Have the CVs Desecrated 'IshRa' for Good? - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

72

Views

5.7k

Users

25

Likes

207

Frequent Posters

--Megha-- thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#31
For me they had already butchered Ishra long ago, but still as u said this is the finalNail in the coffin. Whichever way they go (seperation or not) Ishra relationship has been heavily compromised.

I guess I started losing connect with Raman character manhandling incident and Dafa Hojao etc. everytime I wud put myself in shoes of Ishita n how wud I react if such a situation happened n the way CVs ended those tracks either in a joke or Romance left a bad taste in my mouth.

Similarly when Ishita ran away with Ruhi. Whatever justification was given was not good enough for me coz again if I keep myself in shoes f Raman then irrespective of how bad a parent I am, I wud expect some answers from my spouse for running away with my child n having no trust on me. Again we never really got ISHRA's POV at the end of that track as to how Raman screwed up with papers n how Ishita panicked.

When CVs themselves do not end tracks giving a logical ending with respect to that track, I started losing my Interest with Ishra.

I am not sure what they will do with this track but seriously speaking I have No Hopes either.
-Vishakha- thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#32
Nice post

Finally long awaited separation happening. Lol

Ok im one of those who thought ishita raman don't deserve each other from mani track itself Lol
they were dead for since mani track.
many ppl like me who didn't like mani track hv stopped watching this show long back

So its almost one yr to that! Things hv nt changed he he he.

Honestly I hv watched couple of daily shows nd ishra r definitely the worst couple.
The actors do hv gr8 chemistry on-screen but story wise they r pathetic. This im not saying only becoz of surrogacy track. This what I felt since mani track
From realisation to consummation everything was pathetic. Everything just ruhi ke liye No communication between them. No trust

It would hv been better if raman would hv left to Singapore.

Ishita with ruhi nd mani
Shagun with adi
Raman alone.


Vaise Do you seriously think ishra separation is permanent?!
This is an ek show
The way mu started I guess ishita will be happy after she knows baby was born out of surrogacy n its not sharam ka baby Lol

Cold storage then shagun getting pregnant all this point towards this kinda track

After leap misunderstanding will cleared they will back together. Shagun will turn black bas.

Only twist is how will ishita leave ruhi(as trp audience will nor like it!) kyunki obviously shadi toh ruhi ke liye hi ki thi so I feel cvs will not show ishita leaving raman as ruhi toh raman ke saath hi milegi ...lol
I guess she will be blamed for rinky death nd ishita will be thrown out of house ha ha ha

Trp audience like when women is shown like some duniya ki sabse badi bechari toh this kinda track will fetch them more trps..

Then after leap wen ishita comes back clean...trp audience will love Watching everyone apologizing ishita.
Then again mu cycle continues.


Only msg one gets through this show that is never marry "sirf ruhi ke liye" ha haha such marriages end up like this... 😆
pomegranate thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#33
This is the point of no return. Everything else was somewhat redeemable but this is the final nail in the coffin, whether CV's agree or not.

As an audience, I gave up on this show a long time ago. Divyanka and Karan's acting prowess or chemistry were no longer a reason to stay back. Both individuals and couples were contorted so they can fit the new 7pm mould. Once there was a topic on this forum that claimed Ishra was the worst couple on tv, and while I don't think that is entirely true, it cannot be denied that Raman and ishita are not a good couple, nor are they a healthy couple. I started noticing this a while ago hence decided that I cannot root or support them despite the amazing chemistry. it was always up and down for them, such a rocky relationship was never ok to begin with. in addition, Ishita never reacted strongly to anything, which then turned her into a spineless woman and created an illusion of an admirable couple in front of the audience. this is why I quit the show and stopped fangirling over ishra, which is why I'm not mourning this show and I'm glad that i was not one of those viewers who were living in an utopia. Ishra started going downhill long ago, this is not the 11 pm YHM and it won't get better. This is a balaji soap that has given Star plus a lot of money and as a result, writers will unleash insanity just to keep the cash flowing. it's all business for them, and emotions for us.



