--Megha-- thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
I am trying to analyze the whole Mani track or Insecurity Track. IMHO this track is not finished yet and has been pushed ahead to give way to Ruhi angle with Shagun Marriage Drama.
Firstly when Mani entered Raman just got jealous that another guy is getting more importance over him from Ishita's side.

Most of us were really confused as to where this track is heading to? Is it trying to solve Ishra's problems or complicate things more. Its ok to not show the final outcome of the track in the first episode itself when it started, but the way things are going and especially the way Ishra have kept aside serious issues of Physical abuse and emotional Trauma aside and went about going their daily routine in yesterday's episode it was really weird.

Any rational person in Raman's place irrespective of the baggage that they came with would have doubted Ishita's intentions cause he saw Ishita in the 8 month old marriage and she never was like this - calling non stop any of her Best friends, calling them for help in the night, lying about calling them etc.

While Ishita's intentions were always right, her actions (lying and her constant need to involve none of the family members in Bhalla family problems) were not really justified.

The Main problem with Raman's insecurity was he didnt confront Ishita and Mani in the beginning itself openly and went on assuming things on his part.

Similarly Ishita failed to use her woman's instinct and putting things together about what is ailing Raman.

During this track on one hand we saw an Ishita confess to Mani that she is liking to force this jealousy on Raman so that one day he will blurt out truth that he loves her.

On other, we saw a Raman trying to hurt her purposefully by taking Shagun's name in the party and also force her to accept him as her husband while he manhandled her.

It was all a game of actions and reactions. Raman saw Ishita saying ILY and took it to be true. Ishita saw Raman taking Shagun's name and thought that Raman is still thinking about his Past, present doesn't matter.

While we all know that both love each other , both are equally at fault at handling their insecurities and selfish in thinking form their POV's only. Raman is thinking only about his hurt and Ishita is thinking only about her hurt.

Firstly Love cannot be forced nor through jealousy nor by Physically demanding, Love happens and understanding is the most important factor in Love.

I find Raman a Man of less words more action in love and Ishita woman of more words and less action šŸ˜› in LOVE.

Here is where the problem lies. Raman doesn't expresses his love well in words, Ishita doesn't expresses her love by actions. Hence these two are as different as chalk and cheese.

Raman will put up a nameplate but when it comes to talk with Ishita - he will talk Rudely or most of the times Mock Ishita.

Ishita will try to talk about matters related to his family etc but when it comes to saving some post of his or solving some family member problem will not say directly that I did this for u or lets do it together.

Obviously both think that it should be naturally understood to the other person but sometimes in Love this is what u need to do Talk and show ur actions then only the other person can understand ur intentions.

Now all of us were expecting that they will have a heart to heart TALK (which has become almost elusive now after the Hug šŸ˜†) in yesterday's episode we got confusing scenes like Raman understanding in one day the whole Mannisha thing and Ishita asking about Bracelet.

I think Raman always knew that his Ishita is not wrong in her OTT friendship with Mani, yes he accused her etc but he wanted answers and reactions from her that all I am doing is for U (Raman). The trust that Raman has for Ishita is really commendable. šŸ‘ But Ishita is also responsible for this building of trust as she has been an upright and straightforward person so far. If she truly loved Mani she would have come and told Raman upfront about it rather than going behind his back and having an affair.

When he knew that Ishita was trying to save his position he put 2 -2 together and knew that ishita did all this (lying to him about Mani, Manisha etc) for him. Again CV's showed him repenting his actions and Car scene where he was seen having flashbacks, CV's y do u hate Ishita so much - Could u have not given us mini second scene of what is going on in Ishita's head?

Madam Ishita although doesn't understand her husband is very forgiving by nature. She thought of forgiving his jaanwar acts and going back to her Love. In yesterday's episode we saw her asking him about Bracelet more than asking him about his Janwar act. Jaya (Ehsaas) pointed me out that Bracelet is a metaphor for her Love. SO she was more concerned about her Love than her self respect. Only a person like Ishita can bear taunts and abuse from a Husband. Yes it all sounds Mahaan to us but then there r people like that in real life too who are overly forgiving.

