~*~ || PearBhi/BeHir AT #29 || Tere Aasmaan Pe Aake Thehra Hai ~*~ - Page 85

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

44.6k

Users

36

Likes

2.6k

Frequent Posters

Stardust91 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
@ crusty which is why before that blow two things need to happen:
1, he needs to have Bela with him because when he realises that Sumi is fake and only wants him for his money and Yuvi doesnt care about him either where will he go; who will protect him; who will he cry to -- Bella

AND right now that is the same Bella he is treating like this? The person he has professed love for 100 times -- Bella I love you; Bella you are only mine; Bella I don't want anything except you TO Bella I HATE YOU x 3??

Therefore he needs to redeem himself ASAP

2. He needs to see through Sumi because what will happen will be like he will break SO BAD otherwise so it might be better if he has already realised Sumi;s truth and is faking the memory loss
415868 thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: Stardust91


He did promise to trust her but he was also very aware of his feelings from the first day; he knew that he had fallen for Bella and he did everything he could for her. At the wedding he said he would never let anything bad happen to her.

He did what he did because he wanted to; he wanted to marry her; he WANTED to trust her; he did keep saying to Bella that he trusts her and he will do anything for her but did she ask him that -- NOT until she realised that something was there and that she had fallen for him; when fake Yuvi vivaah was on ; Bela had already fallen for Mahir and his good ehart and his kindness and his love for her

He followed her around like a puppy dog; YES, in future we may realise that it was his powers that would lead him to Bella but till now all we see is a lovelorn guy promising his wife everything

Bella was going to come clean wasn't she -- she was scared he would leave her and he did exactly that -- he walked off; yes he was hurt but she was scared; he heard that she was molested and yet he said OH I WILL ASK Pratham

I am not saying that Bella is right and Mahirji is wrong; I am just saying that I need Mahirji to stand up for his love and realise that Bella was not wrong ebcause she did what she thought was justice in HER world; that is why she said that courts and the law are for normal humns not for her;

Was he upset that he had married a Naagin? I mean she is a Naagin but unlike Nagini she is not a Maledictus; All we see is a Bella trying and a Maahir hating her so to us it is as if he has forgotten her

She has cried and begged fr forgiveness and he did not want to hear💔


That's the thing.

She wanted to come clean but she was "scared". Wasn't it her CHOICE here just like how it was Mahir's to trust her? She made a "Choice" based on her fears, insecurities and experiences. If we can't fault Bela for the "choices" she made based on her life lessons how can we fault Mahir for taking the blow this way, because they also came from his deep-rooted fears and experiences.

He is scared of being cheated upon. He is scared of "other person" in the life of the partner. And Bela KNOWS about these fears. Since he knew that she knew he was SURE she wouldn't hurt him there. And what does he come to know?! She kept her ex-lover KNOWINGLY under his nose all along. What would the trigger of a person be who was emotionally damaged in this area?!

And we've always seen Mahir's coping mechanism towards emotional crisis or cheating is his mind shuts down for sometime till he processes it slowly and properly. Even during Bela's wrong confession he blew up and shut his mind and ears to her pleas, he had to run away, take time off, process the whole thing, then he came back to fight for her. That is exactly how he reacted here too... She was full of half-truths and lies all along, she MURDERED people, this is something AGAINST his moral compass, do you think he would even THINK of Bela as murderer and hoped to keep up his promises in the face of such truths?!

His reflex action was to be the "Fair guy". He took all her information as JUST information and judged it fairly. Why should he take her words at face value?! On what basis?! There are too many emotions overpowering, before he could feel rage at the deeds of his brothers, he was immediately hit with the fact that he was already punished for it in the form of death by this very person!

Any sane human being would need TIME to process all this... above that he gets hit by truth of her "different" world. This is BRAND NEW information for HIM, we knew she was Naagin, but he doesn't. How would he immediately jump to understanding things in her Naagin POV?!


Imagine if Mahir turned out a supernatural creature who faked memory loss coz he had to hide his identity for some reason & killed Nmom, would you blame Bela for getting angry initially for hiding it from her?! Even if he told her that Nmom was harmful/fake? Wouldn't Bela want to find it out about her mom n be shaken that Mahir lied such a huge thing?! And here half of his family is wiped out... Innocents like Bultu's GF and ACP were dead. And above all, the guy for whom she apparently killed is alive n his very house with her knowledge. What would any SANE person do?!

You know, you can make promises and vouch to live by them, but they should COMPLY with your MORAL compass. Mahir TRUSTED Bela is not someone who would challenge his MORALS and PRINCIPLES! If you have to go against them to keep your promises, then one would make sure it is worth it by reasoning about it.
Edited by crusty - 6 years ago
415868 thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: Stardust91

@ crusty which is why before that blow two things need to happen:

1, he needs to have Bela with him because when he realises that Sumi is fake and only wants him for his money and Yuvi doesnt care about him either where will he go; who will protect him; who will he cry to -- Bella

AND right now that is the same Bella he is treating like this? The person he has professed love for 100 times -- Bella I love you; Bella you are only mine; Bella I don't want anything except you TO Bella I HATE YOU x 3??

