Ae Mere Watan Ke Logo.. - Page 2

The comparison between Nihira and Seema is not only irrelevant, it is futile.

Of course Seema rendered it perfectly.

I think only by comparisons we are able to see the standard.

I do not want to comment about seema singing this song.

For me, this song is associated with lata di and no one else.

Just cannot connect this song with anyone else.Impossible for me😳

sorry😳

Originally posted by: musicmuse

I do not want to comment about seema singing this song.

For me, this song is associated with lata di and no one else.

Just cannot connect this song with anyone else.Impossible for me😳

sorry😳

Well so long as the soul has been captured it is all that matters.

Originally posted by: Summer3

Well so long as the soul has been captured it is all that matters.

A lot depends on the listener too.😆

Soul, singing right, everything matters, esp for this song.

it is an iconic song, lyrics, music and singing wise.

The lyrics of this song comes from deep anguish at the loss of unnecessary very young lives.This would be the best lyrics for me, till date😳😳

Yup, it depends on a discerning listener, who has knowledge of music, can appreciate lyrics which tears at their soul even today.

Sorry, i cannot laugh at this song, ever , summer bhai😳😳

Yes these songs are sacred and many have made great sacrifices. Respect and sentiment are more important than the execution.

Nihra, Anwesha, Seema, etc try their best to sing this song, and they sing it well musically, but nothing can compare to Lata-ji. I know people are not comparing them to Lata-ji, but I just have to state that. None of these people can make me cry when they sing this but Lata-ji. When Lata-ji sings it is really feels like the words go from your ears straight to your heart. Just listen to this:

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

Koyal I am 😕 at your post abv..I was speaking of Nihira as contestant and not comparing her to Lata di..😳

Lata di is Maa saraswati when it comes to singing..WHo am I to even bring these 2 names in one sentence?? Main aisi galti kabhi na karoon..Meri budhhi bhrashta huvi hai kya ?

I was sharing Nihira's rendition only..Hope u enjoyed it as I did..

nahi nahi - what I meant was ke after hearing Nihira singing this song which is so close to the best of the best, one is quickly reminded of the ultimate best i.e. Lata M. - I feel like listening to Lata M. not to compare but to just enjoy that divine voice at it's purest. IMO - Nihira and Anwesha are very very close to Lata M's voice. I just don't know why they are not given any filmi songs and have to resort to singing at concerts - not that there is anything wrong with it - but they should be in the big league - me thinks...