She comes across as selfish and egoistic in Love when she demands her husband to mend his ways ( and become more caring but that is the way she is. N she is trying to do him good, I hope this track too teaches her a lesson that over meddling in other people's lives can cost u badly too. 😳

Although the dialogues yesterday looked misplaced somewhere the storyline was kept in tact. But what I really didn't like was the fact that they went from high intense drama to sudden lull, there should have been a scene or two when the Realization part should have been shown that both were trying to understand each other hence the confusion. Their Nok Joks were not required IMHO and that is y the episode fall flat on its face.

I want Raman to apologize for his rude behavior and when Ishita realizes that she caused her Ravan indirect pain then she too should apologize for his hurt. 😳

Currently not watching the show but once they have a proper talk will bounce back on it. Please share ur thoughts. 😊



Edited by mnr123 - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

26

Views

5.5k

Users

11

Likes

55

Frequent Posters

mayu1982 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
Very well written Megha...

Agree with you. Nothing to add as such. So just expressing my views on track( As I am still confused whether this track is closed or notšŸ˜†):

Cv has definitely sent wrong message to the society( considering the track is finished now). Yes I wish they could have shown a mature serious conversation between this couple but they didn't. Even during amma track- cv managed to close that track with proper social message. But in this case cv failed miserably.That is why I consider this track so far as " worst" track in YHM.

No wife should behave like IShita ( just taking this stupid track and not otherwise). Similarly NO husband should behave like RAMAN( talking in terms of assault episode only). Yes communication is the important factor for any relationships. THis important factor is terribly missing in ISHRA.

Hope you see some maturity when both deals with new problem- u know what I am hinting nowšŸ˜‰..
Edited by mayu1982 - 10 years ago
...EhSaas... thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
First of all very well said šŸ‘
It's not question that this track is ended or not but problem is that most of the episode look disjointed no proper connection šŸ˜•
From last month emotional torture to fans tgey gave single funny episode like nothing has happend šŸ˜†
It's like everything is just like round and round. Whole intense drama and they are back usual nok jhok no growth no realization specially from ishita side. As per article shagun drama will happend that means again one month whoke dramaof ishita insecurity towards shagun and raman and after one month they will strat same as usual nok jhok.
How will there relationship grow without this any proper closure if there insecurity šŸ˜•
Edited by ...EhSaas... - 10 years ago
Sandysprings thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
Awesome post megha..
I must say a neutral post ..

**
This track is not finished yet because the purpose of this track is not fulfilled.. Raman realize his mistakes in it but insecurities of his past is not over yet..and for that shagun marriage track started.. Uncoustiously he still gets affected by shagun ( a ex wife not mother of his kids ) ..we didn't like Mani much because CVs r failed to handle it convincing ways..people get confused in this track because Mani is too positive to be real/true..and dome Ott stuff from ishita's sshani.

This time they dealt with very much serious issues : physics abuse , fidelity issues, male friend of married woman , trust between hubby-wifey etc..so I was expecting some serious heart to heart talk between them ..but they suddenly jumped to very normal nokjok ..

And about ishita , we never get to see her views, her thoughts , her pain, her past ..nothing ..in accident track we got glimps of it only ..hope CVs show us her POV/thoughts also .YHM is about a journey of two broken hearts Raman and ishita ..here we get to know everything about Raman but ishita..

In this track both r responsible ..both did mistakes..ishita still doesn't know the actual reason of Raman's behavior ( in their bedroom). She doesn't know that Raman show her and Mani hugged and said ilus to Mani . so she is thinking that bracelet issues and Raman's not liking the Mani shani r the only problems. She has to think these r not big issues to make Raman janwar..and Raman also has to clear his doubts related to Mani or anything.. At least now he has yo tell her..but he is also assuming things from his pov's only ( he also very well know ishita )..so problem is they r too much egoistic . jukna nahi chahte dono..may be their part partners r responsible for it ..

