Have the CVs Desecrated 'IshRa' for Good? - Page 3

Originally posted by: Neetz

It sure is yaar. And I have this sick feeling that maybe just maybe they will butcher Ishita too. Because snow white needs to shine and stand out na.
I don't if she will take a stand considering the history. They always end up with comedy or lollipop romance. They have never had a meaningful conversation. Almost never. Serious communication problems as you already know. They will bicker away but rarely address the elephant in the room. It took me very long to forget the incident after the fire. What he was about to do we all know. And its better i dont say anything about how it ended. More than Raman I was angry at Ishita for just letting it go. This time it's so needed. There has to be anger and hurt waiting to spill over. All the baggage I mean. I fail to understand how they can show a woman just getting over it. She needs to lash out for the viewer's sanity atleast. Lol
They have always made Raman commit bigger and graver kaands than Ishita. Why oh why?

I have loved these 2 hopelessly Krishy. At this point I don't know if I want them to get back together later cz they gave butchered their love. I think about it and all I wanna do is punch someone.

Originally posted by: Neetz

It sure is yaar. And I have this sick feeling that maybe just maybe they will butcher Ishita too. Because snow white needs to shine and stand out na.
I don't if she will take a stand considering the history. They always end up with comedy or lollipop romance. They have never had a meaningful conversation. Almost never. Serious communication problems as you already know. They will bicker away but rarely address the elephant in the room. It took me very long to forget the incident after the fire. What he was about to do we all know. And its better i dont say anything about how it ended. More than Raman I was angry at Ishita for just letting it go. This time it's so needed. There has to be anger and hurt waiting to spill over. All the baggage I mean. I fail to understand how they can show a woman just getting over it. She needs to lash out for the viewer's sanity atleast. Lol
They have always made Raman commit bigger and graver kaands than Ishita. Why oh why?

I have loved these 2 hopelessly Krishy. At this point I don't know if I want them to get back together later cz they gave butchered their love. I think about it and all I wanna do is punch someone.

Originally posted by: Mreddy

Mourning the loss of this once lovely fictional couple. I don't feel like seeing them together on the screen anymore. The magic is truly dead for me. Maybe this is what the makers wanted to achieve so that they can slowly kindle the other non existent spark. Fell in love with both these characters

But now even actors acting prowess will not be enough. Not sure if I will ever be able to empathize with him anymore. What a debacle. No words can even do justice to this crap. Hope ishita takes a strong stand..

Originally posted by: Neetz

Also I don't think they have yet realized the damage they have done. Once they do which I hope is very soon, it will hit them hard and I wish it hits so so bad that they can never recover from it. Serves them right.
I think they mixed it up It was supposed to be Rishta naya soch wahi not the other way round. The mentally sick people.

Originally posted by: Mreddy

Mourning the loss of this once lovely fictional couple. I don't feel like seeing them together on the screen anymore. The magic is truly dead for me. Maybe this is what the makers wanted to achieve so that they can slowly kindle the other non existent spark. Fell in love with both these characters

But now even actors acting prowess will not be enough. Not sure if I will ever be able to empathize with him anymore. What a debacle. No words can even do justice to this crap. Hope ishita takes a strong stand..

Originally posted by: Boo2014

Totally agree with you. Its hard see what is transpiring before our eyes.

I have no doubt in my mind that Ishra are very deeply in love but now we are seeing the cracks. Previously, they have both made mistakes because of their love for one another, primarily hiding problems etc all to prevent the other being hurt. What Raman has done from the moment he had the surrogacy agreement signed, has unfortunately been unforgivable for me. I did not like the fact that so soon after the miscarriage he was pressurising Ishita to agree to the surrogacy. He has become a man obsessed and no one not even his wife can stand in his way. He keeps saying the baby is for Ishita, I am no longer buying it. In fact, this baby is Raman and Shagun's third child.

The events over the last few days have not destroyed Ishra completely for me, but it has changed the way I look at their relationship. Many times we have heard various characters in the show commenting on Ishra's love/relationship as being an example of how a marriage should be. Yes, initially I could see why that was the case, but today, I am questioning whether their love is an example to aspire to or just flawed and unhealthy. Ishra love relationship will never be the same for me and I am certain after the separation they will get back together but for me their love is forever tarnished.

If Raman ends up in any type of relationship with Shagun I will be disgusted. I personally do not think this will go down well with TRP aunties. People can't relate to Shagun nor do they trust her intentions as we know just how manipulative she can be. Whilst watching a daytime repeat of YHM, my mother asked me 'how can someone's character change so much ... she can't be trusted'. TRP aunties will always favour Ishita over Shagun and that is not something BT or Star Plus can change. Whether they choose to ignore this and and make Anita a parallel lead (in every single episode) is obviously their decision.

I had just wished SP spent more time trying to improving their other shows rather than destroying one show that was bringing in reasonably good TRP's and money.

Sorry for any errors.

Originally posted by: -K.13-

There has been no spark this week. Even from the LU, I can't feel it...before even a line of Ishita & Raman's love for each other brought a smile to my face. But now...idk.

It does - desi TV standards are actually horrible for both the FLs & MLs.

FL: she's aadarsh, self-sacrificing, loyal to their main love, often compromise their self-respect, but they are always right in their actions...rare mistakes will happen but they will be justified by the reasoning for the error.

ML: he's a lost soul who comes to rely on his spouse. either he makes mistakes or small slip ups (in non-YHM shows) but the mess will be cleaned up usually by the spouse or they become wallflowers. rarely do they experience a gamut of emotions on screen (baring YHM where the ML cries more than the FL 😆).

I'm missing stuff on this analysis of leads in Indian shows, but as a whole many shows some how adopts this weirdly contrived societal view of gender expectations.

--

Logically and to be truly fair, this show needs to move from the journey of a two individuals coming together to the journey of their lives separately. But what sucks is - what about the kids? Why do they have to suffer again too?

--

Trust me - reading things on the forum this week and writing this were hard...I feel like a fool for still caring even though I knew in January that this wasn't my YHM...hope is hard to kill & ironically while SP is promoting "Hope Never Dies"...my hope for this show has been killed

Originally posted by: bscorp13

Hey TM..

I get your frustration. ..but honestly and this is purely my opinion..IshRa as i knew them were desecrated during the mani track..I could never look at ishita the same again. ..thanks to the way the cvs convoluted the script and made her seem condescending, emotionless and just plain unrelatable..raman was still there in parts...but no longer the 11pm version that I had so grown to adore. .flawed ..making huge blunders but always standing for what was right...

The sautan saga and bringing home her molester officially killed ishita for me ...and many others i knew who followed yhm like addicts. .and were INVESTED in ISHRA...one half of ishra died long backMute Raman for few months after this made me lose interest in him too..I knew it was a matter of time before raman turned into pure 730 time ever slot ML...

So for the last 8 in months odd it really hasn't been ishra. .Just few glimpses of them off n on..n predominantly those left watching ..like me ...watch only for those moments of brilliant acting and camaraderie of the leads...

Will that change after this disgusting plot line and leap..idk...i have already skipped a lot of weeks., at times months in the last 8 months odd...i might still completely skip this track..n watch intermittently ..popcorn in hand ...if and when there is a good scene..purely nostalgia sake and cos honestly indian telly hardly has anything else to write home about in the few other shows i hv managed to see...

But ishra and YHM of 11pm will still hold repeat value for me...and IshRa for , e would always be those broken souls in the first 10 months till sep 14...that image is enough for me. .