-Anku- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
So I was just re-watching a few episodes from before. And came across this one. A few dialogues and scenarios here remind me of the current track and wanted to share.

http://www.hotstar.com/#!/ye-hai-mohabbatein-3/simi-decides-to-stay-with-param-1000030110-e

In this ^ Episode 217. Raman said a similar dialogue to Simmi. "Ye mera ghar hai, aur yahan mai jo chahunga wohi hoga" Mr Bhalla was right there, through the conversation. Even when Raman threatens Simmi that he'd hit her if she went to Param. Why didn't Mr Bhalla react like how he reacted now? I mean I know they're creating drama 😆 So he has to react now because the track demands it. But nonetheless the situations are similar.

In both the scenarios Raman is being protective for his siblings. Simmi wanted to go back to Param and Raman did not want to allow it because he knew she would ruin her own life. It was his concern. Yes he has a weird way of expressing it, he goes overboard etc. But his intentions are never wrong.

In the current scenario Rinki came home, barged in and questioned Ishita, then Raman. Insulted Ishita for something she had not done and did the same to her husband who deserves respect. What she said to Mihir was not excusable. She called a decent, truthful and honorable man spineless, when she claims she's fighting for his rights.

Raman as an elder brother had every right to ask her to behave. Because he isn't just Rinki's brother, he is someone to Mihir and someone to Ishita too. And he said the dialogue he had said a number of times.. once again. But he's still the same, his concern and love for his siblings is consistent too. When he says its his house, it doesn't literally mean that no one else has authority or that he's the unquestionable king, because when the time arrives he's supporting everyone. And everyone in the family has equal rights.

So when anyone on the show or on the forum says he's changed, or does not respect his family anymore or that he was wrong. I don't get why, because for me he's still the same. His family probably changed.

Created

Last reply

Replies

20

Views

2.6k

Users

10

Likes

56

Frequent Posters

Ramyalaxmi thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
@TM: Good observation. I feel that the bottom line of the current drama is Raman's will.

Hope CV's are not portraying/ruining bhalla's family as selfish, greedy one to highlight the angel Shagun was right about the family initially.
Hayaa.m thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
Good observation Anku. Raman has always been liked that. He is consistent in his attitude towards every relation. I guess all the bhallas except Raman is suffering from amnesia disease.

Whatever i m just loving this track. It is so realist. Even worst than this happen in the families due to property or some other related issues. Good thing this all the actors involved are giving marvelous performance. The best of them is coming out. So i am happy with whatever is served to me.
Edited by Hayaa.m - 10 years ago
mreshma thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: -Anku-

So I was just re-watching a few episodes from before. And came across this one. A few dialogues and scenarios here remind me of the current track and wanted to share.


http://www.hotstar.com/#!/ye-hai-mohabbatein-3/simi-decides-to-stay-with-param-1000030110-e

In this ^ Episode 217. Raman said a similar dialogue to Simmi. "Ye mera ghar hai, aur yahan mai jo chahunga wohi hoga" Mr Bhalla was right there, through the conversation. Even when Raman threatens Simmi that he'd hit her if she went to Param. Why didn't Mr Bhalla react like how he reacted now? I mean I know they're creating drama 😆 So he has to react now because the track demands it. But nonetheless the situations are similar.

In both the scenarios Raman is being protective for his siblings. Simmi wanted to go back to Param and Raman did not want to allow it because he knew she would ruin her own life. It was his concern. Yes he has a weird way of expressing it, he goes overboard etc. But his intentions are never wrong.

In the current scenario Rinki came home, barged in and questioned Ishita, then Raman. Insulted Ishita for something she had not done and did the same to her husband who deserves respect. What she said to Mihir was not excusable. She called a decent, truthful and honorable man spineless, when she claims she's fighting for his rights.

