Originally posted by: moumita04
Hey - What a wonderful topic you brought out for discussion...
It is said that:
"No love is greater than mom's love
No care is greater than dad's care"
Unfortunately, both of these are missing from Arjun & Naina's life...
Their mother's demise brought a void in their life that was fulfilled to an extent for both of them by Bela Chachi and Taiji... I know Taiji is like kadvi jubaan but still she has brought up Arjun and she even somewhat cares for Naina (remember the scene in ep11 when Naina pretended to be unconscious... Taiji was equally worried).
They have their father - an only parent whose love should ideally have been selfless, unconditional and forgiving... BUT... it's not. The reason behind this can be several and still left unexplored by the CVs... I have read several versions on this forum, below is my two cents -
-- It's 90s: Totally unrelatable reason because this could potentially cause him to differentiate / do partiality between girl and boy child... but not be so bitter towards his daughter
-- Because of the partiality he faced in his own life: Possible! But then this should have made him bitter towards his brothers and not towards his children
-- Because his wife died during Naina's birth: This is one reason that I just cannot digest at all... If he had been so much in love with his wife and so attached then he should be equally in love with the precious children that are a result of that love he shared with his wife. But not only he is not attached to them but only sees his son as a medium to fulfill his material requirements and earn him his share of pride in family & society... and as for his daughter she is just a liability to him, period.
So none of the above reasons are completely justifiable to me. As I see him on screen, he is just a complete jackass...
No conscience, no values, no independent thought process, no understanding of person / situation, no concern for anybody, no patience
He can be easily fooled (as proved by our dear Sammy).
Despite being a teacher he has a narrow vision, no ethics, no respect for others.
Sometimes he is shown to have a teeny-tiny bit of affection & pride & respect, but that is immediately overshadowed by his demeaning personality.
His reformation - Extremely tough to even think of it... But I see only one way - when his own children stand up to him and point out the decisions made by him / his actions that has influenced their own life in negative manner... That would probably make him think that as a father he has not really been successful.
-- He should have given them wings of dreams, instead he buckled his son with chain of expectations
-- He should have been a supporting wall for them to fall back on, instead he was a pillar of hatred
-- He should have been a guiding light, instead he was choking darkness
-- He should have been a hero leading by example, instead he only managed to teach his children what not to do as a parent