This is the end of ishra, But rest assured that writers will find a quick fix. ishita may be angry initially, but will come around and THANK raman for being so thoughtful, she will realize how much raman loves her or what a big sacrifice shagun has made. Ishita reacting strongly or even leaving him will lessen the chances of a redemption/reunion. The temporary seperation my be initiated by ishita assuming that Shagun's pregnancy is a result of whatever "happened" in the cold storage but they will be back together after the leap once she knows the baby is actually her and raman's. Therefore completely glossing over Raman betraying her in such a inhuman manner. If ishita get violently angry about the surrogacy then how will they get back together? there is no way to recover from that, so CV's may not even show a strong reaction. Writers does not have a balls to handle deep human emotions, so of course they will choose the most convenient route, or the route that requires less brain power. so it will be a quick fix and it will look as if the conflict was a small one, and we were just over reacting. although, even writers know that they have created a gigantic mess that can never be cleaned up.




Edited by pomegranate - 10 years ago
-K.13- thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: sidivyapall


I honestly may enjoy watching the show if they focused on their lives separately... like an actual separation period, considering/pending divorce. it actually would make me sick to the stomach to see Ishita still living under the same roof as Raman, when (and if?) she finds out the whole truth.

The children are the ones to suffer with no fault of theirs... and that makes me very angry. But, I would rather they see a strong, independent woman in their mother rather than what I fear the show will show...
I'm talking about the FL solely because I absolutely cannot relate to the ML at this moment in time... so I have nothing to say for Raman.

I should have just quit in January... curse my optimism and hopefulness. 😆


@bold is a selling point because I do believe viewers will relate to Ishita moving on. I think even TRP viewers just disregard Raman now (or so people have mentioned in various places) but they do expect an eventual reunion.

For the kids - it hurts that in YHM Season 3 - the paternal influence is tainted for viewers and I don't find that fair to fathers anywhere b/c Raman has been a flawed but good father. But this track negates it all.

The last full episode I saw was 8/17/15 (b/c I'm slow & behind) so for me Raman is still intact. I don't think I'll watch past the family track to keep my image of my favorite male lead.

Because while I can't relate to him, I do still feel for him even while reading the LU b/c I can't just shut off the connection I had to that character. On the same hand though - I can relate to Ishita so I can't help but want a separation. But on the other hand - the "IshRa" fan in me just hurts.
EkPaheli thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#35
Krishy Desecrated is too small a word in my opinion for what they have done here

Honestly I feel disillusioned with the show as a whole and moreso with Raman specifically. How can a man who claims to love his wife not see what he is doing here

Really how can he even think that this child would make Ishita happy, why has he never tried to put himself in her shoes for once

Was the guilt so much that it drowned his rationality too?


I feel for Ishita like never before in this track and I hope that they should show what a woman feels when betrayed this enormously - Ishita has never cracked before but I hope to god that this breaks her - I want this woman to become depressed and suicidal or just go into her shell and Raman to witness every damn second of it because you know what seperation would be easy - it would be simple and it would be merciful.


Rather he should be inflicted with the very pain that he is giving Ishita twice as much and nothing can do that better than making him watch as she suffers and bleeds but refuses to come out of it and especially to him...she should be in front of him but miles away from him - physically not an inch away but mentally and emotionally so far that there cannot be a measurement to how much space exists between them

EkPaheli thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#36
Frankly if they do show them heading for a divorce even if it doesnt happen I want Ishita to turn cold towards him and even the family including the children - because of course they are his...as he always keeps on saying and since she is not their mother in his mind because she didnt give them birth.

I want Raman to actually see what he has done in this blind obsession


I still dont trust Shagun and feel she will show her true colors at some point...which may happen with this pregnancy, she can disappear with the kid or may refuse to give it or even outright lie to Ishita that yes it is her and Raman' child she is carrying once again...she won, has Raman given that a thought?
--Megha-- thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: pomegranate

This is the point of no return. Everything else was somewhat redeemable but this is the final nail in the coffin, whether CV's agree or not.

