Mar 9th: Sameer Jayprakash Maheshwari :) - Page 3

Originally posted by: rose1000

What a tearjerker episode!

Nanu's words were so strong. And even when in his last breath, he did not forget Naina. Yesterday and today's episodes were well executed. The death scenes in soap world are usually OTT. But today i felt I am watching a desi show from the 90s when content used to be meaningful and acting used to be natural. I have memoery of only one movie of Kiran Sir as hero. Aaj Ki Taza khabar. It came on DD channel ages back. I had enjoyed it. It was comedy. But Kiran Sir never made it as lead in HIndi films. So he turned to negative roles which he always played so well. I am so thankful to the CVs for keeping Nanu's character so good from start to finish. 👏

Aadmi musafir hai

Aata hai jata hai

Aate jate raste mein

woh yaadein chor jata hai...

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ipePh7hAkYc[/YOUTUBE]

Nanu ki yaadein humesha hum viewers mein zinda rahegi.

Coming to the scene, I liked Somani today. I think he was really genuine. He did keep his hand on Sam's shoulder. I hope it is not a loophole to be forgetten in future just like so many them have been forgotten. I hope it means Somani will try to be good to Sam. In the past Somani did want to take Sam to Delhi. Probably Somani is not that bad. We don't know how he speaks to Rohan and Deepika yet. May be he is like that with all kids...Let's see...

Vishakha.. I liked her acting. But sorry I don't feel anything for her now. She abandoned her own son to make her own life comfortable...How can she be called a good mother? Well she promised lot of things to Nanu. May be she will take care of Sam and get close to him in the process neglecting others And that negative daadi will be furious with her...and so Sam may leave Delhi...

Mundit...gems...❤️

Village scenes...I found them stupid today.

We are feeling so emotional jsut by watching Nanu's death on screen. Can you all imagine what Sumeet Mittal must have gone through in real life? HE lsot his mother, then his grandfather and then Chachiji...no wonder Shashi Mittal has been a rock for him and her family has always been there for him. 😭

Randeep should consider himself very lucky for getting this role. And he has not let Shashi Sumeet down. The remarkable improvement in his acting skills is an indication he will go very far...👏

And now to all the behenas of the thread...cheer up

Kahan tak yeh maan ko andhere chalenge

Udasi bhare din kabhi to dhalenge

Kabhi sukh kabhi dukh

yehi zindagi hai

yeh pathjhar ka mausam ghari do ghari hai

Naye phool kal phir dagar mein khilenge

udasi bhare din kabhi to dhalenge😊

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qJJIAgm3LLA[/YOUTUBE]

Rose, lovely songs. Thanks for trying to cheer up all of us. I am too furious today.

Nanu believed in his grandson's innocence but will never what had transpired. So many things unresolved, its all annoying me at the moment.

What true to life depiction in the show are we talking about? Was Sumeet slapped by Shashi's dad so many times? Was he a 'naukar' is Shashi's house? Did he have a mean step dad? So much fiction has been added to the original love story for drama. Then why couldnt Nanu be alive? If nanu is paralyzed or in coma or on extended bed rest Sam would still have to step up and handle the business. Then there is hope of his recovery and it has more positive vibes.

Anyway I have spoken enough about it.

Somani confused me today. I saw him consoling, smirking and empathizing. If he had not been shown to call the princi about the key, instigated Vishaka repeatedly, created distance between mother and son, I would have thought he was a grey character. I remember how he made an excuse so Vishaka had to leave with him during the cricket match in the head boy selection phase. Have the CVs forgotten all that?

Originally posted by: Infofan

I try to be sanskari on the first page but today, if I may make an exception and speak my heart out Dear CVs, You added many dramatic elements, characters and events to the real life love story of Mittals. This is one aspect of Mittal's life that could have been easily skipped in the show. As CVs, I am sure you could find many ways to move the story forward and show character progression but you took the easy way out. What a bunch of sadistic morons! I had to actually see it to believe that Nanu is no more!

Originally posted by: canapoem

So true Nandy.

Why should a story always take a regressive track for the growth of a character.

