Naira's bonding with Singhania's disappeared...

Naksh-Keerti's marriage was unnecessarily forced I agree on that...

@bold But I see Shubham taking promise from Suwarna, him misbehaving and attempting to suicide too...

Plus they should have a separate track for Naira's low fertility and Keerti's pregnancy than mixing two of them...but it happens in real life too...women like KD's friends taunt girls who are unable to conceive giving examples of those who have conceived before them...and yes those who are unable to conceive are are considered to be on contraceptives and unwilling to conceive early it is somewhere a reflection of section of society...Naksh-Keerti's happiness could also be highlighted I won't mind seeing Naksh happy for a change...
Edited by CaptiveFreedom - 7 years ago
pranesh_swetha thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#25
I have been writing this again and again u should concentrate on both t pairs keerti s pregency had so many moments that could have been written between keesh but they are ruining it why should Naira announce it it is a husband wife pal Naira can not be centric
In everything and showing a women responsible for not having children is very 3 class in majority of such cases men are infertility such a track is being wasted by showing old masala because they canthink of only dadi belngproblem factor keesh story line is very strong but they want to ruin it fine i have stopped watching t show I read only ff now those writers are better than t cvs of this show Rip yeh rishta
Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8

Team Critics

Posted: 7 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: CaptiveFreedom


@bold Wasn't it same during Naitik Akshara's time? their issues and their problems weren't highlighted through their bonding with other characters? Varsha's character was a lott stronger than Keerti's character...similarly Maheshwari's considered their daughter important too than doing gun gan of their DIL only and babysitting her 24/7. Akshara's bonding with Maheshwari's didn't disappear like Naira's bonding with Singhania's disappeared...

Naksh-Keerti's marriage was unnecessarily forced I agree on that...

@bold But I see Shubham taking promise from Suwarna, him misbehaving and attempting to suicide too...

Plus they should have a separate track for Naira's low fertility and Keerti's pregnancy than mixing two of them...but it happens in real life too...women like KD's friends taunt girls who are unable to conceive giving examples of those who have conceived before them...and yes those who are unable to conceive are are considered to be on contraceptives and unwilling to conceive early it is somewhere a reflection of section of society...Naksh-Keerti's happiness could also be highlighted I won't mind seeing Naksh happy for a change...


Exaxtly..All this happened but at that time story telling was way better..Aksharas miscarriage was.dealt with sensitivity..Nobody taunted her , her mil or baisa ..Every track was handled well ..It had a beginning and proper closure with all characters given due importance ..The way maheshwari s stood like a rock to akshara, naira never got it .. but she has a family, why don't they focus on it ?...Bec kaira are superheros and problems in their life are bec of their family only 99% of the time. ...Otherwise there is no story for them literally..That's the impression I get..That's what they show..There is no bond present here except kartik naira..No bond between anyyybody is highlighted except them


Naitik does nothing but gives impulsive reactions , go and shout on dadi..It's crass...Shaurya and vishambhar also got angry whenever something happened with akshara but maheshwaris discussed the issue first and decided what to do, , rather than go and shout on their samdhi..Every problem was handled maturely ...At least the elders can show maturity ?..there is a vast difference in approach...The story was so well woven at that time that they didn't need any outside character , for years...It all happened between the families only ...


Edited by _charu_ - 7 years ago
CaptiveFreedom thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: _charu_


Exaxtly..All this happened but at that time story telling was way better..Aksharas miscarriage was.dealt with sensitivity..Nobody taunted her , her mil or baisa ..Every track was handled well ..It had a beginning and proper closure with all characters given due importance ..The way maheshwari s stood like a rock to akshara, naira never got it .. but she has a family, why don't they focus on it ?...Bec kaira are superheros and problems in their life are bec of their family only 99% of the time. ...Otherwise there is no story for them literally..That's the impression I get..That's what they show..There is no bond present here except kartik naira..No bond between anyyybody is highlighted except them


Naitik does nothing but gives impulsive reactions , go and shout on dadi..It's crass...Shaurya and vishambhar also got angry whenever something happened with akshara but maheshwaris discussed the issue first and decided what to do, , rather than go and shout on their samdhi..Every problem was handled maturely ...At least the elders can show maturity ?..there is a vast difference in approach...The story was so well woven at that time that they didn't need any outside character , for years...It all happened between the families only ...



