Created

Last reply

Replies

56

Views

9.2k

Users

33

Likes

442

Frequent Posters

-Anku- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: rose1000



Thanks Anku. There is a reason I directed my question to you. Because I know you are unbiased Ishra fan who backs up her answers with good reasoning.

See I can understand all you said about Pihu. And so I did not ask about that. My question was...why take Ishu to PTA meeting at all when the matter is not related to Ruhi at all...and then telling Ishita not to get attached...when he himself is involving her...Well I guess it is shoddy writing at best...Ekta should really get better writers who can give script with some consistency...😊


When he said there's a meeting and both parents have to be there, IshRa shared a look and that look said loud and clear - both the parents were right there. But that's not something they've yet faced, that's something they don't have the guts to face amidst all that's happening right now. But that look shared, his request and her quick nod was not shoddy writing... It was them subconsciously doing something for Pihu they would have in normal circumstances.

Him taking her there is an impulsive decision of involving her in his life but when the involvement raises hopes he crushes them himself... Isn't that how Raman has ALWAYS been? Hot and cold? He used to do that prior leap, in the first year of this show. There would be a sweet moment between the two in the night and morning would be back to square one. He did that because his brain stopped his heart from going with the flow of falling in love. And to cover up for falling weak he would shout at Ishita...Here he's scared to hope they can have that life again because so far they've both assumed they will go back to routine...and that is what he said (which again I am only guessing because we don't have the exact context) Hot and cold was going to be rehashed like everything else has been.

I don't believe this is shoddy writing though, because it's just like how Raman has been (not that it makes his behavior right...it's just the fabric of his character)

Maybe I over discussing or over analyzing...but some episodes do that to me 😆
snehaseshan thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#32
Yes wat Raman told is d reality according to wat both had decided but if he is so clear he shouldn't HVE involved ishita in pihu's matter that's his mistake if he knows the reality y to involve her in matter where she may get emotionally attached but can't b d reality, pihu is also her daughter he shud HVE known that his act of him taking her as a proxy mom wud hurt her badly.. This was like using her for a purpose n then telling her subtly that don't take ur own meaning abt this,it is just temporary.. That is like playing with her feelings which is wrong he shud involved ishita only in ruhi's matter n kept her away from d rest..
momb24 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: snehaseshan

Raman said that "ishita peaceful feeling se accha Lagne SE sachchaayi nahi badal jaati hai naa so inn chotte chotte cheezon SE apni mann mutabik matlab nikaalke don't try to pacify urself jo kuch kar rahe hain Ruhi keliye kar rahe hain uske baad tum ausssie chali jaogi aur mein apni Roz marra ki zindagi mein lag jaunga toh ye bache kuche theiis (24)din aaraam SE guzaar lo zyada sochogi dil lagaogi dil tootega takleef hogi"


English translation:

So he is saying ishita feeling nice & peaceful doesn't change the reality don't take ur own meanings from the small small things that r happening & pacify urself we r doing this for Ruhi after that u wil go back to Aussie n i'll b back to my daily life So live these 24 days peacefully don't get attached so much,ur heart wil break n u wil get hurt..


It is difficult to understand raman as his actions and words don't match all the time.
It feels like his reminding himself it's only for ruhi ke liye and his heart will break and he'll get hurt. I don't even understand the monologues they gifted us when he decided to marry shagun. They justified nothing.
Edited by momb24 - 9 years ago
Ramyalaxmi thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#34
Is this precap scene before or after Ishu introduce herself as massi to pihu's teacher (olv)?
Zoyamalik2005 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: -Anku-


When he said there's a meeting and both parents have to be there, IshRa shared a look and that look said loud and clear - both the parents were right there. But that's not something they've yet faced, that's something they don't have the guts to face amidst all that's happening right now. But that look shared, his request and her quick nod was not shoddy writing... It was them subconsciously doing something for Pihu they would have in normal circumstances.

Him taking her there is an impulsive decision of involving her in his life but when the involvement raises hopes he crushes them himself... Isn't that how Raman has ALWAYS been? Hot and cold? He used to do that prior leap, in the first year of this show. There would be a sweet moment between the two in the night and morning would be back to square one. He did that because his brain stopped his heart from going with the flow of falling in love. And to cover up for falling weak he would shout at Ishita...Here he's scared to hope they can have that life again because so far they've both assumed they will go back to routine...and that is what he said (which again I am only guessing because we don't have the exact context) Hot and cold was going to be rehashed like everything else has been.

I don't believe this is shoddy writing though, because it's just like how Raman has been (not that it makes his behavior right...it's just the fabric of his character)

Maybe I over discussing or over analyzing...but some episodes do that to me 😆

WORD anku.
sarsyed thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: annvi

logically speaking...i don't know why neither of them are thinking about Pihu...
Ishita australia jaaye ya na jaaye...Pihu aur Ishita dono haq hai janne keliye..

pehle alag tha...sab ko Ishita margaya laga so Pihu ko nahi bataya...
ab to batane ke baare mein soch na he na...



None seem to be interested in that part.
Pihu is well versed in such matters thanks to her knowledge of saajan ka sasural it shouldn't be a big thing for her to know that ishita's her mom.

The families too seem too be unaffected by it..what follows whether pihu accepts or not is secondary she knowing the truth is of major concern and u guess this is just being pushed to accommodate the sautan drama
Ramyalaxmi thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#37
It doesn't seem to be appropriate dialogue after witnessing her massi confession.😕
DiVan_ thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#38
🤣
Edited by -Awara- - 9 years ago
-Anku- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: -AngryBird-



Word. Thats what I feel. More than the words to Ishita. He is reminding himself not to hope again when she didn't come back in these 7 years. So, how can she be back to him in these 20 days? He thinks she has moved on. On the other hand, Ishita will think he doesn't needs her back in his life.


Yes, these are the results of the various misunderstandings they have, because they fail to communicate. They get swayed by their love, and by how they unintentionally react in each other's presence but when reality hits they both think the other wouldn't want them back.
sindhu.kashyup thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#40
Raman's character is very inconsistent in the show especially post leap . At starting of today's episode he said "Agar aisa hi chalta raha tho sab kuch pehle jaise hojayega " and in precap he said its only a matter of 20days. wo tho pagal hi hai viewers ko bhi pagal banaraha hai "Raman is himself a big confused soul"😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".