_symphony thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
Hello people. I am back here almost after ages. Had stopped watching YHM long back but the leap somehow managed to get me back. I am kinda finding new characters quite intresting. But one thing which I found very confusing is why the hell everybody is so sympathetic towards Ishita and angry towards Raman? 🤔

I watched the past few epis and found that actually it was Ishu who lied to the family for the whole 7 years and made them beleive that she is dead. 🤢 I mean may be Raman was equally or even more responsible for losing Ruhi than Ishita and he putting the blame of Ruhi's death on Ishu is very wrong but did that give Ishu the right to leave her kids, her families like this?? She tried to commit suicide because she somewhere felt burdened of Ruhi's death (though she wasnt at fault) but strangely she forgot all that wen she chose to move with Mani and let Raman and her kids beleive that she died? She didnt even realize that even if raman was angry on her or asked her to move out that didnt break her relationship from Adi and her newborn kid. She didn't realize how would he bring them up alone? Even if she would have stayed away from Raman as he wanted but atleast her kids wont have suffered. And she actually let Raman's momentory anger/disgust (which was pretty obvious in the situation) make her believe that he or his family wont be affected if she died. I mean how stupid is that? For 7 years she didn't try to know how her family or her kids were doing w/o her. What if Raman did this? What if he left her all alone and made her live the life of a widow all by herself. '

I don't understand why Raman is expected to accept Ishita so easily? What he is doing is much justified from his perspective. As for him being violent to Adi thats something I surely don't agree of but as for Ishita I really feel he is not wrong. He must take his sweet time to make her realize what he went through all those years. Atleast she had the solace that Raman is alive. He didnt even have that. He dint know whether to love her or hate her...he didnt know whether to miss her or be angry on her. He just didnt know what to feel for her that actually amde him like this.
Edited by Malika - 9 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

4

Views

601

Users

5

Likes

9

Frequent Posters

MyLoveSuVa thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Its a grey matter! Ishita has always thought of others, always protected others even if it meant hurting herself. I think she was just completely SHATTERED after what happened to ruhi. She didnt have enough energy to go back and face raman taunts, even if it meant loosing Adi and her newborn kid. NO ONE was there to stop her from suicide or protect her or care for her.
And Raman is Raman, they have ALWAYS showed him this agress and angry, taking irrational decision. I thought ppl would have accepted that by now! Thats his personality!! if suddenly turned into RAM it wouldnt be the same. Raman has every right to be mad at ishu, but shouldnt treat her this way.


But these two different personalties of Ishita and Raman is what makes IshRa!
GBSC thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
I agree to raman's feelings in totality.
But a small info,for those who do not know about recovering from suicidal activities.
A psychiatrist's first diagnosis would be the cause and prevention of recurrence of that tendency.
Their advice to that patient and their partner would be to stay away from negative thoughts and most importantly the ppl who caused it.Until that patient is mentally strong enough to face the same ppl again,the patient will be repeatedly adviced against it,as the patient might go into depression again.
As depression has a tendency to come back 100%.
I will defend Ishu here.
Pl don't take depression easily.
It is a silent killer.
FunnyBreeze thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
Ishu left bcoz according to her she came to the Bhalla family as Ruhi's Ishima...and she loved Ruhi more than anything.. So she was shattered by her death and at that time noone was there for her...so she left that no one is happy coz of her and she decided to end her lyf...
And den coming to her living with mani...itz bcoz she had to take care of him as he lost his legs or sumthng like that while saving Ishu from committing suicide... And since no one cared for her she thought itz better to move far away from their life so that atlest they can b happy...still she says that no one is happy coz of her...I mean with her coming back to India...
Den Raman!! I won't completely say he is arrogant...he is right on his part...he still loves ishu.. Bt I think there is a mu that mani and ishu are married like the same way ishu thought of Sharam... But CVS are killing Raman's character by making him tooo aggressive for his children ... And he is being partial too... I mean.. He always do what pihu wants bt nevr cares for adi... He can't just slap him everytime...
sunitas123 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
Raman can be angry, but he is always to blame for his actions. He thinks he can keep throwing shit and Ishita should take it? He did not realize that Ishita has lost her child too! Not just that he still blames only her for Ruhi's death, so I have no sympathies for a coward like Raman.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".