Baanj ......... A curse no more

redwine1 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
It was a winter evening ... her body was shivering from the cold when with just a phone call her soul was frozen solid ... she was denied the right to become a MOTHER ...
He stood there silently a voyeur to her pathetic plight ... he saw .. he felt her devastation ... but that day as she cried ... he could not offer solace ...he did not have the RIGHT ... nor did he have the might

CUT TO ...

It was a break from routine ... two opposite individuals took the first fledging steps to a relation .. they sat in his office sharing lunch ... she told him then ...Once Ruhi came into her life ... & she was complete ... he did not understand what she told him that day ... but tonite the meaning was CLEAR ...


Hello everyone ... yea the worst case of inertia ... not really i was blessed with an angel .. & she kinda takes up all the passion ... so this passion kinda took a back seat ... but when something touches u to this level ... ugh INERTIA be dammed .. one has to pen ... so here goes .. a small bow to the great talents ( kind of hidden for a long time) ... which pen our much loved show .. Yeh hai mohabbatein ..
Jaffar ... Ritu's ... take a bow ladies ... this kind of thot .. is beyond sublime .. at core its a cliche .. but the rounding up of the writing the CONNECTING of DOTs .. was simply outstanding ..


Let me pick the second scene from above which i have mentioned .. if u guys recall my post ... which i had written post this scene .. u will recall .. i had said ... what ISHITA actually spoke that day in his office was ... all about RAMAN ... coz RUHI was in her life .. because of RAMAN ... that day to she ended the dialog saying .. she was happy ...
but as she said those words .. she looked at her husband .. she did realise even then .. he did not really get her ... but these were first steps in their build up of a solid base ... so she left it there ...

For me that scene was beyond brilliant ... & a little part of me hoped for the audiences sake .. that the writer would recreate this scene .. but with the meaning down pat ...so thnx writers for doing this ..

Tonite as she lay her head on his shoulders .. she told him ... in no uncertain terms ... U R MY WORLD ... every part of her was his ... & every part of his was hers ...

DID u guys really want to see connsumation after this ... ofcourse u will get that eventually ... but first for a physical consummation to happen ... the souls needed to consummate ...

Tonight dear friends .. was the Consummation ... Consummation of the souls of two lovers ...

Now when u see the scene thru this lens .. did it seem like one of the BEST ANNIVERSARY GIFTS the writers could ever give us ... KUDOS guys .. HATS OFF ...

Now lets take the first scene i have penned above .. the day Ishita is denied adoption ... i have often written about this scene .. the need for Raman to physically offer solace to Ishita ... but the final step back .. he could not take that step .. & he decides the best solace he could give her was to go away .. coz she hated being WEAK in front of her ARCH ENEMY ... even then he thot only of her COMFORT ... COZ he knew what it was to be DENIED A CHILD OF THE HEART ...

If u see tonites scene .. the set up is almost similar .. once again she is crying ... but this time he has the right & the might .. he has the right to offer her solace .. & he has the might to change her PLIGHT ... he takes her in his arms .. & gifts her ...her WORLD ...

Ishita Vishwanathan Iyer nee Bhalla ... a woman who considered herself as HALF a woman ... cause she could not have a child .. she was apparently barren ... & because of this . her first love left her ...

Lets step back a bit here ...

It was stormy night .. the rain gods were pelting their might on the grounds ... her very feminity .. her very ability to attract a man was questioned ... he took her out of his car in the middle of a abandoned street & under the shower of the rain God .. he bared himself .. he bared his desire for her ...
Thats the night ... he made a woman .. who due to a quirk of fate .. was left abandoned by her childhood love ... it was as if .. if she could not have a child .. she was NOT DESIRABLE ..
That night .. RAMAN gave her ... her FEMINITY .. her DESIRE .. HER SELF CONFIDENCE ... he closed the surface of the wound which was festering for a long time ...

Yes he healed her that night ... but the core of the wound still festered deep down inside ...
TONITE .. the man who was smitten .. who was crazily madly in love with this woman .. completely obliterated the deep buried wound of ISHITA VISHWANATHAN IYER .. nee BHALLA ...

Tonite ... ladies & Gentlemen ... let us introduce you to the COMPLETE WOMAN ... ISHITA RAMAN BHALLA ...

If he credited her the other night of making him feel alive ... tonite .. he brought her out of the freezer as well .. he thawed that long frozen soul ...

Now i am sure most of you got this surface meaning of the scene ... but have often enuf spoken about how layered is the writing of YHM .. so lets kinda dig a bit deeper & lets unearth the real meaning of this scene ...

A man gifts his wife .. her dignity .. actually he gifts her the core of being a WOMAN .. being a mother .. tonight he tells her ... you can have a baby if u want ... but whats more .. he also confesses his love in the most basic way ... the desire to procreate with the one who u love ... the desire to see their love bear fruit ... with a lovely child ...

