Old Wine in a new bottle?

Page

Next Last

sumsukor

@sumsukor

Rocker

Posted: 7 years ago

Hey all

Just my thought suddenly which dawned

going through the promo, the forum activity and varied emotions and perceptions one thing which dawned on me is that

Are the makers giving the viewers the Same Old Wine in A New Bottle??

what is new?

the spoilers said that there will be fresh tracks... is it...

too early assumption but still when it is being looked at what I feel is that

Chakor came after 10 years now she is coming after 5 years... (why 5 years ? no idea maybe to retain the youthfulness to romance????)
When she came back the village was ruled by KN. - Now being ruled by Imli (more horrendously)
Manohar was killed at that time and no one bothered to find about the killer - Now Ranjana has been murdered again the same silence.
Vivaan was drugged then Now it is Suraj's memory loss (equal as to drugging)
KN was ruling with Suraj - Now it is Imli ruling with Suraj (unconsiously)

Where do we get to see a new idea or fresh track?

Again it is chakor who is going to get back Suraj (yeah the idea to keep the track going, but what is new)

At the end

The career of the protagonist is at stake (she will be now around 24/25 old years which will be difficult though i am not against it to take to spikes and athletics)

We thought to see the village proceed with development but it is being show pushed to pre- medieval age

and the best part as shown in insta and twitter by all the production people as something totally new is being cast!!

Are we to fall and believe this??

just the love of MeeJay and Sukor being misused??

Well I know it is a drama, show, but has it to be only like a vicious cycle of only repeat ideas.

the disclaimer says they want every child to fly high but are they standing by their disclaimer it is like showing drinking alcohol is injurious to health and the hero is always shown with the bottle in hand and ofcourse we also appreciate the actor albeit the disclaimer's propaganda!!!!

I am sorry about this ranting but

I feel there is nothing new, new ideas, new tracks as of now the makers of thinking of

Same old stuff

only thing Chakor thought she was loving vivaan when she came back

Now Chakor is married and loves Suraj while coming back.

Am sorry if I had hurt the sentiments of the regular viewers of the show / shows (not only to Udaan but in general)

Honestly, for me the story had ended after the basti wedding and along with the beautiful godbharai...

I wish to cherish and stay away for some time.

Quote

Frequent Posters

binivenugopal

@binivenugopal

Dazzler

Posted: 7 years ago

I don't like the idea of Sooraj being slave of Imli.

It would have better Imli throwing out,Teju,Bhuka from village.

And Sooraj after memory loss end up in some other village.

When Chakor came back,Imli ruling Azadgunj.

And Chakor's first mission to find out Sooraj and rest of the people first and then fight with Imli.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

nemo316

@nemo316

Sparkler

Posted: 7 years ago

Sukor are the winners in the revamp because there was little left in their story to show, but only if the makers learn from their past mistakes and improve their execution and writing of Sukor scenes.

Athletics is one of the most forgiving sport age wise, especially for long distance, most of the champions are above 30, so age isn't a problem for Chakor, it's more the stigma of going to jail for murder. The residents of Azaadganj and nearby places will know the reason behind this but for the outside world, she'll have to continuously explain herself and it will be difficult to find sponsors. But this is reality, in fiction whatever CVs want will happen.

I'm not familiar with the show before the first leap, but it was also Chakor vs KN, still the plots were different from post leap, so it's too early to conclude that this time it will simply be deja vu with new faces.

There will probably be no fresh ideas, but still old tracks can't be repeated. When Chakor returned the first time, her career was blossoming, she was optimistic and unscarred, now things are different. Also, she was occupied with saving her sister which won't be explored now.

I thought everyone assumed Manohar died in a car accident, so there was nothing to investigate. As for Ranjana, there is no one to find out the truth except her father, they may show it near the end like they did with Ranjana.

If you describe a story by its basic plot line, they all sound similar. A determined heroine, with known enemies and some backstabbers. It's the details and execution that sets a story apart. Whenever I read a review of a new show that praises it for its fresh concept, I smile to myself and say it's not the start that counts but how the story progresses that makes a show unique.

In conclusion, Chakor's fight for freedom will be a lot like its first chapter, whether it's interesting or not will depend on the plots, the writing and execution, so it's too early to tell. Also, I think the Imli factor is clouding everyone's judgement, if it was Ragini in her place or if Chakor has moved to another village with a new KN, fans wouldn't have been this despondent. And I think if the makers have allowed Sukor to stay together the last two weeks, fans would've at least used these memories as consolation, the early spoilers were a negative factor too.

Quote

Sakshi Srivastava

@Sakshisriv

Navigator

Posted: 7 years ago

I told it earlier also...this is not a fresh track..it's just old track with a new villain...this time cruelty level is also high...Imli doesn't fit in the look and character both..she is looking like a dacoit who come time to time for looting the villagers(tho there is different scenario)...everytime screaming n making evil face doesn't make any sense...

Edited by Sakshisriv - 7 years ago

Quote

nemo316

@nemo316

Sparkler

Posted: 7 years ago

I too don't like Suraj being Imli's slave and torturing the villagers. A person's true nature doesn't change with memory loss, but I'm holding judgement until I see what's actually shown.

I think that Bhuka or Tejaswini will exit the show, I can't imagine Suraj having his mother next to him and remaining in this condition for so long.

Quote

sumsukor

@sumsukor

Rocker

Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: Sakshisriv
I told it earlier also...this is not a fresh track..it's just old track with a new villain...this time cruelty level is also high...Imli doesn't fit in the look and character both..she is looking like a dacoit who come time to time for looting the villagers(tho there is different scenario)...everytime screaming n making evil face doesn't make any sense...

true and she just canot cannot shoulder it long.

the viewers may see whats actually happened but will not tolerate her too much I presume.

Quote

sumsukor

@sumsukor

Rocker

Posted: 7 years ago

Thanks Mai and BIni

hope the makers come up with good rejuvenating track

Quote

77nikita

@77nikita

Dazzler

Posted: 7 years ago

Sumi exactly my thoughts albeit penned down very well...and I think you should put this up on Insta...whether they read it or not...and in fact all of us should also write telling them that we are not the fools they think us to be...and that it is no fresh track they are shoving down our throats...

It's just role reversals they are doing...of course we can wait for a week and then do it... But we should do it...

And I know some might say that if it's so much of a problem why don't you just quit watching...yeah we will but not before voicing our opinion as loyal viewers of the show...it's becoming a recycling bin...we should let them know.

Quote

Divya

@ndivyateja

Dazzler

Posted: 7 years ago

Sumi 🤗

Will surely post my view once I get this promo out of my head and brace myself for the upcoming track 😃

Quote

sumsukor

@sumsukor

Rocker

Posted: 7 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: 77nikita
Sumi exactly my thoughts albeit penned down very well...and I think you should put this up on Insta...whether they read it or not...and in fact all of us should also write telling them that we are not the fools they think us to be...and that it is no fresh track they are shoving down our throats...
It's just role reversals they are doing...of course we can wait for a week and then do it... But we should do it...

And I know some might say that if it's so much of a problem why don't you just quit watching...yeah we will but not before voicing our opinion as loyal viewers of the show...it's becoming a recycling bin...we should let them know.

yes thanks Niki

will for sometime and then voice it out

Quote

1 2 3 4

Old Wine in a new bottle?

Related Topics

Explore Topics