The Harvey Weinsteins of Bollywood

ajaajaa thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#1

The Harvey Weinsteins of Bollywood Why women in the film industry don't speak out


Entertainment
Karishma UpadhyayOct, 17 2017 14:09:26 IST
Tweet

For decades, women in Bollywood have warned each other about men who use their positions of power to sexually harass.

There is a much-married, 50-plus character actor who recently forcibly tried to kiss his manager's assistant; a debutant who ran away from her film shoot because she was on the verge of a breakdown after regularly being sexually abused by her director; an actor-director who liked to boast about the size of his penis to the women in his crew; an old-time producer who used to insist on special story sessions in a room that only has a wall-to-wall bed; and, female assistant directors afraid to enter a young A-lister's make-up room because he likes to sit around in his underwear.

This is just the tip of the iceberg from a wider and systemic problem in Bollywood.

Harvey Weinstein. AFP image

It's been a little more than a week since The New York Times uncovered the sordid allegationsagainst multiple Oscar-winner and Hollywood mogul Harvey Weinstein. The long list of women speaking out against the once all-powerful 65-year-old producer includes the likes of Ashley Judd, Gwyneth Paltrow, Angelina Jolie, Rosanna Arquette and Rose McGowan.

The alleged sexual harassment and assault that spanned decades ranged from him demanding women watch him take a shower, massage and/or masturbate him; groping, masturbating into a plant and even forcing sexual intercourse in some cases.

As more women come forward, Hollywood has been forced to admit that Weinstein wasn't a dated anomaly, but a very real and existing problem that's been swept under the carpet for too long.

The story is not very different in Bollywood. For as long as anyone can remember, young women both actresses and technicians chasing fame and fortune in Bollywood have been abused in all sorts of ways by powerful men who dangle jobs or even just access to show business.

Since the Winstein scandal erupted, my timeline is peppered with variations of why isn't someone speaking out against the systemic culture of misogyny within Bollywood'.

The answer to this question is both simple and heartbreaking.

Remember Mahmood Farooqui, the co-director of Peepli [Live]? Last month, the Delhi High Court acquitted Farooqui of raping an American Fullbright scholar, reversing the seven-year imprisonment awarded by a sessions court earlier.

According to the judgment, a "feeble no is actually a "yes in the "instances of woman behavior. It further explained that "feeble hesitation can never be understood as a positive negation of any advances by the other partner. With one stroke, this judgment took back any headway that was made to clarify the complex idea of consent.

This wasn't the only case of sexual misconduct in Bollywood's news cycle this year.

In April, Mumbai Mirror broke news that Vikas Bahl, the director of films like Queen and Shaandaar, was being investigated for sexual assault at Phantom Films, a company that Bahl co-founded with Vikramaditya Motwane, Anurag Kashyap and Madhu Mantena. A young employee of the company alleged that Bahl "forced himself on her during a trip to Goa.

The report also quoted a Phantom "stakeholder claiming that there were "multiple victims. Bahl at the time had denied all charges. Six months later, the director seems to have escaped unscathed from what had the potential to be career-ending allegations. Not only does Bahl continue to be a part of Phantom Films, he is at the helm of the Hrithik Roshan starrer based on the life of math genius Anand Kumar.

TVF CEO Arunabh Kumar.

The allegations against Bahl had followed an even more explosive scandal when The Viral Fever (TVF) founder, Arunabh Kumar was accused by a slew of women on social media of sexual harassment in March this year. Kumar's initial response to the allegations was "I am a heterosexual, single man and when I find a woman sexy, I tell her she's sexy but this is only done in my personal capacity. I compliment women in my personal space and not at the workplace. Is that wrong?

Three months after the allegations first came to light and two FIRs were filed, Kumar stepped down as CEO of TVF in June. He might have left his company, but he can be seen reprising his role of Yogi in the promo for season two of Pitchers, TVF's flagship show.

Three high profile cases of sexual transgression and the outcome for all was similar the alleged perpetrators faced little or no consequences.

A largely unorganised industry, Bollywood continues to be unequipped to handle sexual harassment complaints. Normal routes of protection HR complaints, direct confrontation and the police don't work for women in most conventional industries (sexual harassment is rampant in every single industry from medicine to manufacturing around the world) and film sets are anything but regular workspaces.

Recently, when I mentioned the young A-lister with the penchant for lounging around in his underwear in his make-up room to people from the industry, few saw it as troubling behavior. "Boys will be boys and "these things happen on a film set I was told.

