custody novel was much more sorted then YHM

I Found all custody novel messed up in YHM
i mean as per the novel , SHAGUN met ashok after both the kids were born [specifying this part after watching SBS :X]
raman was caring towards ruhi from begining & he fall in love with ishita before marrying her.

i agree in YHM they need to change their chemistry to make it a fiery one.. but atleast RAMAN should be soft towards ruhi & how can he himself doubt his blood..
& how can he trust ashok.. if ruhi would have been ashok's daughter then why would have shagun left ruhi with him

then most importantly as raman mentioned he married shagun 12 years + 1 month ago & ashok met shagun like 12years ago only then how can shagun give birth to aditya & ruhi both when she was madly in love wd ashok 12years ago (where as per novel ashok met shagun after 6-7 years of raman & shagun's marriage where shagun met ashok at some business occassion) which acc to me is a blopper

still raman should have some brain... cv's atleast apne flashback's ko review karo as per last flashback raman got to knw about shagun & ashok after she declared herself.. & if shagun is more concern about ashok instead of raman raman didnt had brain then to judge it...dn trusting ashok bakwas & reacting over ruhi..

I think the time line and flashback is ok for me...He told he married one month before his friend who is celebrating 12th anniversary.
But I don't think the flashback is of the 1st anniversary because he said while looking at building that kuch Saal pahele. So I think Shagun didn't have affair before their son was born. But may be before Ruhi was born and Raman was unknown of that..
They splitted when Ruhi was just 6 months and Aditya was 4 or 5 years and they splitted before 5 or 6 yrs. so this makes sense to me..

Raman mentioned that the FB was 4 years old. And aditya is 11 years old so I dont think Shagun had an affair before Adi was born

i think all got mu with Fb

Ishra chemistry is abit different from the book...they made a passionate one here which we all have no complaints at all

I don't think they exactly follow the book...I agree in the book...raman is a very loving caring father to ruhi...this was one quality that ishu falls in love with raman but after marriage equation change little bit as ishu becomes very possessive towards ruhi n neglect raman a little bit

As for the timeline...raman mention some yrs ago not 12 yrs ago...shagun had affair with ashok after Aditya not before...but abit confused on this part only...did she had an affair when she was pregnant with ruhi?...if yes than raman's current doubt n frustration make sense

In the book...ashok married shagun...but in the show...its a daily issue for shagun...ashok has no interest in marriage...I am sure EK is going to create a twist here regarding ashok's personal life which is not known to shagun...a mysterious one...

Book turned into a movie can be more faithful to the original story line because its just 3 hours! But serial inspired by a book cannot be as faithful I feel because a serial stretches for months... therefore there is no other option but to add mirch masala... can't be helped!

Ashok tells Raman he and Shagun were having an affaire for a long time before Raman even had any clue abt it... So Raman doubting Shagun makes sense...

Ekata is kwn for being melodramatic... She will strech everything to the limits and we the viewers are left being frustrated...

Ashok and Shagun r too disgusting in the shw... Shagun actually considring giving an interview and claim tht Ruhi is not Ramans so tht Ashok can marry her... If thy dragg ths issue to much... Viewers r bound to lose interest... At least i would...

yes knowing Kekta she will screw things but till now i feel its goin fine . She has to add lame tracks as well to keep the pace fwd .In the novel after ruhi's custody story ends and here it begins .

Originally posted by: Loveforlife

Book turned into a movie can be more faithful to the original story line because its just 3 hours! But serial inspired by a book cannot be as faithful I feel because a serial stretches for months... therefore there is no other option but to add mirch masala... can't be helped!