In your honest opinion, who/what is this show about post-leap? - Page 9

Poll

In your honest opinion, who/what is this show about post-leap?

Login To Vote

Created

Last reply

Replies

115

Views

7.4k

Users

29

Likes

331

Frequent Posters

-K.13- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#81

Originally posted by: -Nidoo-



I mean the least focus is on Raman in terms of both - progress of the storyline and character growth. He's the lead, so he's there, but neither has there been any focus on his PoVs, nor is the character given any meaty stuff to do. It is only because of the actor's nuanced performance that we can still see Raman as, well, Raman. Show wise - He's quite unnecessary 😛 Even Neelu gets monologues than him 😆


sorry my light bulb is a flickering today



I do agree though - to understand his POV, you have to read into the actor's expressions to find conflict, any POV he gives is riddled with something that's a turn off (ie choking ), he can't execute a plan all the way through & have it successful

But he is vital or important as a character in terms of the good sides of the story nor is he the main focus of the story in my opinion...but without Raman Kumar Bhalla...How would any track start? How would Shagun change shades? How would Ishita have to fight the world? How would there be MUs abound? Who would turn into a clown when he's sick for humor? How would cry buckets but take no action?

And most importantly...without Raman Kumar Bhalla, how would we get our (now sparse) lollipops 😆

In my opinion - Raman is just the nidus for drama and for other characters to soar from. He is the spark with no POV or follow up...but everyone else's POV can stem from his action easily.

For me, if Raman was who this show was about, then it would be clear what he feels, you could see how he thinks easily, and most importantly if he is the male lead or a hero of the show - he in theory should do a few lead worthy positive actions.

Which is why I asked for the 100+ people who voted for him as the main focus of the show to share their opinion. 😳
Edited by -K.13- - 9 years ago
Veeann thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#82

Originally posted by: gargpoo

u wrote ...which one?? Can u give me the link?? ..waise i hv read ur stories n i love those ...bt ye yaad nhi aa rahi.. 😳


Here you are. It's called Dooriyan


bscorp13 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#83

Originally posted by: -K.13-


sorry my light bulb is a flickering today



I do agree though - to understand his POV, you have to read into the actor's expressions to find conflict, any POV he gives is riddled with something that's a turn off (ie choking ), he can't execute a plan all the way through & have it successful

But he is vital or important as a character in terms of the good sides of the story nor is he the main focus of the story in my opinion...but without Raman Kumar Bhalla...How would any track start? How would Shagun change shades? How would Ishita have to fight the world? How would there be MUs abound? Who would turn into a clown when he's sick for humor? How would cry buckets but take no action?

And most importantly...without Raman Kumar Bhalla, how would we get our (now sparse) lollipops 😆

In my opinion - Raman is just the nidus for drama and for other characters to soar from. He is the spark with no POV or follow up...but everyone else's POV can stem from his action easily.

For me, if Raman was who this show was about, then it would be clear what he feels, you could see how he thinks easily, and most importantly if he is the male lead or a hero of the show - he in theory should do a few lead worthy positive actions.

Which is why I asked for the 100+ people who voted for him as the main focus of the show to share their opinion. 😳

Hahaha...this show is also about childishly pitting ishita vs raman even in a harmless poll...a simple look at spamming scores overnight will indicate. And not one soul of those 200 odd for both ishita or raman can claim aa to why thye feel this show focusses v on them post leap..but yup hardly or no one cares about ishra snymore.. at least that's what this poll made obviously clear. . Even for the sake of blind spamming😆

Btw i have been enlightened with lot of new yhm wisdom since yesterday. .btw question to you krishy, why is your option mani or raman...? When you have a seperate one for shagun and her shades and one for ishita vs shagun😕..doesn't the embodiment of goodness and best friend cum lover cum nextb in line after ms arora to hog most screen space post leap deserve a seperate mention?

Think about it. He gives very tough competition to shagun in terns of monologues, self talks, ishita's counselling, raman's counselling,Aliya's counseling, ruhis counselling, mihir's acchai discussioj, insecurity and jealousy discussion, tricking ashok, slapping nidhi...all done by him...so why this unfairness...😕...my fingers are itching to cast votes too na😉

Btwv in all seriousness. . Your poll made sense for tjhe first few hours.. and loved tjhe genuine comments on tjhe thread too..now it resembles any other war zone on this forum..most posts are anyways nowadays...it's sad even a neutral poll has to go through this 🥱...this is not a democracy by miles mate. ..more like a banana republic😆

priyadarshini.r thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#84
Welcome Back from your vacation Sri.🤗
Pb, I am waiting for the OS.