Therefore he needs to redeem himself ASAP

2. He needs to see through Sumi because what will happen will be like he will break SO BAD otherwise so it might be better if he has already realised Sumi;s truth and is faking the memory loss


Redeem from what?! Tell me, you are presented with one IMAGE of a person. When that IMAGE is proven false what would you do?

Willl you fault a person who TRUSTED or the person who BROKE the trust?!

Why is he being pointed out for trusting and loving?! He knew she had secrets but do you think his mind would imagine scenarios of MURDERS and NAAGIN?!

I am not talking about post memory loss Mahir because I simply don't understand this guy. But before this memory loss fiasco what Mahir reacted to was not at all wrong.

And right now, he lost his memory, not his personality. I don't know why they are taking that away from him... He was fair and reasonable always, observant and understanding but this new version is not showing those qualities till now, how can that be gone?! I really do hope it's fake memory loss... I can't stomach this personality transplant they are attempting with him.



@Kom: If yours is long post, I dunno what would mine be 😆
komlika thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
@ Crusty Honestly I agree with everything you have said

Not blaming mahirji for his reaction because it's how a reasonable person would react in given situation

What I am saying is that even if bela would have come clean earlier as he kept asking her I am not sure that mahirji's reaction would have been any different than what it is right now

He would have still reacted exactly same

His react differently when it comes to bela. Everything goes out of window when it comes to things about bela or related to her. Some times I think he himself doesn't know how he is reacting regards to bela

He himself have confessed that she makes him forget who he is at times 😆

memory loss track 🤢 don't even get me started on that 😡
Stardust91 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
P.S. I cannot believe that I am actually arguing against Mahirji's reaction rather than FOR Mahirji...
Seriously I have lost it; 😆😆
Edited by Stardust91 - 6 years ago
415868 thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: komlika

@ Crusty Honestly I agree with everything you have said

Not blaming mahirji for his reaction because it's how a reasonable person would react in given situation

What I am saying is that even if bela would have come clean earlier as he kept asking her I am not sure that mahirji's reaction would have been any different than what it is right now

He would have still reacted exactly same

His react differently when it comes to bela. Everything goes out of window when it comes to things about bela or related to her. Some times I think he himself doesn't know how he is reacting regards to bela

He himself have confessed that she makes him forget who he is at times 😆

memory loss track 🤢 don't even get me started on that 😡


I agree with you.

He would still be hurt and felt betrayed coz Murders and Fake image created to marry into his family to kill his family members wasn't on his mind... But her direct confession would've made him process it quicker than way he was smashed with truths in haphazard manner.

He trusted her because he knew she was a good person. He still feels she is good otherwise he wouldn't have given her a benefit of doubt n directly bought police. But can't good persons make mistakes and do wrong things?! Shouldn't they be judged for the wrongs they do?!

Both are right in their own place. That's what I am saying. I can't fault both of them because both have their own flaws and insecurities and they balance it out beautifully together. I won't fault Bela for not coming clean soon. Neither would I fault Mahir for reacting the way he did.

komlika thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: Stardust91

P.S. I cannot believe that I am actually arguing against Mahirji's reaction rather than FOR Mahirji...

Seriously I have lost it;😆😆



We have all lost it 🤣 🤣
Stardust91 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: crusty


Redeem from what?! Tell me, you are presented with one IMAGE of a person. When that IMAGE is proven false what would you do?

Willl you fault a person who TRUSTED or the person who BROKE the trust?!

Why is he being pointed out for trusting and loving?! He knew she had secrets but do you think his mind would imagine scenarios of MURDERS and NAAGIN?!

I am not talking about post memory loss Mahir because I simply don't understand this guy. But before this memory loss fiasco what Mahir reacted to was not at all wrong.

And right now, he lost his memory, not his personality. I don't know why they are taking that away from him... He was fair and reasonable always, observant and understanding but this new version is not showing those qualities till now, how can that be gone?! I really do hope it's fake memory loss... I can't stomach this personality transplant they are attempting with him.


I would wonder if the image I had was an image I made or an image I wanted to believe because Bella had not told him anything;

Not revealing a truth is not the same as lying is what I am trying to say . Yuvi is ALIVE and Vikrant is NOT Yuvi

What is bugging me is the way he reacted -- he said himself TUM NAAGIN HO; ICCHA DHARI NAAGIN; it was not like she said I AM A MALEDICTUS and He Who Must Not Be Named will use me as a Horcrux; then he walks away?? if he undersands Naagin and icchadhari naagin rhen he must know that he is living in a world with complexities and fantast and some element of mythology also

OK in his defense i feel he may be observant still -- if you noticed they panned the camera on his face when Bella walked away from Yuvi when he asked her to dance and he looked at her when Sumi was on about naming the kid

it better be fake😭 Sunle EK; and Rangeela -- you need TRPs for Naagin4
komlika thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: crusty



I agree with you.