As an audience, I gave up on this show a long time ago. Divyanka and Karan's acting prowess or chemistry were no longer a reason to stay back. Both individuals and couples were contorted so they can fit the new 7pm mould. Once there was a topic on this forum that claimed Ishra was the worst couple on tv, and while I don't think that is entirely true, it cannot be denied that Raman and ishita are not a good couple, nor are they a healthy couple. I started noticing this a while ago hence decided that I cannot root or support them despite the amazing chemistry. it was always up and down for them, such a rocky relationship was never ok to begin with. in addition, Ishita never reacted strongly to anything, which then turned her into a spineless woman and created an illusion of an admirable couple in front of the audience. this is why I quit the show and stopped fangirling over ishra, this decision stopped me from crying buckets of tears today, and I'm glad that i was not one of those viewers who were living in an utopia. Ishra started going downhill long ago, this is not the 11 pm YHM and it won't get better. This is a balaji soap that has given Star plus a lot of money as a result, they will bring in inane twists just to keep the cash flowing. it's all business for them, and emotions for us.



This is the end of ishra, But rest assured that writers will find a quick fix. ishita may be angry initially, but will come around and THANK raman for being so thoughtful, she will realize how much raman loves her or what a big sacrifice shagun has made. Ishita reacting strongly or even leaving him will lessen the chances of a redemption/reunion. The temporary seperation my be initiated by ishita assuming that Shagun's pregnancy is a result of whatever "happened" in the cold storage but they will be back together after the leap once she knows the baby is actually her and raman's. Therefore completely glossing over Raman betraying her in such a inhuman manner. If ishita get violently angry about the surrogacy then how will they get back together? there is no way to recover from that, so CV's may not even show a strong reaction. Writers does not have a balls to handle deep human emotions, so of course they will choose the most convenient route, or the route that requires less brain power. so it will be a quick fix and it will look as if the conflict was a small one, and we were just over reacting. although, even writers know that they have created a gigantic mess that can never be cleaned up.







@Bold- exactly my feelings.

Even if Ishra seperate is it worth it? They wud simply show them coming together after leap/seperation (if that is what thry have planned).
They might just show us that all Ishita's misunderstandings are cleared n she is ok with Raman cheating on her with surrogacy issue coz ultimately they are the leads, they have to be together if not now then in the end for sure. 😕

But honestly speaking if some couple does that in real life then their relationship wud end in divorce with so much of hiding n doing things behind one's back while involving ur Ex.
SurabhiA91 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#38

Originally posted by: EkPaheli

Krishy Desecrated is too small a word in my opinion for what they have done here

Honestly I feel disillusioned with the show as a whole and moreso with Raman specifically. How can a man who claims to love his wife not see what he is doing here

Really how can he even think that this child would make Ishita happy, why has he never tried to put himself in her shoes for once

Was the guilt so much that it drowned his rationality too?


I feel for Ishita like never before in this track and I hope that they should show what a woman feels when betrayed this enormously - Ishita has never cracked before but I hope to god that this breaks her - I want this woman to become depressed and suicidal or just go into her shell and Raman to witness every damn second of it because you know what seperation would be easy - it would be simple and it would be merciful.


Rather he should be inflicted with the very pain that he is giving Ishita twice as much and nothing can do that better than making him watch as she suffers and bleeds but refuses to come out of it and especially to him...she should be in front of him but miles away from him - physically not an inch away but mentally and emotionally so far that there cannot be a measurement to how much space exists between them


I so wish it happens this way but as you know cvs never think of doing anything logical so no point in keeping hopes they are going to traditional BT way of MU and seperation and drag it till the time shagun again turns black and end up wanting to kill ishita
-K.13- thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: -Vishakha-

Nice post

Finally long awaited separation happening. Lol

Ok im one of those who thought ishita raman don't deserve each other from mani track itself Lol
they were dead for since mani track.
many ppl like me who didn't like mani track hv stopped watching this show long back

So its almost one yr to that! Things hv nt changed he he he.

