tapasya and scarlet o hara

Originally posted by: chullbullii

guys i really think that there is a similarity betn tappu and scarlett..she was always after someone else who didn't love her and rhett butler loved and married her inspite of her shallow behaviour... what do u think??

Originally posted by: icecream2007

bang on!!

mujhe bhi yahe lagta hai..

rathod is rhett butler..tapasya is scarlet..

gone with the wind...

sigh!😳😳

Originally posted by: hermione8

I have written about this earlier.. But Scarlett never tried to murder anyone or was so mean and she never stooped sooo low as Taps. The only similarity is their obsession for a weak man and nothing else. She was living under the illusion that she loved the weak Ashley who loved only Melanie. She never realized the worth of Rhett Butler and when she realized that she loved him it was too late. Here also I am getting a feeling that Taps will lose Rathore also.

Please check this post:

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/post/39306808�

Originally posted by: chullbulli

😆 i think hum dono hi ratrhore ke deewane hain...😉😆 u know i stopped watching since vansh was introduced... ab jab rathod ke ek do scene dekhe to dubara se back log dekh rahi hoon...i wish he was given more screen space... ichcha veer ka romance is very mild ...not my type. aur koi serial hai humare rathod ka???

Originally posted by: icecream2007

u mean currently or from before?

Originally posted by: hermione8

I have written about this earlier.. But Scarlett never tried to murder anyone or was so mean and she never stooped sooo low as Taps. The only similarity is their obsession for a weak man and nothing else. She was living under the illusion that she loved the weak Ashley who loved only Melanie. She never realized the worth of Rhett Butler and when she realized that she loved him it was too late. Here also I am getting a feeling that Taps will lose Rathore also.

Please check this post:

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/post/39306808�

Originally posted by: Kruthika.N

Yes, I definitely see the comparison. Both characters are strong yet extremely ignorant about love at the same time. Technically, Scarlett did murder a man at a time, though for extremely different reasons. I appreciate Scarlett's character a lot more than Tapasya's because I find her much more ambitious than Tapasya, and she definitely has not gone as low as Taps has gone on many occasions. There certainly is a Rathod-Rhett similiarity as well.

Originally posted by: hermione8

@ Kruthika.N... Nice to see you interacting and giving your inputs...😊.

Scarlett killed a man as it was war time and it was survival of the fittest as otherwise that enemy soldier would have looted and killed her and burnt Tara, her home, the source of her strength, which was above all things for Scarlett. She did not kill anyone to possess Ashley Wilkes and do any of the low, mean things Tapasya has done, and so she is in no way comparable to her. She was not entirely selfish either, like Tapasya, as she took care of everyone in Tara with her hard work and determination, giving out strength and support during the very difficult war times. There is something to like and admire in Scarlett in spite of knowing her flaws, but there is nothing lovable in Tapasya.

Anyway Veer is definitely becoming very weak like Ashley and the old, justifiably angry Veer with fiery looks (with Vansh's suicide memories) when he sees Tapasya is missing and his role has become really pitiable and ridiculous.

Rathore, on the other hand, is very impressive and his role of the eternal saviour of Tapasya in spite of knowing her fully reminds us of some characteristics of Rhett Butler, but Rhett is awesome and I cannot compare him to Rathore.