Raman as an elder brother had every right to ask her to behave. Because he isn't just Rinki's brother, he is someone to Mihir and someone to Ishita too. And he said the dialogue he had said a number of times.. once again. But he's still the same, his concern and love for his siblings is consistent too. When he says its his house, it doesn't literally mean that no one else has authority or that he's the unquestionable king, because when the time arrives he's supporting everyone. And everyone in the family has equal rights.

So when anyone on the show or on the forum says he's changed, or does not respect his family anymore or that he was wrong. I don't get why, because for me he's still the same. His family probably changed.


@Blue...I guess Mr.Bhalla reacted differently to these words from Raman bcoz this time unfortunately he uttered it the very next day when he transferred the authority of his company to Ishita...So, as Mr.Bhalla himself said he is not bothered about the company but when it comes to house it really bothered him...and the truth is Raman who said these words never meant it from heart but he is misunderstood always...so none r at fault... I don't know if I made any sense...
-Anku- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Ramyalaxmi

@TM: Good observation. I feel that the bottom line of the current drama is Raman's will.

Hope CV's are not portraying/ruining bhalla's family as selfish, greedy one to highlight the angel Shagun was right about the family initially.


Yes maybe it was the will. But then wasn't he finally right. Because when Ishita found out, she was humble enough to deny wanting that share. But the family changed colors.

I don't know about Shagun right now, because she's not in the picture, so can't say 😊

Thanks for agreeing 😃
iffanvidz thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
Even before ishra's marriage...
raman uttered such dialogue...
"simi you got married...how long you are going to stay here...
call your husband and ask him to take you soon"
That time simi felt bad and she cried...but mrs.bhalla scolded raman for saying such things...

so Transfering the company's name in Ishitha is the root cause for every one...(even for mr.bhalla)
-Anku- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: mreshma


@Blue...I guess Mr.Bhalla reacted differently to these words from Raman bcoz this time unfortunately he uttered it the very next day when he transferred the authority of his company to Ishita...So, as Mr.Bhalla himself said he is not bothered about the company but when it comes to house it really bothered him...and the truth is Raman who said these words never meant it from heart but he is misunderstood always...so none r at fault... I don't know if I made any sense...


Yes but what is so different from the scenario back then. Raman wasn't making a decision for the company then, he was talking in a raised tone with the daughter of the house back then too. And even with Rinki in the current situation. And in both the scenes his intention was concern. Moreover similarly in both the scenes Rinki and Simmi were misbehaving as well.

If you remember around the episode I just linked, Raman even pinned a nameplate outside the house that read Dr Ishita Raman Bhalla, right below Senior Bhalla's name. Why no offence then? Why now?
Ramyalaxmi thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: -Anku-


Yes maybe it was the will. But then wasn't he finally right. Because when Ishita found out, she was humble enough to deny wanting that share. But the family changed colors.

I don't know about Shagun right now, because she's not in the picture, so can't say 😊

Thanks for agreeing 😃


If I am not wrong, Raman uttered those words to simmi in old house (Sr. Bhalla's house) but now in his house (previous company's apartment😆) that may also be a reason.
malaxmi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
He has even said Ishita a number of times that it is his house. He has even asked her to get out of the house. But none of the Bhallas reacted that time. I am a huge fan of RKB and I am justifying his act and not blaming him.
-Anku- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Hayaa.m

Good observation Anku. Raman has always been liked that. He is consistent in his attitude towards every relation. I guess all the bhallas except Raman is suffering from amnesia disease.


Whatever i m just loving this track. It is so realist. Even worst than this happen in the families due to property or some other related issues. Good thing this all the actors involved are giving marvelous performance. The best of them is coming out. So i am happy with whatever is served to me.


Absolutely. That's all I wanted to point out. That Raman is consistent with his attitude towards his family. His concern is all the same. And he almost always wants to side with the right. It's not about who he is siding, its about standing up for the truth.

And totally - The track is very real. And such things, or even worse happen in a lot of familes based on money or properly etc.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".