Should Sameer be bullied, verbally abused, slapped, trashed, burnt to become a responsible person?

Should Nanaji be killed for Sameer to build a relationship with his mother and if possible other members of the family?

Infact 90s television shows used to be very progressive. Most of them say that it was Ekta Kapoor who ruined the Television industry. Maybe true.

I remember watching shows during 90s which were not only progressive but had so much depth and content in them.

If Sameer had to move to Delhi, then story writers could have come up with so many creative ideas for him to move.

Jayaprakashji is a very respected industrialist in Ahmedabad who is also an active member in school boards to encourage education.

The Govt could have sent him as India's representative to UN (New York or Europe) for girl child educational development. He could have been appointed as a Rajya Sabha member or an adviser to the Govt.

In these cases Nanaji might have had second thoughts of going as Sameer would have to move to Delhi and Sameer could have convinced him to go and assured him that he will try his best to build a relationship with his mother and others.

Atleast Sameer will have someone to fall back on and lean on, if his attempts failed.

Now Sameer has no option at all. And he has to undergo another round of bullying, abusing, slapping etc etc to prove his worth.

And really is it worthy to go through all this? Was the regressive way the only way the creative team could come up with?

Is there no production house in the country who can take it up as a challenge and not come up with regressive shows?

Originally posted by: canapoem

So true Nandy.

Why should a story always take a regressive track for the growth of a character.

Should Sameer be bullied, verbally abused, slapped, trashed, burnt to become a responsible person?

Should Nanaji be killed for Sameer to build a relationship with his mother and if possible other members of the family?

Infact 90s television shows used to be very progressive. Most of them say that it was Ekta Kapoor who ruined the Television industry. Maybe true.

I remember watching shows during 90s which were not only progressive but had so much depth and content in them.

If Sameer had to move to Delhi, then story writers could have come up with so many creative ideas for him to move.

Jayaprakashji is a very respected industrialist in Ahmedabad who is also an active member in school boards to encourage education.

The Govt could have sent him as India's representative to UN (New York or Europe) for girl child educational development. He could have been appointed as a Rajya Sabha member or an adviser to the Govt.

In these cases Nanaji might have had second thoughts of going as Sameer would have to move to Delhi and Sameer could have convinced him to go and assured him that he will try his best to build a relationship with his mother and others.

Atleast Sameer will have someone to fall back on and lean on, if his attempts failed.

Now Sameer has no option at all. And he has to undergo another round of bullying, abusing, slapping etc etc to prove his worth.

And really is it worthy to go through all this? Was the regressive way the only way the creative team could come up with?

Is there no production house in the country who can take it up as a challenge and not come up with regressive shows?

Originally posted by: KashafZaroon30

Nivi how could you write a post on this...Mera toh LU dete waqt hi bura haal tha...It was by far one of the best episodes...After a long time I cried in an episode..moist eyes many times but hardly cried...

And as they say Experience aakhir experience hota hai. Kiran Kumar and Vaishnavi McDonald proved it today...

Today the dialogue writer I felt was in some different world, all the scenes be it Nanu-Vishakha, Nanu-Sameer or Nanu-Vishakha-Sameer, were so well-written that they struck a chord with every viewer today...

The dialogue when Nanu says Vishakha tumhari zindagi savarne ke liye maine Sameer ko apni chhaaya mein rakha hai, just pierced my mind. It was like Nanu was his protector, protecting and shadowing him from all the evils of this world. As rightly said by you, what Vishakha was expected to do Nanu did all these years and now he expects and wishes Vishakha to love him like how he did.

Sameer mera guroor hai. Nanu indeed has been his friend, his brother, his guru and his mother all his life. Nanu cannot fathom his life without Sameer. Nanu now wants his Sameer to take up his responsibilites.

I agree Nivi, Naina not overtly worrying or missing Sam was nicely done. She was diverting her mind and enjoying with Preeti just like normal humans. This show thank God doesn't show diya bujhna and all. But today just like you I also felt and wanted full 21 mins of Nanu scenes.