Now, imagine if this beefy actor worked in a regular office and sat naked in his cubicle or decided to strip down in the middle of a meeting. In the real world, he'd be hauled up for harassment and indecent exposure, but in Bollywood he is called quirky.

When it comes to sexual harassment, the burden of proof unfortunately lies with the victim. How does a female technician then prove that her colleague groped her breast on set? Or, a journalist prove that an actor invited her into his study to show off his movie collection and then whipped out his penis? Or a struggling singer prove that a legendary singer forced her to watch him masturbate? Or how does an actress prove that she lost out on a film because she refused to give into the director's demands?

It's hard for those who have never experienced predatory sexual assault to understand the effect it has on the individual, but trust me when I say your first thought is not to document evidence.

I am not naming names because either the incidences didn't happen to me or (in the instances that it did) there's the crippling fear that no one would believe me. I want to believe that there are more enlightened men in Bollywood today but I am realistic enough to know that men still dominate this industry.

In just the last year, three men with connections to Bollywood have gotten away with sexual harassment. It is clearly not enough for just women to speak out. It is imperative that woke men challenge Bollywood's hyper masculine bro-code and call out sexual predators.

Comedian Tig Notaro, while talking about the Weinstein scandal to Steven Colbert said abusers are "everywhere, but the scandal is "cracking the glass. Hopefully, this noisy sisterhood that #MeToo has brought together online cracks some glass in Bollywood as well.


Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

2k

Users

9

Likes

36

Frequent Posters

TotalBetty thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
"No" means "Yes" in India? And the rapist was acquitted?


Is it the judge's personal experience? He assumes "Yes" when the woman says "No"?

I think Western Women should stop taking risks unless they absolutely have to visit India, and even then don't get caught alone

But once in Delhi, a western woman jumped out of a high storey hotel room window bcz the hotel manager was trying to break into her room
ajaajaa thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: ---Betty---

"No" means "Yes" in India? And the rapist was acquitted?



Is it the judge's personal experience? He assumes "Yes" when the woman says "No"?

I think Western Women should stop taking risks unless they absolutely have to visit India, and even then don't get caught alone

But once in Delhi, a western woman jumped out of a high storey hotel room window bcz the hotel manager was trying to break into her room


iirc that judge said something about feeble no or some shit - disgusting man
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/sep/26/a-feeble-no-may-mean-yes-indian-court-overturns-conviction
^ here is the article.


Wow, i didn't know that happened, it's a shame there has been many rape cases that you really can't keep up :/
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
India has many many such stories.
But it is all swept under the rug as industry is heavily male dominated, unorganised, unprofessional, unregulated and even has influence of criminal elements who ensure anyone exposing industry gets destroyed.

Advaita Kala, Rajeev Masand and Swara Bhaskar recently spoke to The Print about about it.

Someone please post that article.

Cases here remain confined to gossip forums or magazines. Even if someone comes out he or she is labelled psycho, publicity seeker or attention seeker.


Look at Southern industry too and see how industry was silent at molestation of an actress by goons of Dileep. That actor's fans welcomed him outside jail and threatened journalists, female stars, activists who spoke against him.

Fans and PR also defend their icons passionately and think he or she can commit no crime. Media covers up cases or starts blaming victims instead.

People remain quiet all their lives. Rekha was abused when she started out as a teen artiste. She never spoke about it openly.

Some think people willingly sleep around and later laugh off claims of sexual harassment saying this is routine or all of it is consensual. As if a legendary filmmaker or singer or star does a favour by paying attention to anyone and anyone would die to be in his arms or his bed.🤢
TotalBetty thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: ajaajaa


iirc that judge said something about feeble no or some shit - disgusting man
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/sep/26/a-feeble-no-may-mean-yes-indian-court-overturns-conviction
^ here is the article.


Wow, i didn't know that happened, it's a shame there has been many rape cases that you really can't keep up :/






When regular people are affected I don't see as much outrage as I see for casting couch

This story is so ugly

She repeatedly said "No", yet he forced himself on her, restrained her arms when she tried to stop him from removing her clothes

Later she went along out of fear of becoming another Nirbhaya and had to fake orga*sm to make him stop

Another case

"It is the second legal decision to draw outrage in recent days, after three law students were granted bail last week while appealing against a sexual assault conviction from March.

The students were convicted of using nude photographs of a woman to blackmail her into having sex with them over an 18-month period. Releasing the students on bail, the Punjab and Haryana high court said the victim's behaviour could be interpreted as a "misadventure stemming from a promiscuous attitude and a voyeuristic mind.

The court said her story did not "throw up gut-wrenching violence that normally precede or accompany such incidents.

