Originally posted by: Khyati8Redux scene was hyped as her "chand" gave her the chand bracelet. But the original one had more to it. Just how ingrained it was and a part of anika's personality and how tied it was to shivika:) i loved the scene where shivaay finds her chand bracelet but gives it to her later in the room and then even during diwali gives it back to her all repaired. Those scenes man had soo much substance. Wese baat toh hai ki puri tarah bezaiti karwake off air gayi show but while it lasted it definitely was one of a kind!:) The growth and organic relationship on a GEC that too still is worth cherishing. That legacy carries on leaving the whole ugliness behind. That was is the power of OG shivika:)
Having said this indeed yes Such bitterness redux generates. Koshish karte toh zaroor accha hota they gave a promise for a while and then toh๐
Exactly. The original just had so much meaning attached to the chaand bracelet being an inherent part of her personality, her IDENTITY. Redux mein they just made it a random "pyar ki nishaani"๐ค.....which just shows how hastily they put together the scene just to show a lolliop "romance" moment.
Redux Shivika ka waise bhi koi interaction basis nahin tha.....they just instantly jumped from regressive abusive crap to "lovey dovey" husband-wife.....lol....is scene mein bhi the "I love you's" seem kinda OTT๐....kahaan yeh, kahaan original ke depth waale, slowly built up confessions.
And what do they mean by "her chaand"? lol Shivaay was supposed to be her suraj, not her chaand. Chaand uske paas already tha uski bracelet mein :P
Anyways, this is a dumb alternate reality that has no bearing on the original meaningful journey.
Yeh waale scenes visually enjoy kar sakte hain log for NM-SC ki chemistry I suppose....but the underlying disconnect remains cuz they don't feel like the actual Shivika.....main connection toh unse hi hai. Mera yehi problem hai redux scenes se abhi bhi....even if on one level, NM-SC try to bring in some of their original Shivika mannerisms, the writing itself is bad enough to remind us that beyond the mannerisms, these are hollow redux characters only....and that feeling never gets fully overcome. Watching redux scenes is like watching a distorted familiar painting. You reach out thinking it looks familiar....but the closer you get, you see how it has been distorted....and you feel torn between watching it for the familiar and being repelled by the distortion.
comment:
p_commentcount