asmita21180 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
I know right now many of you have agreed to justify Swati and Naina as wrong ...But I have some points about both of them ...I am not Saying Naina is not at fault...But not because of the reason given by Swati..
1. I loved Sameer and I told Naina where as she did hide the truth -

My POV ... Swati was always shown as extrovert person even from day 1 of her entry ( she mentioned some neighbour singing for her) Although filmy I can give her benefit of doubt ..As many young girls have lots of crushes and it's a basic human feeling not at all wrong...So when sameer came it was even swati to fall for his charm as the other school girls...She even told Naina ,but with a tag line ( tu nahi samjhegi ,tujhe padhai se fursat nahi , teri shakal sahi nahi ..)

Naina - she did fall for sameer on first sight and although this feeling was new for her it was her first time... Why she didn't told.Swati ...It was her first romantic encounter and she knew swati is too filmy she would never be right person to give her insight ( but she told Shefali ..Although she lied about an imaginary friend but it's obvious that days no one just shout their feelings openly ...) Later also we saw she did take advice from Shefali and not Swati...not because she thinks swati less ...But she took advice from a person who has similar Mind level as herself...

Even now-a-days we see classmates hate the most intelligent of them..They always despise them..But do they ever try to be equal to them...I don't think so...

Even grown up..I know many of us despise our collegues, neighbours or relatives ...When we know they are what they wanted to be ...This is human nature to point the grapes sour when you can't have them ...

So whatever reason .It was ...But Naina didn't do this intentionally or unintentionally...Infact when the thing got out..She even thought to distance from sameer if you all remember ..She said that she can't leave Swati as she is her friend since ling time for sameer...

2. It was rather other way round ...Although due to bet ...But it was Sameer loves Naina ...

Even if Sameer had not loved Naina I don't think he would have fallen in love with anyone else there...
Like he rejected Kamya ... Kamya was so eager to even get physical with sameer but he rejected her...In many cases I think although Naina never gave credits Kamya is even more loyal then swati... When chance for Delhi competition Kamaya happily sacrificed herself so that Naina could meet sameer ..Never taking big claims ...Where as if it was swati ..She would have named it as back stabbing...

He denied the kiss scene in play with swati just because he thought that his best friend is in love with that girl...
So stop blaming Naina for everything that goes wrong in some.other person life...


When in love it is always two peoples choices ...So Swati beating over past is not right..It was as much as Sameer's choice he loved Naina ...And he did whatever to get her love back...Swati witnessed all this things..And still if she hates Naina then god pity her...

3. Swati's Anger for Munna ...

Swati and munna are in relationship and she has all the right to be angry with him...But how is this Naina's fault...Some one pls explain ...

It's amazing how Fans did support munna's craziness and involvement with Samaina as Concern and loyality before days ..Are now blaming Naina ...( Naina devi ki jai and all ) ...

If you guys remember post breakup ..Naina told preeti to join gang and sit with other and not to worry about her...She told peeti that she can't break with friends coz she is no more with sameer... That's the maturity level and selflessness of Naina ..But many ignore this all and always keep blaming her for whatever happens...

Munna did ignore swati so this is their problem... Not others...Swati if she was so much serious she must have put some efforts on her relationship...But seeing her actions I don't feel they were or atleast swati was ever serious about her relationship...Infact their love story was even worse then Shef-Jun ...

Now about elections when it was whole gang pressurized Naina in the canteen scene...Naina voiced that she can't...But everyone wanted her to fight for G.S. and she gave in...

So minus Naina and Swati by majority if we see everyone wanted Naina ...(She had earned it ..Believe me or not...She was always oriented and serious about studies and her life...Not like others who are having fun now..And when times comes keep blaming others...)


4. G.S . Elections..

Although I don't know how but as JBR said Sunaina has already Named Naina to be her Rival...

So how come swati didn't hear this...( Completely fault of CV's to bend the story as per plot required) ...But if we ignore this...How is Naina responsible...


After all this ends and Even It is revealed that it was Swati behind everything...I don't think Naina should be her friends anymore...This kind of inferiority in other person will never make her loyal...( If even they are friends Swati will take.credit of G.S ..Like she takes credit of Naina getting Sameer .. 😆) ...

Edited by asmita21180 - 7 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

16

Views

3.7k

Users

13

Likes

75

Frequent Posters

bmk28 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
Asmita, Dil Le Lo for this post.. You summed up really well...Naina is an easy prey right now and in the process some of the posts are not always in form of critical analysis.. Anyways, I tend to ignore it as you cant change mindset of everyone.. But I hope this agni pariksha that Naina has to go through everyday ends soon...Swati is still filmy and thats the flaw of her personality!!
PS- Just wrote on another post about the quote - Real friends talk shit on your face and good things behind your back..
RedGiant thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
Thank you so much for this post ! Lots of Love ❤️
asmita21180 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: bmk28

Asmita, Dil Le Lo for this post.. You summed up really well...Naina is an easy prey right now and in the process some of the posts are not always in form of critical analysis.. Anyways, I tend to ignore it as you cant change mindset of everyone.. But I hope this agni pariksha that Naina has to go through everyday ends soon...Swati is still filmy and thats the flaw of her personality!!