Ever wondered what was the need of the dam belly dancer ... well this was a man who did not even look at a sexy half clad woman ... coz to him every part of him belonged to ISHITA ...
This was a man who was TOTALLY COMMITTED TO THIS RELATION ... what better way to show that this was Ishita ka Raman .. the man who was smitten with his wife totally ...

This is the man who steps forth & wants to on this very auspicious day .. become ONE WITH HIS WIFE ...

Now lets change the lens ...

Ishita takes the report & tears it into bits & pieces ... she lays her head on her husbands shoulder .. & bares herself ...
she says the word BAANJ had cost her .. her first love .. but tonite ... she knew she was not half a woman ...tonite she knew she was not an undesirable woman ... coz the man she LOVED ... not only loved her totally ... BUT whats more DESIRED HER TOTALLY ...

Tonite ... the woman ... long buried desirable woman .. was unleashed ...this woman will now come out of the shell .. we have seen glimpses of her .. the one who wore a maids uniform & danced for her husband ... but tonite the cage which had imprisoned her was opened ...

That was Raman's gift to Ishita ...

Ishita's gift to Raman ... she tears the piece of paper ... the ULTIMATE SACRIFICE .. tonite she was TRULY ISHIMAA ...

Did u not wonder .. why would a child of Raman & Ishita call ISHITA ISHIMA .. he/she would call her simply MAA ... coz that was a reminder that this woman ..took up the task of becoming a mother to a abandoned child .. a child of her heart .. RUHI ...

She throws away the piece of paper .. saying ... i am already a mother .. our union does not need a physical manifestation of a child .. cause our union was because of a child ... our union was blessed by this child ... & our union has a physical manifestation .. we have a child .. RUHI ...

But in the midst of all this ... she also without having said anything or alluded to ..included ADI into the mix ... this will be the start of the ADI TURNAROUND TRACK ..

Ruhi & Aditya .. two kids who have suffered neglect & abandonment . two kids so insecure .. that even at the slightest mention of a problem in their world .. they crumble ... these kids were not yet ready for a THIRD in their MIX ...

I have mentioned this a million times this story is narrated as a contrast between two women .. Ishita & shagun .. one who gave birth to to kids . but could never become their mother .. & one who did not give birth to these 2 kids .. but they could not have dreamed up a better mother ... ISHIMAA

Tonight as a mother for a flimsy event lied & abandoned her child ... on the other end .. another mother .. gave up the right to become a mother .. so that she could help mother someone else's child ... TONIGHT ... ISHITA GAVE BIRTH TO A SON ... ADITYA BHALLA ...

The couple who sat hugging in that hotel room . tonite became proud parents

A long time back i had spoken of a story ... where 2 lovers gave each other christmas gifts .. by sacrificing what was most dear to them only to realise .. that the other had sold the very thing which was loved by them ... the man gifts his wife silver combs .. only to realise that she had cut off & sold her hair to buy a gift for him ...

Tonite Jaffar wrote her version of this story for us ... he gifts her a right to be a mother .. she sacrifices the same since she was already a mother to his children ...

The writing tonight was beyond brilliant ... now lets pause here a minute .. ever wonder what was the SOCIAL message behind this scene .. lets take a shot at that as well ...

In a society where a woman is considered half a woman just cause of her inability to bear a child .. a freak or quirk of nature which she is not even responsible for .. in such a society .. to show a scene where the woman tears up a report & says i am complete with you & what u bring to me .. was indeed path breaking .. glad to see that the writer broke the cliche & did not pander to the TRP aunties .. but gave a rock solid message ...

A woman becomes a mother through 2 organs of her body ... SOME BECOME MOTHERS THRU THEIR WOMBS >> SOME BECOME MOTHERS THROUGH THEIR HEARTS ..
both are organs of the body ... who are we to choose which child is more HERS ..

Tonight Ishita embraced the fact that she was a mother .. she was mother of 2 kids .. Adi & RUHI .. HER family was complete .. just to pander to societies stupid rules .. she did not want to conceive ... she was above all this .. if their union was to be blessed by a child .. that would be cause of their love .. NOT CAUSE SHE HAD TO PROVE TO SOME .. small minded women .. that she was not BAANJ ...

BAANJ ... tonight very beautifully the writer once again elucidated ... was a CURSE NO MORE ...



Sorry guys garbled bit of sentences came pouring out of me... blame it on the long break ... will hope to catch u guys soon on the forum ... take care ...

sorry to all those whose PM's i have not responded to ...

Created

Last reply

Replies

39

Views

8.3k

Users

38

Likes

187

Frequent Posters

-kri- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
Ruby...After a long time...😃 How are you yaar? Come back soon...