Both trust each other but their insecurities of past shakes it..and they do mistakes.
Because of ishita's habit of meddle in others life , ruhi and Raman got ishita in their life and vice versa..šŸ˜‰šŸ˜† but sometimes I also don't like it .it looks too unreal when she interfere in shagun or ashok's or adi's matter.. when She interfere in simmi or param or romi or any family member of bhallas or iyers I don't have any problems...

Both r not going to discuss anything nor gonna apologize.. After watching today's epi I feel both realize their mistakes but from their POVs..actually they don't know the cause of the problems..they just assumed it and trying to solve it or repair it..I think they r not ready to face the reality. So again MUs will be there till they don't communicate..mihika already started to involve ishita into shagun marriage functions ( and of course ruhi is gonna join the all preparation/functions ) so.
Edited by v_ani_patel - 10 years ago
--Megha-- thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: v_ani_patel

Awesome post megha..

I must say a neutral post ..
Will update later ..


Thanks dear😊

Y? dont I make neutral posts ?šŸ˜•šŸ˜† Just kidding. šŸ˜›

Well the cvs don't give me scope to root for Ishu much, the whole story looks like dealt with Raman's problems, rarely we get to see Ishu's realizations or her past hurt etc šŸ˜• Maybe others might disagree with me, but this is my experience as a viewer.

Unres soon.
DivianTanz_Divz thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
Very nice post Megha.

Beautifully portrayed the emotions and features of both IshRa, which I many times fail to get and understand. Brilliant.

PS : In today's episode, Ishita gave a hint to us that she will try not to make Raman upset with Mani jhaap or importance. They way she never finds herself wrong, her this action of tactically ignoring Mani for Raman is something new from her. I appreciate it, but I still want a convo b/w them. IshRa convo is much more romantic than some typical romance.
--Megha-- thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: ...EhSaas...

First of all very well said šŸ‘

It's not question that this track is ended or not but problem is that most of the episode look disjointed no proper connection šŸ˜•
From last month emotional torture to fans tgey gave single funny episode like nothing has happend šŸ˜†
It's like everything is just like round and round. Whole intense drama and they are back usual nok jhok no growth no realization specially from ishita side. As per article shagun drama will happend that means again one month whoke dramaof ishita insecurity towards shagun and raman and after one month they will strat same as usual nok jhok.
How will there relationship grow without this any proper closure if there insecurity šŸ˜•


I agree with u, the way this track was handled and in the end they just went to doing their usual business Nok Jhok was not at all justified.

Ishita's insecurity of Shagun is valid and needed too, but they should have put a lid on the first thing that they opened in Mani track properly and then went on Ishita's part of insecurity.
--Megha-- thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: DivAniTanni

Very nice post Megha.

Beautifully portrayed the emotions and features of both IshRa, which I many times fail to get and understand. Brilliant.

PS : In today's episode, Ishita gave a hint to us that she will try not to make Raman upset with Mani jhaap or importance. They way she never finds herself wrong, her this action of tactically ignoring Mani for Raman is something new from her. I appreciate it, but I still want a convo b/w them. IshRa convo is much more romantic than some typical romance.


Thank dear. Even I fail to get their emotions coz sometimes it is not properly portrayed in front of us 😳.

Especially Ishita's part what problems CV's have with this beautiful character I really don't understand. Her share of realization or insecurity is less shown compared to Raman's n its not like DIvyanka is not a good actress she is.

In Mani track there was no need of showing un-necessary drama of showing her chirping around Mani rather they could have shown her thinking about Raman once in a while, coz this is how people in love look like - thinking about the man they love, her butterflies in stomach during Car scene after Sanjana episode was spot on.
...EhSaas... thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
In yhm except accident track none of the track has proper ending šŸ¤”
I was irritated with that track but we got proper talk between ishra that was last time they talk genuinely and heart to heart but here still no proper talk but as usual nok jhok. We love there nok jhok but at right time not force one
Paap nahi lagega ishra ya writer ko agar yeh dono seedhi tarah baat kare to šŸ¤“
shravani_2311 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
evn i need realiztn nd confrntatn frm both sides...waitng to justify their actns...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".