Honestly I hv watched couple of daily shows nd ishra r definitely the worst couple.
The actors do hv gr8 chemistry on-screen but story wise they r pathetic. This im not saying only becoz of surrogacy track. This what I felt since mani track
From realisation to consummation everything was pathetic. Everything just ruhi ke liye No communication between them. No trust

It would hv been better if raman would hv left to Singapore.

Ishita with ruhi nd mani
Shagun with adi
Raman alone.


Vaise Do you seriously think ishra separation is permanent?!
This is an ek show
The way mu started I guess ishita will be happy after she knows baby was born out of surrogacy n its not sharam ka baby Lol

Cold storage then shagun getting pregnant all this point towards this kinda track

After leap misunderstanding will cleared they will back together. Shagun will turn black bas.

Only twist is how will ishita leave ruhi(as trp audience will nor like it!) kyunki obviously shadi toh ruhi ke liye hi ki thi so I feel cvs will not show ishita leaving raman as ruhi toh raman ke saath hi milegi ...lol
I guess she will be blamed for rinky death nd ishita will be thrown out of house ha ha ha

Trp audience like when women is shown like some duniya ki sabse badi bechari toh this kinda track will fetch them more trps..

Then after leap wen ishita comes back clean...trp audience will love Watching everyone apologizing ishita.
Then again mu cycle continues.


Only msg one gets through this show that is never marry "sirf ruhi ke liye" ha haha such marriages end up like this... 😆


You know - I've come to realize everyone had different points of no return. I noticed cracks post-slot change, but the didn't seem too big. Then the CVs cleverly mixed in TRP drama & small throwbacks to old, intentional YHM...so I could cope. But now they've given up fully.

About the stereotypical set up of the post leap scenario - I think that's very likely given YHM doesn't have anything to set them apart.

Indian TV does have a history of having paradoxical FLs and equally lackluster female vamps. Stereotypes make easy TRP catches.

I don't know (or care anymore) of how the separation will happen - as a viewer guided by my personal conscious, I would want to see it being her standing up for herself and her sense of womanhood, but the CVs may just use Rinki's death as the catalyst. 😕
-kri- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
#40

Originally posted by: EkPaheli

Frankly if they do show them heading for a divorce even if it doesnt happen I want Ishita to turn cold towards him and even the family including the children - because of course they are his...as he always keeps on saying and since she is not their mother in his mind because she didnt give them birth.

I want Raman to actually see what he has done in this blind obsession


I still dont trust Shagun and feel she will show her true colors at some point...which may happen with this pregnancy, she can disappear with the kid or may refuse to give it or even outright lie to Ishita that yes it is her and Raman' child she is carrying once again...she won, has Raman given that a thought?


Aani...come on. Don't talk about Saint Shagun like that. Even the holy Ganges can't help you get rid of this sin. Ek character ke liye soap ka khoon bhi maaf jab voh character Shagun ho.


SIck people want viewers to fight for it forever. As though it means nothing to them.

Related Topics

Ye Hai Mohabbatein thumbnail

Posted by: ChanChanMan · 4 years ago

I dare you to post a thing about anyone other than DivAn.

Expand ▼
Ye Hai Mohabbatein thumbnail

Posted by: Devanshi14 · 7 months ago

Chapter # 01 Title: “Pehli Baar Ishq Hua” Raman and Ishita had been married for months now—contractually, yes—but slowly, silently, love had...

Expand ▼
Ye Hai Mohabbatein thumbnail

Posted by: Im_sherlock · 7 months ago

It was one of those rare calm nights in Delhi, the kind that carried a soft breeze, the scent of blooming mogra, and a strange kind of silence...

Expand ▼
Ye Hai Mohabbatein thumbnail

Posted by: Im_sherlock · 8 months ago

On the show, we all know how Raman tried to give hints to Ishita about his feelings and desires, by keeping a box of condoms in her drawer. An...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".