Coming back to your post, as usual, it was fabulous... What a start to this track... You have explored the difference between Ishita and Shagun and much more in your post... But, this scene reminded me of that bench scene in Ritesh's party...

Ishita heard that convo between Raman and Shagun which made her think that he wants a kid again... She asked him as to why Raman married Ishita when the truth was before him... But, that day, Raman never meant that... Before Raman could get to that topic, she stopped Raman from entering that private zone... She told him that its her issue... Today, this man produced a report...as their anniversary gift... Which showcased his desire too... But today, she opened up... Sought solace in his shoulders... Told him that she's complete even without her biological kid... Lovely...

But, can this picture end here? According to me, its a NO... Raman was realistic but Ishita was emotional... All that Raman cared for was just Ishita, Ishita and Ishita... He has been observing her plight... He wanted to find a solution. I loved his dialogues about Ishita getting that ehsaas of being a mother... Who said that a man can't understand this?

I called Ishita emotional because this woman has her own expectations from her life and marriage too... One lone tear escaped from her eyes when Raman tied mangalsutra around her neck during marriage... It was because of the compromise... Ruhi ke liye... There, i saw a normal woman Ishita. Again, we got glimpse of this woman after that apology incident in Chinese restaurant... She confessed before Bala that 'Ruhi ke liye' was not enough... Once again, Ishita came up with her expectations... Here, she tore that report but that necessarily mean that she doesn't have expectations? Doesn't Ishita have any need of her own? I have this question even after hearing those lines from Ishita's mouth... I will wait for an answer...

Today, Ishita spoke some words while hiding some... When Ishita read that report, that mixture of emotions... I felt that there was fear... She's still afraid of visiting those days... She doesn't want her own kid because she has Ruhi and Raman... She doesn't want any treatment... Felt that was her selflessness as well as her fear... Ishita and her pain can't come out in a day...

The way she hid that topic from Toshi also threw light on her state of mind... She can't break this news there...Before her Amma and Mummyji with Raman by her side... It was just between her and Raman but this doesn't mean she must hide it from her mother and mother-in-law. She has to suffer but her mother suffered too... Her mother-in-law gave her the much needed support by making her Yashoda maiya even when she had expectations from Ishita... But, i don't think Ishita will re-join the torn pieces of that report... A big track in its making... On one hand, god is opening a small window for Ishita when Romi's story is going to re-surface...

This report can change the life of many persons... This is my expectation from our realistic YHM. A normal mother whose world revolves around her daughter, selfish mother-in-law when it comes to her family, Ishima's Ruhi, abandoned Adi, much-in-love Raman and a selfless Ishita... I just hope cv's take this slowly...

I don't know if i did justice to your post by posting my rantings but still, bear with me yaar... Will wait for your reply...

Edited by krikumar.91 - 10 years ago
EkPaheli thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
Hey Ruby

Wow its been so long since you posted or we discussed something...this feels like a deja vu somehow and yet it isnt. Its been a while since I have picked apart the nitty-gritty of the show months to be precise so I dont know how coherent I am gonna be but here goes nothing.

Last night has moved me, I honestly cant remember the last time a scene moved me to this extent when it comes to this show it could have been the bench scene during the accident track or the night when Raman was lost in that haze drunk out of his mind when these two faced an ugly scenario in their marriage ...but we are long past that point now and at this juncture they have surpassed hurdles and yet a lot more awaits them...what has remained as the single constant though is that with each passing hurdle these two have gotten stronger, their relationship has cemented further and that is what happened on this night too - the night of their anniversary - it was a year ago, that they took the vows for a child, came together in the bonds of holy matrimony so that a little girl could have a complete family with parents, the two people she sorely missed and needed in her life and so that a woman who was labeled as Baanj - a woman who was cruelly humiliated for a complication, an issue she couldnt control could be the mother to a child who needed one more than anything in this world...a man meekly submitted to the match to please his child but in his heart of hearts had had no hopes about anything, he had done that...played the gamble of life and lost cruelly once because of a woman he chose to love who couldnt understand nor appreciate him or his feelings in return...it was a day when three incomplete people came together - I say three not two, as opposed to whats expected because there were three of them - a child, a woman and a man - each of them had a lot to give in terms of love and care, but had no takers.

Their lives had a lacuna that had overtaken them so completely.

A child missed her parents.

A man wanted a family, his family.

A woman needed someone to love...to be loved in return by someone - accepted for who she is...

Each of these had what the other could give and needed...a man had a child and a heart, shielded and wounded as it was willing to love seeking to be only loved in return...a woman wanted a child she could love and be loved by in return.

On a day a year ago from now, these lives came together - the man and the woman married - the child got her parents and the woman got a daughter...in the course of this one year they healed each other, discovered each other and filled the emptiness that was in their lives by being there for the other.

