Who do you think had a harder time?

Originally posted by: Ananya_A

When Edward left bella in New Moon who do you think had a harder time, Bella or Edward ?

Edward had to leave with this guilt of hurting the one he loves. He was all alone curled up into a ball of misery, isolated himself from all humanity.😭

Bella on the other hand was leaving with a whole in her heart that Edward doesnt love her anymore.She was going insane..jumping off the cliff..bike riding n all,😆 if Jake dint come to help her i shiver at the thought of what could have happened to her😕.She was better off than Edward in a way coz she had Jake.

So who do you think had a harder time?

Hmm..thats hard! I think Bella coz i agree with the point made above..that Bella had to live for those months thinking that Edward didn't love her..and that hurt! But then she had Jake!

However, then i think about Edward..and like he had no one at all! He had been alone for 109 years and after all that time he found someone whom he truly loved but had to leave her...and he was left alone again...and this time he wasn't even with his family!

Originally posted by: Mimi_Rani

i think edward had a harder time because...

one: bella was convinced edward didn't love her, he had to lie to her but she fell for it....and living while knowing your loved one believes you don't love them is harder....

two: bella had jacob like you pointed out, edward was all alone, no one understood his pain....

three: he knew it would be painful but he went with it, however long he could...

i believe edward was the one undergoing the harder times, he didn't have anyone to comfort him, all around him his family members were happy with one another and he once again was the one without the partner....he loved her but couldn't be with her, found himself the sole reason for her in pain....

being edward was more difficult than undergoing the pain that bella underwent...

as always

sukhi :)

Originally posted by: Leenasmg

Hmm..thats hard! I think Bella coz i agree with the point made above..that Bella had to live for those months thinking that Edward didn't love her..and that hurt! But then she had Jake!

However, then i think about Edward..and like he had no one at all! He had been alone for 109 years and after all that time he found someone whom he truly loved but had to leave her...and he was left alone again...and this time he wasn't even with his family!