Nidoo, Vee - excellent takes.

Shagun changing shades wins hands down. 😆😆

@Krishy - I do not understand Raman getting so many votes. Because I feel Raman has been made useless, dumb, a spineless character post leap without any importance, only as a means to boost TRP with his romance. Yup of late, he is given dialogues to express his POV. But I still have that fear of how long, will he go back to the impulsive ever shouting mode again, constantly lingering at the back of my mind.😊

Anyways, good luck with your poll. 😆😆👍🏼

Edited by priyadarshini.r - 9 years ago
-K.13- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#85
At least the # of votes for Ishita and for Raman are equal 🤪

@Pb - I put Mani or Raman? b/c this idea of who is better - Mani or Raman is randomly put into the story at 2 junctions now...so it by no means is a part of the story from day 1 but post leap it has been. As a result I just didn't know how to frame it. 😕
Edited by -K.13- - 9 years ago
-Gan- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#86
Post leap it has all been about hair, sarees and blouse .. I had given up on yhm .. Came back post leap with the hope of reviving old chemistry .. Which whenever the cvs been meherban we got to witness but frankly the storytelling has become so disjointed it's hard to keep track of the story .. I only watch for Divan chemistry whenever we get a glimpse... There was lot of potential but I guess the Cvs have their priorities all bungled up ... So we talk more about blouses or lack there of than the characters.. And that's a shame as yhm has such deep talent pool..
Edited by -Gan- - 9 years ago
bscorp13 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#87

Originally posted by: -K.13-

At least the # of votes for Ishita and for Raman are equal 🤪


@Pb - I put Mani or Raman? b/c this idea of who is better - Mani or Raman is randomly put into the story at 2 junctions now...so it by no means is a part of the story from day 1 but post leap it has been. As a result I just didn't know how to frame it. 😕


I guess this is typical soap dynamics too na..FL vs vamp. .clear good vs evil..ML is a brute so have a knight in shining armour as a antithesis. ..so that aunties can get a clear loud idea aa to who to compare with and wish the FL was actually with. .aww what a great guy..Kash ishita bhi issee pyaar karti..kitna accha hota..usse bhi woh raman hi mila..ab kya karein bacchon ka sawaal hai..in Mr bhallas words in day befores epi..kya kya sehna padaa hai ishita ko...jabse raman uski zindagi mein aaya hai...anyways you get the drift l. .🥱..yest scene gave me tjhe feels too..it took more than a month for ishita and raman to make any headway with ruhi and here ..mani just used his wand .. and pronto...it was done. ..ishita was crying tears of happiness. .ruhi understood her... at least made a start...all that she couldn't understand when Raman was asking her again and again when ishita was kidnapped last week..he kept saying ruhi you know your ishimaa na.. she is strong..she will never let any harm cone to you. . She ell be back etc..all not needed na😕

Waise my soap viewer MILs comment...when mani and ruhis 15 min long scene aired. .oh..when will this guy stop talking..let me go fry papads for dinner till this scene ends😆
Tashfee thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#88
I personally feel that the CVs are confused about what Yeh Hai Mohabbatein is about. They show too much crap about Vandu,bala,shravan,alia,mani and shaguniya's mixed emotions.🤢 Shagun is a completely confused soul, at first when she got to know about Ishu from Pihu in Australia she was like Shagun The Detective😎 and she was searching for Ishu but by the time she returned back to India she was ready to become Raman's wife even after knowing what Ishita means to him.😡 She didn't even want her own daughter Ruhi to come back just because she knew that Ru is the base of Ishra's relationship. I totally could'nt belive it bc Ru is her own daughter and why would a moher want her daughter to be dead🤢. Well that kind of shows that the love she has for Pihu is just to show the family that how mahan she is. 😕Anyways when Ru returned home and even ishu did she started showing her insecurities by showing over the top bonding with pihu.🤢And then ishu got kidnapped she started showing how good she is and NOW FINALLY shagun's real colors will be exposed.😃 So I think Yeh Hai Mohabbatein is not about IshRaRu anymore its more about shagun's mahanta, sacrifices and insecurities.😕 But still even if there is a little of IshRa moments,😳 like the goons trouble and then putting putting rose water into her eyes and oh how can I forget puttar's great fall 🤣its a bliss to watch.