A year hence they are complete...

A year hence the man who wished nothing more than to avoid this woman earlier wants to start a family with her, not for his sake but because he knows what it would mean to her...

I dont know why but I was so reminded of JWM because of this...I know its way off the mark but bear with me...the movie is one of my all time favorites not just because it stars Shahid who I have a crazy crush on but because its just one of those movies which makes it seem like sometimes all that you need to do is change your perspective towards life, your problems...accept them, face them.

A scene in the movie I love is when finally Aditya reveals to Geet who he is, his identity and she callously speaks about his mother - you see how he reacts, how he absolutely loses his cool and she...the hyper one of the two calms him down and makes him see that holding onto that anger, that hatred is not gonna help him, he needs to accept his mother' choice, her decision...he needs to move on and make peace with her...to feel in charge of his life, he needs to take charge of his emotions first. He brushes aside her words saying its all a bunch of crap, poetic nonsense and stuff...but in the end that is what he does - he takes charge of his emotions lets go of all the negativity plaguing his mind because in the end he realizes SOCIETY doesnt matter...the hate, the anger he held for his mother were caused by society at large, the norms that dictate what is proper and isnt as per a few people who think they can set the guidelines for everyone...but do the norms of society necessarily make you happy? Are the conditions imposed by them acceptable in all cases? NO

Like Aditya' mom in JWM needed to break the shackles of society, tonight YHM also challenged another one of those predominated mindsets of society...

Is it fair that a married woman stay with her husband regardless of the fact that there is no love in the marriage just because it pleases the society?

Does a woman need to give birth to be a mother ? Being maternal cannot be ingrained in her regardless of the biological impairment she may face ?

Aditya himself admits in the movie his parents were never happy together - they fought all the time...his mother might have found her happiness with a man who finally made her feel loved...he needed to accept that whats acceptable to the society need not always make you happy...and what makes the society happy, what it approves need not make your life better...

In accepting her condition, Ishita had submitted herself to her fate long ago but she was NOT happy...she was NOT at peace with herself...she couldnt be because a man judged and left her due to a reason beyond her control and shook the core of her identity...her worth as a woman was questioned and crushed by him in an instant after over a decade of togetherness...

But in the one year of her marriage in Ruhi Ishita found a child who made her a mother regardless of them not sharing any biological bond - to have accepted herself as a Baanj now Ishita would have belittled and crushed the fights her daughter fought for her and that would have been UNACCEPTABLE.

So if you ask me what I saw last night, I would say I saw the acceptance of a woman she need not adhere to the norms of the society to say she is COMPLETE, to say she is HAPPY - because she has a child who she adores more than anything in this world who loves her just as much, a man who loves her for who she is, has fallen for her not despite herself but for all that she is...in admitting to Raman last night she is complete, she is happy...Ishita followed her heart and if some society cant adhere to it...then its no longer her problem - Ishita Bhalla is a woman, she is a MOTHER and she needs no one' stamp of approval to state the same.
Edited by EkPaheli - 10 years ago
MidnightMusings thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
res

Welcome back ruby. 🤗

Thanks for a clearer insight.
Edited by MidnightMusings - 10 years ago
ChanChanMan thumbnail
Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail 11th Anniversary Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
I'm glad Sonali is staying true to the message YHM set out to deliver. No wonder, I'm so proud to be a YHMian!! 😃
mar_21 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
YESSS 🥳
here i have someone whose posts I have always missed reading on this forum from a loonnng lonnnggg time

Fantastic Post!!

U have analysed the entire sequence so well with the past connections that the whole circle of Ishra's journey seems now completed!! Brilliant!


Edited by mischief - 10 years ago
WhyAmIHereAgain thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
good to see you back... that was a lovely post...brilliantly written..
I dont think I have seen the first scene you mentioned...havent caught up with all the old epis.. but tht scene in that office...what was left unsaid.. it was finally complete. I loved the comparison u drew with Gift of Magi... truly they both gifted eachother themselves... beautiful..


incendio thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
Brilliant as usual...👏
Missed your posts very much...
.TIA. thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
Ruby 🤗
Have missed ur posts soo much,specially at the LU😳.
This was brilliant as usual😳 Perfectly put, n straight from the heart😳😛
Loved it😛
Autumnn thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
Ruby 🤗 Congratulations on your sweet angel 🤗
So Good to see your topic. Absolutely love reading it. Missed so much your CTD & Pause 🤗 Welcome Back 😃

Love the episode love your post. Cried watching the episode, cried reading your post. So many feels omg.. Brilliant.

I did remembered the office scene while watching Ishra hotel room emotional scene. :)

Precap for me was just heart wrenching. Poor Adi.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".