Who is the bigger Culprit - Jai or Pushka

Pushkars Crime

Jai was like a father to Pushkar. He supported and mentored him. PP loved each other but Pia decided to marry Jai. Pushkar did not reveal to Jai about himself and Pia. Than on the day of the wedding he ran away with the bride-to-be from the mandap leaving his father figure to be humiliated in front of the whole world

Jai's Crime

Jai drunk out of his mind let's himself be seduced by the estranged wife of the man who he brought up as a son. Pushkar in helping bani decieve Jai was responsible for Jai's condition to a certain extent. Since than Jai has been hiding the affair. He is decieving Pushkar by letting Pushkar believe the child Pia is carrying is Pushkar's. He is sletting Pia blackmail him to spend time with her

Who is the bigger offender? Or do their crimes cancel each other out.

There are sacred vows between PP and there were none between JP

Meg,

Good question. The answer is simple- even if the ONS actually happened it would still be Pushky. His act was a cold-blooded premeditated act whereas the latter act was really an accident. JW was drunk and completely shattered and it was Pia who led him on when it happened.

Expecting lots of jootas and belans for this.

Rgds,

Pri

Originally posted by: majumdar

Meg,

Good question. The answer is simple- even if the ONS actually happened it would still be Pushky. His act was a cold-blooded premeditated act whereas the latter act was really an accident. JW was drunk and completely shattered and it was Pia who led him on when it happened.

Expecting lots of jootas and belans for this.

Rgds,

Pri

Pri,

It can be said that Pia also emotionally manipulated Pushkar into thinking that three lives would be destroyed if the wedding happened. Also since returning to India what Jai has been doing is pre-meditated - the coverup and the running around with Pia (granted he is being blackmailed). Just playing devils advocate here.

Meghna

Meg,

Fair point. But Pushky could have saved the situation by making a clean breast to JW rather than running away. Finally, had the first crime not happened, the second would never have happened.

Rgds,

Pri

i think the biggest mistake is of puskar not becoz he humiliated jai walia infront of the whole world. but he shouldnt throw pia out of his house when she got aborted to his child.
if he didnt throw her out his house then she wouldnt get close to jai walia.!!
aur hamara jai bani ka hota!

Originally posted by: majumdar

Meg,

Good question. The answer is simple- even if the ONS actually happened it would still be Pushky. His act was a cold-blooded premeditated act whereas the latter act was really an accident. JW was drunk and completely shattered and it was Pia who led him on when it happened.

Expecting lots of jootas and belans for this.

Rgds,

Pri

I totally agree with you Pri. Pushkar could have easily told Jai about his feelings for Pia, but he decided to go the hard way. Deliberately.
Actually, when Pia wanted to go back from the airport to the mandap, it was Pushkar who emotionally blackmailed her and told her to make a choice.

Neither Jai nor Pusky is to be blamed. As they were both seduced by PIA. SHE IS THE REAL CULPRIT.

Jai is a bigger Culprit -

But I expected a lot more from JW, a successful,experienced,middle aged man, Business tycoon ...come on he should know how to judge people and he got carried away by pia.

And for being drunk, this guy is not new to it. He got away from roshini before so why couldn't he push pia away or even stop and return back to his room ...

Pushky and Jai both acted like idiots with a common problem - Pia!😕

I won't say they're no at fault, but what happened was due to the circumstances, and Pia!

As for the bigger culprit..........unless Jai does something, Mr. Walia is definetly the one!!