He would still be hurt and felt betrayed coz Murders and Fake image created to marry into his family to kill his family members wasn't on his mind... But her direct confession would've made him process it quicker than way he was smashed with truths in haphazard manner.

He trusted her because he knew she was a good person. He still feels she is good otherwise he wouldn't have given her a benefit of doubt n directly bought police. But can't good persons make mistakes and do wrong things?! Shouldn't they be judged for the wrongs they do?!

Both are right in their own place. That's what I am saying. I can't fault both of them because both have their own flaws and insecurities and they balance it out beautifully together. I won't fault Bela for not coming clean soon. Neither would I fault Mahir for reacting the way he did.




Exactly they are both right in their place. Can't blame either of them

My only fear is that hope they don't damage the character of Mahirji. The character has shown beautiful growth and now it's on verge of being damaged. I'm having hard time connecting with him post memory loss.

I'm not sure if direct confession would have made any difference in his reaction to it

He never listen or gives bela chance to explain (ex: pregnancy track & wrong confession track)

I'm sure he would have been logical if it was someone other than bela but again as I said she makes him forget himself 😆
415868 thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: Stardust91

Bella IMO might get the benefit of the doubt here because she never ran after Mahirji for his love; she only realised she loved him when she realised what kind of person he was. Even then she only made promises that she knew she could keep like 1. Mahirji i will not let anything wrong happen 2. Mahirji i will never leave you. Whereas Mahir's promises were Bella my heart is yours; mein apne dil tumhare kadmo mein rakhta hun; Bella main tumhare liye KUCH BHI karunga; Bella mein tumhein kabhi galat nahin samjhunga...so Bella thought he would understand


She never ran after Mahir for his love, but she did not deem it important to be plain to him AFTER she knew of his innocence. Why so lenient towards Bela?😆 An innocent man does not deserve an explanation of being CHEATED into a Marriage?!!! 🤔

Apne dil kadom mein rakta hoon... He ALSO said - Main kabhi galat ka saath nahi doonga, tum itna jaanti ho mere bare mein. He ALSO said - Main pani self-respect nahi rakta tumhaare kadmom mein.

You are conveniently forgetting some statements here. We can't be selective in judging one character on one parameter and other on another. right?!

Originally posted by: Stardust91


Vikku is not her lover; Vikku is FAKE; he is another puppet; and Bella did not invite Vikku; he came on his own and was like I am alive and I am back but by then Bella was like I am not leaving Mahir; why didnt mahir looka t it from her POV and think she still chose ME; she picked ME; it is ME she cares about; instead he went on and on about tumhara pehla pyaar


IF Vikku was FAKE why did she NOT send him away? Look at it from his POV. She apparently killed his family for THIS guy. He is FINE. And he is in HIS house disguised as HIS brother and his wife LET him. When Bela herself took SO LONG to figure out Vikku is WRONG then how would you expect Mahir to?😆

Originally posted by: Stardust91

Who has she murdered though -- we are HERE now where NO ONE is murdered; they are all alive; all he had to do was realise why he did it and that she comes from a different universe. This is like he is punishing her for being who she is


This doesn't make an iota of sense. He asked her to seek Law BEFORE he knew of her Naagin truth. AFTER Naagin truth did he ONCE utter about the murders?! He ONLY talked about the cheating, which she DID. DESPITE knowing he is innocent, knowing he deserves truth, she did NOT tell him. Isn't THAT wrong? Wouldn't he fele betrayed for THAT?!

Originally posted by: Stardust91


She is a Naagin; not cursed by a spell to be a maledictus and turn into a snake forever (Ekta you better not get any ideas from this); but even if she was I would hope that the Maahir I know would say that the time he has with her is more than enough even if she was to turn into a snake permanently; he would still be expected NOT to walk away


And HE DID NOT walk away coz she was a SNAKE. HE CLEARLY told he is walking away coz she CHEATED him.

Originally posted by: Stardust91


That would go against his character so he isn't going there; he will have powers but he will not realise until it is TIME; and remember how he reacted when he thought he had killed his sasu ma

I was only giving a hypothetical scenario there. Just so that you would see his POV unbiased.

Originally posted by: Stardust91


I am not saying they should but morality for us in our world and say morality for mythological characters for example is completely different; Just as an EXAMPLE morality for witches and wizards is different from morality in muggles; so Mahir is judging Bella as a muggle whereas she is a magical creature with rules of her own.


He should BEND his own MORALS coz she is a Naagin ? But she should not be expected to respect his MORALS?!
If he should understand it from her POV, so should SHE! Why is only he burdened with all understanding?!
If she is right in her moral perspective, SO IS HE!!! As simple as that!!!

Edited by crusty - 6 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".