p.s. I really miss the old YHM😭... Hae kya din the IshRa's cute nokjhoks and mohabbatein😳 and IshRu's ishima-ruhi scenes😳which could literally make me cry... 😭
-K.13- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#89

Originally posted by: -Gan-

Post leap it has all been about hair, sarees and blouse .. I had given up on yhm .. Came back post leap with the hope of reviving old chemistry .. Which whenever the cvs been meherban we got to witness but frankly the storytelling has become so disjointed it's hard to keep track of the story .. I only watch for Divan chemistry whenever we get a glimpse... There was lot of potential but I guess the Cvs have their priorities all bungled up ... So we talk more about blouses or lack there of than the characters.. And that's a shame as yhm has such deep talent pool..


Yeppers, Gan! An awesome chance to revitalize IshRa and take away the "Sirf __ ke Liye" tag and make it officially "Sirf Ek Duje Ke Liye" has been lost thanks to these CVs, and I will confidently say even TRP viewers would've enjoyed that track had the CVs executed it b/c it had all the angst, third parties, drama, and MUs they love while focusing on what we love - IshRa.

Shagun is here to stay - we've known this...but the promising (minus a few big things) post leap track was literally botched to speed this shade change nonsense. Very reminiscent of magical pregnancy and the subsequent surrogacy track meant to show the first shade change.

I watch 95% of the episodes over the last 4 weeks and even I can't tell what's head or tail with the story and I even watched and could remotely follow Subbu kaand and bhoot track 🤪
-K.13- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#90

Originally posted by: bscorp13


I guess this is typical soap dynamics too na..FL vs vamp. .clear good vs evil..ML is a brute so have a knight in shining armour as a antithesis. ..so that aunties can get a clear loud idea aa to who to compare with and wish the FL was actually with. .aww what a great guy..Kash ishita bhi issee pyaar karti..kitna accha hota..usse bhi woh raman hi mila..ab kya karein bacchon ka sawaal hai..in Mr bhallas words in day befores epi..kya kya sehna padaa hai ishita ko...jabse raman uski zindagi mein aaya hai...anyways you get the drift l. .🥱..yest scene gave me tjhe feels too..it took more than a month for ishita and raman to make any headway with ruhi and here ..mani just used his wand .. and pronto...it was done. ..ishita was crying tears of happiness. .ruhi understood her... at least made a start...all that she couldn't understand when Raman was asking her again and again when ishita was kidnapped last week..he kept saying ruhi you know your ishimaa na.. she is strong..she will never let any harm cone to you. . She ell be back etc..all not needed na😕

Waise my soap viewer MILs comment...when mani and ruhis 15 min long scene aired. .oh..when will this guy stop talking..let me go fry papads for dinner till this scene ends😆


I do get your drift totally and while usually nowadays I can get over it...it still stings a little

B/c totally forgetting Raman, I believe that Ruhi's hurt and Ishita's hurt in their relationship deserved a better near-end. But that's just me

Related Topics

Ye Hai Mohabbatein Thumbnail

Posted by: Manan_Pani_fan

9 months ago

Divyangana Jain joins DT and KP in Ekta Kapoor’s new show for Sony TV

Exclusive: Udti Ka Naam Rajjo fame Divyangana Jain joins Divyanka Tripathi and Karan Patel in Ekta Kapoor’s new show for Sony TV Divyangana Jain...

Expand ▼
Ye Hai Mohabbatein Thumbnail

Posted by: Manan_Pani_fan

10 months ago

Divyanka & Karan are set to REUNITE for Ekta's next show on Sony TV! Divyanka & Karan are set to REUNITE for Ekta's next show on Sony TV!

#DivyankaTripathi and #KaranPatel are set to REUNITE for Ekta Kapoor's next show on Sony TV!

Expand ▼
Ye Hai Mohabbatein Thumbnail

Posted by: Manan_Pani_fan

8 months ago

Karan Patel and Divyanka Tripathi BOTH NOT part of Sony TV show

Exclusive:; Harshad Chopda and Shivangi Joshi likely to play leads The Sony TV show produced by Balaji Telefilms has seen major developments...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".