Why the current track = accident track pt. II...

-K.13- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
I've been a silent stalker of the YHM forum for a while & just now started engaging in the discussions! Also it was a long weekend for me with absolutely no plans - so this is ultimately the product of a lot of boredom! 😉

We know that since the time slot has changed, some tracks have been rehashed with a spin on them. As I watch this track unfolds, I can't help be see direct parallels between this track and the accident track - all the way down to certain scenarios.

Here are some examples...

Accident track: Amma speaks of an ominous horoscope to Ishita
Current track: Amma again speaks of another toofan entering Ishita's life

Accident track: Raman is supportive, helpful, & thoughtful for the first 2-3 weeks in finding the culprit
Current track: Raman is support, thoughtful to Ishita's emotions, and manages Adi like a parent (i.e. Adi should understand his dad's remarried; tells Toshi to let Adi put his dinner items away on his own; questions Ishita about Adi hurting her post-storytelling)

Accident track: Raman does a sweet gesture for Ishita & participates in her aunty's Tamil pooja ceremonies.
Current track: Raman has a Tamil-based pooja, asking for Ishita to be his for saat janam

Accident track: Raman discovers Adi is the culprit and starts hiding things & feels guilty - somewhat irrational but still could feel for him
Current track: Raman bursts in anger at Ishita and based off the OLV is a passive audience member in the "sorry situation" - somewhat irrational again - harder to feel for him bc of his character's sudden 180

Accident track: Ashok confronts Ishita about Raman supporting/being with Shagun. Ishita argues with him but then finds her trust broken
Current track: Ishita is forced to say sorry to Adi and sees Raman not standing up - slowly seeing her trust breaking

Both tracks: Shagun illogically involves Raman using Adi.
Accident track: Shagun involved Raman because she wanted to prove to Ashok that she still had a hold over Raman. For some stupid reason, she thought this would encourage him to make their relationship valid?
Current track: Shagun initially states she wants revenge from the Iyers sisters. Thus she blames Ishita & vows to oust her from the Bhalla house. Now we're seeing this as more of Shagun's attempt to snag a access to a bank account via matrimonial bonds (finally a justification that's a little bit more logical)

Accident track: Raman defends Ishita in front of Shagun but then accuses her in private of hiding the proof that Shagun did not do the accident
Current track: Raman in private during his outburst of anger accuses Ishita of being too nice which led to Adi being separated from again.
Thanks @luvabhiya9 for reminding me about this one!

Both tracks: When it comes to Adi - Toshiji is beyond blind

Accident track: the core issue Raman faced was to save Adi
Current track: the core issue Raman faces is if his perfect family picture of him, Ishita, Adi, & Ruhi can happen

Both tracks: Raman makes a mistake & is greatly hated by the audience!

----
What's left to continue the parallels in these tracks...

Accident track: Appa has trouble paying for Amma's hospital bills - Raman steps in
Current track: We just saw the resurgence of another Iyer family financial issue - who will step in this time?

Accident track: Ishita's Kali Ma roop came out when she felt Raman was saving Shagun because he still loves Shagun
Current track: the emergence of Ishita's Kali Ma roop is still TBA but it's coming soon...

Accident track: Raman + Simi vs. every other Bhalla & Mihir
Current track: possibly seeing a Raman + Toshiji vs. every other Bhalla & Mihir

Accident track: Raman sees the repercussions of supporting Adi thanks to Adi's actions himself
Current track: Who will show Raman the light of day? Ishita? Ruhi? Adi? Shagun? or what I prefer - Raman coming to a realization himself and making a smart decision

----
Main difference between the tracks:

Accident track: Raman & Ishita don't outright love each other but have a mutual respect/admiration
Current track: Raman & Ishita outright love each other but haven't vocalized it

----

If this this track is infact a rehashing of the accident with a possible separation at the end like the 1st Param track - then boy do we potentially have a long few weeks ahead of us!

The only thing frustrating about the way this track is shaping up is the sudden 180 change in Raman's character. At least in the accident track there was a build up, so you could sort of understand where he's coming from, but here, thanks to the CVs incorporation of some harsh lines during Raman's outbursts - the regression of Raman's character seems more out of left field.

One silver lining if this these tracks are truly that similar - the CVs could possibly give us some closure! The accident track actually had some sense of closure to it unlike the Mani track.