Oh and one more thing, Naina was not there on his mind today and may be won't be there in Monday's episode. And I liked that. Usually movies and many TV shows show that whatever happens in life, their love-life is the thing on their mind always. But in reality when tragedy hits our family life, love-life is bound to be back seat. He is not in a state to think about Naina or his relation with her for now. Well done.

Anyway it was a very emotional ride for all of us. A very nicely made, subtle but impactful episode with wonderful performances. Nothing much to discuss today.

Precap: I don't want to think about it. I'm horribly confused, don't how will things wrap up in 2 days. Please CVs after impressing and raising our standards by giving such a power-packed and superb episode please don't dishearten us by forgetting logic.

Nivi love you for this🤗

Originally posted by: Infofan

Kiran ji thank you for breathing life into Nanu, one of the most loved characters on YUD. Those of us who lost our grandparents relived our moments with them through Jai Prakash Narayan Maheshwari. The bond you shared with Samundit brought a smile to our faces and warmed our hearts. Thank you for brightening our days. Thank you for all the beautiful memories.

R.I.P Nanu. You will be sorely missed. Kiran ji you will be sorely missed.

Life is unpredictable truly. Spend time with your loved ones and never ever go to bed or end a conversation with anyone in anger. Never ever hesitate to show your love to them. Say I love you often Kyunki kal ho na ho!

I try to be sanskari on the first page but today, if I may make an exception and speak my heart out Dear CVs, You added many dramatic elements, characters and events to the real life love story of Mittals. This is one aspect of Mittal's life that could have been easily skipped in the show. As CVs, I am sure you could find many ways to move the story forward and show character progression but you took the easy way out. What a bunch of sadistic morons! I had to actually see it to believe that Nanu is no more!

In asli duniya, Nanu's passing away in the show and its aftermath will be a painful walk down the memory lane for Mr. Mittal.

Nanu had the most beautiful dialogues today. His last words to Vishaka also were a message to Somani. Good he heard Nanu's last wishes. He was confusing though with his expressions for he seemed to be smirking one time and concerned another time even kept his hand on Sam and Vishaka briefly. Did we briefly see his humane side? Did he acknowledge Sam's smile is precious?

Will Vishaka be able to fulfill her father's last wish?

I had hoped Nanu would have a word or two with Mundit as well. They loved him as their own and he was fond of them too.

Yesterday I enjoyed the village scenes, today they were downright annoying. I wish they had added Samundit Nanu scenes as FB instead as you suggested. Yesterday I hoped they were dragging Nanu in hospital scene possibly to show him recover... well... but I am glad they didnt rush it. A character like Nanu deserved a proper send off.

BTW nobody looked at Preeti or Naina during the wedding track and now suddenly we have two dudes crushing on her?😕

At the moment don't want to think about Samaina or Sameer in Somani household. Dont really care and had enough of the darn symbolism and speculations!

Emotional episode, well enacted by everyone. I liked Randeep better in today's episode than yesterday's.

BTW was Somani wearing white pants? I don't get men who wear white pants!!😕

Thank you Nivi for this post and caps and giving us a place to discuss or rant🤗 ❤️

Originally posted by: rose1000

The makers could have kept it simple and effective like Hrishikesh Mukherjee movies. But they chose to go full fledged Bolly masala movie of 80s.

The separation could have happened without sending Naina to village and without killing Nanu. Nanu gets attack. Sameer takes him to Delhi. Naina would never have objected. Plus Nanu could have blessed Naina too.

Or my paper stealing truth theory was far better. I had said Sam would feel sad...sort of abhiman because Naina hid the truth. Sam goes away to Delhi. Naina depressed. Nanu, Mundit plan. Nanu pretends to be sick. Sam comes back...when I talked about this theory except a few, noone wanted the paper truth out. My suggestion was simple Hrishikesh Mukherjee types...but...

Also, Nanu could have passed away after Samaina marriage.

Someone pointed out yesterday CVs have changed...well the new CVs better be careful...making this show sadistic will not work.

I am simply tired of screaming about paper stealing...I have done for ever since it happened...but new CVs chose to ignore it. The incident that resulted in 6 months of the show is now forgotten. NO words...