PS- Just wrote on another post about the quote - Real friends talk shit on your face and good things behind your back..


I agree Beena ..

Even of I ignore some posts I can't take all and everyone criticising characters ...First for the things they do ...Or for the things that they don't...
There is always 2+2 =4 ...If you think that way you wil never face problem ever...Problem is people try to make 2+2=5 and then justify it...

This may be a show...But a show close to everyone's heart...And this is why we are even here in these forum on an off day ...To get some thing related to show...

So far I am all satisfied with the CV's to keep this show as realistic as possible... It is like part of life I am watching on TV...( Although some.aspects I have issues...With the conversations ,missing plots...)But in no conditions I don't feel it is right to bash or abuse any character on the actions they chose to do...
ani25 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#5
Good analysis..the only fault I see of Naina is that she didn't considered checking with Swati before opting for elections again. I feel it's both of their fault that they didn't tried enough to discuss the issue. Swati could have reached out to Naina the next day when she didn't talk to her over the phone to talk about her concerns and Naina could have asked her why she called so late at night. But other than that I feel the entire scene of Swati confessing the issues with Naina to Shoe was due to Swati's immaturity and insecurities.
Abhinaya_Abhi thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#6
Bang on👍🏼
Awesome post!
PM1774 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#7
In indian Tele series the FL has to be great...rest all characters are to be made grey if not dark...even they do not even spare Hero...yeh kya mahan...naina ko dikhana...in reality every one is a little bad and a little good...but in Tele series only the FL has to be good in all aspect...the general girls with average intelligence cannot do anything...they can only turn childish foolish or grey at times evil...why they are showing sunaina as evil and swati as grey...they could have shown them as normal girls with only jealousy or angry...but no in serial they have to be shown as bad...why...if the story writer is boosting about a real or even inspired by real story...then swati sunaina is actually non existing...
kranti thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#8
According to me when gang did not consider Swati's view and insisted naina to stand for election I felt bad for that... And even Munna not taking her seriously was actually not good for relationship.. That time I understood her feelings... But later getting instigated by sunaina and backstabbing childhood best friend is not good and justified in such friendships.. It's breaking of trust for lifetime...
If she considered naina as best friend she had full haq to bash naina for not understanding her feelings and replacing her in elections... It was justified actually.

Yes Naina and Sameer not thought of her that seriously but guys think after so much pain, betrayal and after almost 2-3 months they were back together as lovers.. It was very natural for them to get engrossed into each other,to be in love... and not paying attention to others particularly that time... .
But apart from this election how naina was responsible for her misery and considered as selfish I don't know...
And Swati sharing her past feelings for Sameer to sunaina was weird actually ...
I think maximum girls like kamya, swati, sunaina and other girls too had crush on Sameer that too naturally by his looks and personality.
I think it seems all these girls did not understood why and how Sameer fallen in love with Naina that too soon deeply...
According to them Naina was padakhu, Zhalli ,Average looking girl and not good looking ,fashionable then them . Still how Sameer had fallen so much in love with this simple girl and not them... And I think Swati was one of them and deep in subconscious mind she was still hurt that Sameer fallen for Naina not her... So in spur of anger and hurt she comes her feelings to sunaina...
But I don't know if these things were still in her head how she had fallen in love for Munna ..or should we consider she never loved Munna that deeply...

Lavender25 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#9
Great post. I agree that swati got ignored and actually felt bad about it. We dont know whether the spoiler is completely true or not, but dont want swati to do something like that . Swati can yell at Naina, she has full rights but if she do something like jumbling votes it would be betrayal and most importantly deeper than Naina's blindness towards her feelings.Swati loves munna right , then how come she all of a sudden remembered her crush for sameer ?? It kind of conveyed that she never got over that incident. Im dissatisfied with Naina's behavior these days but she wasn't like this before and i admired her for that ❤️she even told swati is very important for her to sameer then.
asmita21180 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: kranti

But I don't know if these things were still in her head how she had fallen in love for Munna ..or should we consider she never loved Munna that deeply...



Yes..This and the other point u mentioned ..So swati is the one selfish ( forgive her as it's her age ) ...But she comes out as selfish for her best friend or the love..( she mentioned that it was her who first loved Sameer but gave up for Naina as she was her childhood friend😆 )...

Whole loop and writers fault...Othr then that I feel that SwaMun love story is a decision in rage which could happ en among any teenager it can be infatuation or attraction but not love...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".