I hope I don't sound totally silly, but hey if the show can be silly and illogical, why not us viewers? What do y'all think?
Edited by krishy13 - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

15

Views

3.5k

Users

10

Likes

62

Frequent Posters

Lekz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
I think your observations make perfect sense...
Separation is what I would hate...
Wings-of-Fire thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
It is actually- just an advanced version with more extreme execution since now they are in love. I wish it gets a proper closure- which will take a lot of working on their relation and their relation with Adi but with the track records of the CVS- I'm not hopeful.
nb.neha thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
Another similarity... ishita had toshi's support until she thouhht shagun is the criminal. The moment truth came out she begged ishita to take back her case.
Even today her love for aditya has over powered her sense of right n wrong.

Sadly ishita has no support. Raman in his fear of loosing adi will never understand ishita's plight. Even if she tries to show him the reality he l remain ignorant n probably will accuse her yet again for disliking Adi.

The track can come to a closure only if some how truth comes out from horse's mouth.
sunitas123 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: nb.neha

Another similarity... ishita had toshi's support until she thouhht shagun is the criminal. The moment truth came out she begged ishita to take back her case.

Even today her love for aditya has over powered her sense of right n wrong.

Sadly ishita has no support. Raman in his fear of loosing adi will never understand ishita's plight. Even if she tries to show him the reality he l remain ignorant n probably will accuse her yet again for disliking Adi.

The track can come to a closure only if some how truth comes out from horse's mouth.


Neha, but how will the result progress from what we saw in accident track? If at all the only difference is Raman's complete hostility towards ishita! So now again he finds out Adi/ Shagun are playing a game? I mean does he not know it already here? He does. And that is what is making it worse! Atleast in that track Shagun was not living with Bhallas! Here Raman seems to be okay with all the games Shagun and Adi r playing even if it hurts Ishita, provided he can keep pampering Adi - thats all he does, where is the time to teach him any manners? So while in the accident track Raman had soem escape route and he was in fact feeling for Ishita, here he seems all fkae, making grand proclamations of love - main tumse nahin ladunga, duniya se ladunga etc...? Does he mean he will fight for her once she rebels or threatens to leave? Else he will just take her for granted?😡
nb.neha thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: sunitas123


Neha, but how will the result progress from what we saw in accident track? If at all the only difference is Raman's complete hostility towards ishita! So now again he finds out Adi/ Shagun are playing a game? I mean does he not know it already here? He does. And that is what is making it worse! Atleast in that track Shagun was not living with Bhallas! Here Raman seems to be okay with all the games Shagun and Adi r playing even if it hurts Ishita, provided he can keep pampering Adi - thats all he does, where is the time to teach him any manners? So while in the accident track Raman had soem escape route and he was in fact feeling for Ishita, here he seems all fkae, making grand proclamations of love - main tumse nahin ladunga, duniya se ladunga etc...? Does he mean he will fight for her once she rebels or threatens to leave? Else he will just take her for granted?😡

In the accident track we somewhere knew wat the closure would be like. Here honestly I have no idea. Raman knows the truth still is acting in the opposite way. Only if raman gets to know adi's real intentions then may be he l realise wat blunder he is making
-K.13- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: sunitas123



Neha, but how will the result progress from what we saw in accident track? If at all the only difference is Raman's complete hostility towards ishita! So now again he finds out Adi/ Shagun are playing a game? I mean does he not know it already here? He does. And that is what is making it worse! Atleast in that track Shagun was not living with Bhallas! Here Raman seems to be okay with all the games Shagun and Adi r playing even if it hurts Ishita, provided he can keep pampering Adi - thats all he does, where is the time to teach him any manners? So while in the accident track Raman had soem escape route and he was in fact feeling for Ishita, here he seems all fkae, making grand proclamations of love - main tumse nahin ladunga, duniya se ladunga etc...? Does he mean he will fight for her once she rebels or threatens to leave? Else he will just take her for granted?😡



That I like to say is the CVs kalakari - is seems that they feed us that scene before the anniversary fiasco to appease is a bit. It was also a double-edged sword to make this track "more emotional."

The biggest difference between the accident track and this one was the build up. The CVs chose the most undigestible and illogical route to lead to the eventual choice between Ishita and Adi. In the accident track it was not AS much Ishita vs. Adi, as it was a question of Raman supporting right and wrong. However the CVs want this track to boil down to Ishita vs. Adi, and if I am speculating they are showing this sudden 180 regression in Raman's character and his breaking of vows for a "more dramatic and emotional" patch up between the leads. There are attempts being made to show that no one trusts Shagun but they all seem half-baked. Also they are also trying to bring in Ishita's insecurities of being a step-mom and not being able to have her own children. It could have been done with more class and not with Raman rubbing salt in her wounds, but supposedly drama sells.