They are overdoing everything be they unnecessary problems, extreme negativity or situations. By Kaira oriented track most of Kaira fans also mean their bonding with other characters which is completely missing...most of us also don't want them to solve other people's problems and being unable to solve their own problem the way it happened in jkg track...for CVs their bonding with others can ONLY be highlighted by them solving other people's problems (Shubham) or other people (KD) creating problems for them...I believe if Keerti and Naksh were not married the only way to involve Singhanias in storyline was to show their bonding with Naira...but now they are give few monologues every day...whereas I want to see the positive dialogues like titliyon jaisa khoobsorat rishta from them...I want to see Nani-Naira bonding which was beautiful...I want to see KD-Kittu positive bonding which is completely missing now...want to see Naira's Suwarna maa standing for her the way she stood up for her several times previously...Karthik-Manish bond was least explored...Suwarnish also had good chemistry...I want to see drop by drop progress in KD, sometimes they turn her overly negative only to create problems for Kaira...these days only negativity is highlighted which made me lose interest in jkg track, there is negativity in real world too but family's support is an integral part of everyone's life...Karthik and Naira are not receiving that support...neither Kittu from his dadi...nor Naira from her nani...I like their determination, strength and ability to face challenges together or as individuals...ability to be happy for others forgetting their sorrows...but the bonding...the conversations I want to see are missing...I want to see them showing their vulnerable sides infront of their love ones the way once Karthik showed infront of Suwarna on seeing Naira's condition and Naira showed infront of Nani after Akshara's death truth...that's why we get excited over whatever we get be it small Kaira conversation or their romantic scenes or them standing for each other...Monotony isn't good..there was a time when ardent Kaira fans including me requested CVs not to show any song sequence on Kaira Milan and show their proper conversation after JKG track...its flaw in writing that they are unable to write good Kaira's conversations with other characters too...beside that I'm personally liking Naira's approach in present track...and looking forward to see Kaira facing it together...KD will be negative throughout, Singhanias will be all monologues and none will go upto Naira to say that everything will be okey...
--Priyaa-- thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#28
I started watching Yeh Rishta from the very first episode..Then it was about Akshara and Naitik...Then later, I really liked the lovely KAIRA..they have nice chemistry and once they seemed more relatable because they had proper trust and understanding for each other.. and once this show was better than most Indian shows and the stories seemed real and relatable..but all current tracks are boring..I just now read an India Forums article about Dadi trying to get Karthik remarried because Naira's chances of getting pregnant are less..now its turning into a typical Saas bahu saga..maybe leap of 10 years will come after this..and I guess Naira is living separately with her kid and Karthik don't know about them..But they get cool makeovers to woo audiences..Then it will be typical soap opera with Rona Dhona manana..now I'm not interested in this show and stopped watching it few days back with a heavy heart because I really liked it once..
Edited by mere_pyaar - 7 years ago
A HUGE FAN thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: _charu_



Ditto ! I really dont get the skewed perspective of the Cvs..If kirti is pregnant , it's all about naira is not pregnant , naira is worried for kirti, naira is announcing for kirti , kaira is dancing for kirti, naira cannot conceive , naira will hide the truth then kaira will hide the truth ...If it's shubham, it's all about how naira will be suspicious, how naira will bail him out ..And then they say cvs focus on other characters and trps go down 😕 koi track ko theek se toh dikhate nai..Why did they bring in Naitik's depression story ? To see others reaction to his hiding the truth and his illness ? Sorry..kairas reaction ..Kairas stand, kairas trust on him..In naksh kirti wedding focus should have bee n on their characters, their thinking , their delimma, and not kaira fight and separation...Sab gadbad yahan hai..derailing yahi se shuru hua..why did they show naksh forcefully saying yes to marriage..there could have been a mature love story too between them or arranged match with willingness..bec then kaira separation kaise hota ?


suvarna shubham was so poorly handled I have said this so many times . Now what if they show bonding ? It will look fake..again, the focus in this track was kartik and suvarna reunion instead of suvarna shubham story..Ulta suvarna ko hi justify kar diya...In a story every character should be important even though they are supporting ..As u said balance is the key. ..Isse acha toh they can apply the good old formula of theirs..Festivals/shadi followed by gharelu problems followed by festivals shadi..


Beautifully said and completely agree. The CVs just don't know what to do anymore. Yes Kaira are the leads but you cannot forget the supporting cast & the importance of their values as well. The leads (in this case two people) cannot carry a show.
A HUGE FAN thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: CaptiveFreedom


Bur her low fertility was never highlighted right? Low fertility is a common issue these days and yes I've seen many woman not being able to conceive and are shattered hearing it...few couples handle it with maturity the way Kaira will do...the way Naira did by not losing hope...even 2% chances are enough...sometime woman who is 90% fertile isn't able to conceive...

@bold In my opinion their pregnancy is forced the way their marriage was forced without any development...Its early for them to have baby with zero development in their bonding...also Kaira never had a full fledged pregnancy track...initially it was more of false alarm track the only track during Keesh ki Shadi with 2.7 before Bahu Beti ki Bidayi and than KD's orthodox believes were highlighted when she wanted a baby boy for them...yesterday's episode had 12-15 minutes longg Shubham attempting to suicide scene...they could have accommodated it with Naksh-Keerti feeling happy...but Naksh's mind is stuck over that one thing Keerti has hidden and he is not talking about it...Keerti on being confused about fast and getting panicked over this small issue should have directly asked elders or could have refused politely...few women fast during pregnancy too specifically when fast is of short duration...


Again, Keesh maybe forced because CVs didn't build or took time with them like they did with Kaira. Even Kaira, it took time like over a year and Keesh weren't given that at all. Keesh were given a pairing so quickly due to future Kaira storylines. You cannot fault the characters of Keesh, but blame the writers!

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Arziya

28 days ago

YRKKH BTS, SM updates and Spoilers Thread! #122 YRKKH BTS, SM updates and Spoilers Thread! #122

Hello everyone! Welcome to the YRKKH BTS and Spoilers Thread! Please share any clips about upcoming story arcs or Behind the Scenes clips that...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: minakrish

2 months ago

📌 YRKKH EDT Sign-Up /Permission Thread [Closed]

Hey everyone, As many of you know, Sutapasima has stepped down from the YRKKH moderation team. With that change, we’re now opening up the EDT...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Sutapasima

6 months ago

YRKKH: TRP Thread #14 : 10 Jan 2025

Welcome to the YRKKH Weekly TRP thread! This will be the official thread to post and discuss about the weekly online and offline TRPs of Yeh...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Arziya

1 months ago

YRKKH BTS, SM updates and Spoilers Thread! #121 YRKKH BTS, SM updates and Spoilers Thread! #121

Hello everyone! Welcome to the YRKKH BTS and Spoilers Thread! Please share any clips about upcoming story arcs or Behind the Scenes clips that...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: shahsb_26

2 months ago

YRKKH Gen 3 Triangle On Screen Again 😂😂🤭

Apart from laughable title of Atoot Rishta on this channel... If new show airs at 8 as per rumours from June 16th, we will have Harshad at 8 on...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".