Because the rape was not gut-wrenchingly violent, it's okay? What is wrong with Indian legal system?

Edited by ---Betty--- - 7 years ago
MercurialMedusa thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#6
Most recently a BB contestant harassed a foreign contestant and said the exact same words to her when she protested "a woman's no is actually her yes" 🤢
Krantikari thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#7
To be completely FRANK, IMO a major reason why these women are the subject of such cases of harassment is due to a lack of solidarity amongst themselves. Women are much harsher critics of each other than men, and this is what men take advantage of. Men in the industry cover up for each other and have each other's backs. This is how criminals like Sanjay Dutt get away with (literally) murder! And superstars like the Khans also take advantage of their Khan brand and stick up for each other when one (or more) of them is going through a rough patch. Because eventually the good 'karma' comes back to them in the end because their Khan brand still sustains. Every single Khan has enjoyed a period (long or short) of being number 1, and this has benefitted all three of them.

Have you seen women doing the same? Rarely, maybe. But not often enough. We hardly see any cases of women propping each other up, especially when one of them is successful because of the fierce competition between each other. Men in Bollywood take advantage of this and divide and conquer. Women get locked up in petty issues like obsessing over their weight, fashion, magazine covers, driving a media circus, getting back at silly exes, chasing after married men, going to Hollywood to compete with other actresses, boasting about being a working mom, complaining non-stop about nepotism without doing anything substantial to change anything & dragging feminism through the mud by making inflammatory & uncouth remarks due to a personal agenda.

With this LONG list of things to do, how and where will they get the time to actually focus on doing things that actually matter.


Am I victim blaming? No. I just think everyone should start taking accountability of their own actions first before pointing fingers at others. If you want change, better start with yourself. Be the change. People will be forced to give you the respect that you deserve.
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: -Goldendew-

Most recently a BB contestant harassed a foreign contestant and said the exact same words to her when she protested "a woman's no is actually her yes" 🤢


Indians have horrible mindset when it comes to this.

And cinema, TV have contributed a lot to this no means yes, naa mein haa stereotype.

Indian court legitimised this by that horrendous judgement!

No means No. No way does no mean a yes! (Regardless of gender)


bips thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 7 years ago
#9
Not specific to india at all... Read some of the rape judgements in USA especially when it concerns athletes in university... A recent judgement have the rapist 3 months as punishment for rape.. 3 months!!!
.
Its the same in every damn country.. We are just second class citizens... The judiciary does not want to inconvenience the men with silly things like sexual assault and violence punishments...
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: bips

Not specific to india at all... Read some of the rape judgements in USA especially when it concerns athletes in university... A recent judgement have the rapist 3 months as punishment for rape.. 3 months!!!

.
Its the same in every damn country.. We are just second class citizens... The judiciary does not want to inconvenience the men with silly things like sexual assault and violence punishments...


It is about who has power, resources, who controls capital, production and in whose name do dynasties go.

The men of course!

That's why they get away with anything. And often women also support them. Nirbhaya rapists' families also defended them like crazy despite knowing extent of brutality of their crime. That's because those rapists were source of livelihood.

Women are thought of replaceable everywhere be it family or work. That's why no one takes their issues seriously.

And women being harsh on other women only worsens problem further.

See how so called empowered liberal women remained quiet on RK Pachauri, Tarun Tejpal and Mahmood Farooqui!

And how seemingly independent Anusha Rizvi defended Mahmood Farooqui in that rape case. Wives defend husband blindly despite knowing he was wrong. Because they rely on him for wealth, social security, connections.

Sexual harassment kya even rape doesn't seem like crime to men because they are used to it as a routine. They never see what's the big deal about it. Unless it affects their own daughter or sister.

Related Topics

Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: khan.baba

23 days ago

2000s decade bollywood music Vs 2010s decade - More memorable era

Not posting super popular songs of both era but few underrated one for 2000s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l9zYeIqCGHw for 2010s...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l9zYeIqCGHw
Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: mintyblue

25 days ago

2016 was a really good year for Bollywood - throwback post

2012 is often hailed as one of the best years for Bollywood — and rightly so — but 2016 deserves to be in that conversation too. It was a year...

Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood

1 months ago

Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: sentimentalfool

a month ago

Which Bollywood actor (male) should do an item song?

I'm tired of item songs just being done by female actors. It's high time some hottie showed what he got think about us ladies please!!! So, who...

Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: mintyblue

1 months ago

Saiyaara album reminds me of how Bollywood music used to be

It’s not often that an album quietly slips into your playlist and ends up carving a permanent space in your heart. Saiyaara is that rare gem....

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".