What the CVs seem to fail to understand is that by presenting the track like the accident track, they are compromising the purity of Ishra's love-story.
-Gan- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: krishy13

I've been a silent stalker of the YHM forum for a while & just now started engaging in the discussions!


We know that since the time slot has changed, some tracks have been rehashed with a spin on them. As I watch this track unfolds, I can't help be see direct parallels between this track and the accident track - all the way down to certain scenarios.
Here are some examples...

Accident track: Raman is supportive, helpful, & thoughtful for the first 2-3 weeks in finding the culprit
Current track: Raman is support, thoughtful to Ishita's emotions, and manages Adi like a parent (i.e. Adi should understand his dad's remarried; tells Toshi to let Adi put his dinner items away on his own; questions Ishita about Adi hurting her post-story telling)

Accident track: Raman does a sweet gesture for Ishita & participates in her aunty's Tamil pooja ceremonies.
Current track: Raman has a Tamil-based pooja, asking for Ishita to be his for saat janam

Accident track: Raman discovers Adi is the culprit and starts hiding things & feels guilty - somewhat irrational but still could feel for him
Current track: Raman bursts in anger at Ishita and based off the OLV is a passive audience member in the "sorry situation" - somewhat irrational again - harder to feel for him bc of his character's sudden 180

Accident track: Ashok confronts Ishita about Raman supporting/being with Shagun. Ishita argues with him but then finds her trust broken
Current track: Ishita is forced to say sorry to Adi and sees Raman not standing up - slowly seeing her trust breaking

Both tracks: Shagun illogically involves Raman using Adi.
Accident track: Shagun involved Raman because she wanted to prove to Ashok that she still had a hold over Raman. For some stupid reason, she thought this would encourage him to make their relationship valid?
Current track: Shagun initially states she wants revenge from the Iyers sisters. Thus she blames Ishita & vows to oust her from the Bhalla house. Now we're seeing this as more of Shagun's attempt to snag a access to a bank account via matrimonial bonds (finally a justification that's a little bit more logical)

Accident track: the core issue Raman faced was to save Adi
Current track: the core issue Raman faces is if his perfect family picture of him, Ishita, Adi, & Ruhi can happen

Both tracks: Raman makes a mistake & is greatly hated by the audience!

----
What's left to continue the parallels in these tracks...

Accident track: Appa has trouble paying for Amma's hospital bills - Raman steps in
Current track: We just saw the resurgence of another Iyer family financial issue - who will step in this time?

Accident track: Ishita's Kali Ma roop came out when she felt Raman was saving Shagun because he still loves Shagun
Current track: the emergence of Ishita's Kali Ma roop is still TBA but it's coming soon...

Accident track: Raman + Simi vs. every other Bhalla & Mihir
Current track: possibly seeing a Raman + Toshiji vs. every other Bhalla & Mihir

Accident track: Raman sees the repercussions of supporting Adi thanks to Adi's actions himself
Current track: Who will show Raman the light of day? Ishita? Ruhi? Adi? Shagun? or what I prefer - Raman coming to a realization himself and making a smart decision

----

If this this track is infact a rehashing of the accident with a possible separation at the end like the 1st Param track - then boy do we have a long few weeks ahead of us!

The only thing frustrating about the way this track is shaping up is the sudden 180 change in Raman's character. At least in the accident track there was a build up, so you could sort of understand where he's coming from, but here, thanks to the CVs incorporation of some harsh lines during Raman's outbursts - the regression of Raman's character seems more out of left field.

One silver lining if this these tracks are truly that similar - there will be closure! The accident track actually had some sense of closure to it unlike the Mani track.

I hope I don't sound totally silly, but thought I would share my views and maybe ease some tension that's floating around. What do y'all think?


Wonderful comparison between the two tracks... We all got a deja vu of the accident track in multiple occasions.. But I love how you laid each element of the two tracks abd drawn the comparison .. Loved your insight!
Great job!
-Gan- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
Oops double post 😳
Edited by GanBarunFan - 10 years ago
geno0309 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
Hey great comparison post! I am wondering the reason they are revisiting this is coz they believe there should have been a better more meaning end to that track?like getting Raman out of the blind love slumber for his first born? Making Raman stronger and more aware of his son's nature?
Fingers crossed!

Related Topics

Ye Hai Mohabbatein thumbnail

Posted by: Sana2020 · 11 months ago

I'm rewatching the memory loss track episodes again for the nth time. I didn't watch yhm whilst it was on TV, so not sure how much appreciation...

Expand â–¼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".