Created

Last reply

Replies

136

Views

15187

Users

21

Likes

418

Frequent Posters

aish. thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
You make absolutely zero sense.
Just saying child marriage works for some and comparing it to GOT speaks volumes.
There's something called Indian law. Read it up once in a while.
ErisedWitch45 thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: ..Khushi..


I didn't say anything, again you perceived it your way because that's how you look at things. Child marriage is progressive or not, how can you decide? It may work for some and not work for some. How it turned out for many Indians, doesn't decide whether it's good or bad for all other beings around the globe.


@bold - That is for marriage. not child marriage. Marriage between 2 consenting adults who are deemed rational. That may work for some or may not work for some.


Originally posted by: ..Khushi..

My comment on stalking is again how you perceived it. Not everyone following someone is stalking. Intent makes all the difference. But you seem to blindly follow a standard definition for everything. What our country is seeing is a result of airheads and messed up heads who lack the power of judgement. No third party can be blamed for the choices one makes and the thinking one develops. Just because most people in our country used child marriage in a horrid way doesn't mean it's horrid. Horrid are the people.. and trust me no amount of morally strong shows will help in shaping anyone. It will be ultimately their own choice.

Also, whether I am young or stupid is entirely my problem.


A quick google search will show you how horrid child marriage is. Govt has made it illegal coz of the myriad problems - mental and physical associated with it. The laws in place are not just for fun. CM is a huge problem prevalent in India (esp North India) and has traumatised many kids. 
We all know the TRP audience in our country. If educated folks here (who can type in English, has laptop/internet) don't take a stand then all that education and civility is good for nothing. Small steps at a time :) 
ErisedWitch45 thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: ..Khushi..


GOT is full of much more messed up shit. Do not give me excuse that it's a historical series set in some fantasy land. Either talk right and wrong by putting everything in the equal ground or don't talk at all.


GOT is NOT aired at prime time on a channel accessible to all. The target audience for both shows are completely poles apart. GOT is not meant to be a family show. PPK was meant to be - hence airing it at a primetime slot. And yes, HIstorical and fanatsy are not excuses. That's what makes a massive difference. ALso and most importantly, GOT shows child abuse as crime.  The characters who engage in child abuse/child marriage - Ramsay, Roose, Little finger etc are villains, not heroes.

Comparison with GOT will bring down your entire argument coz PPK doesn't even cover 0.00000001% of the complexity that GOT is.
Edited by ErisedWitch45 - 6 years ago
..Khushi.. thumbnail
Anniversary 17 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: aish.

You make absolutely zero sense.

Just saying child marriage works for some and comparing it to GOT speaks volumes.
There's something called Indian law. Read it up once in a while.



You live in a age and among the people who deeply rely on fiction to shape up the real world and the society. That itself screams that this world is as good as doomed 😆
ErisedWitch45 thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: surabhi01

only ppk crictizer know what is illegal or legal .thanks for eye opening otherwise v would have never known child marriage is illegal


Nope. Any sane, civilised and educated person knows this.
..Khushi.. thumbnail
Anniversary 17 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: ErisedWitch45


GOT is NOT aired at prime time on a channel accessible to all. And yes, HIstorical and fanatsy are not excuses. That's what makes a massive difference. ALso and most importantly, GOT shows child abuse as crime.  The characters who engage in child abuse/child marriage - Ramsay, Roose, Little finger etc are villains, not heroes.

Comparison with GOT will bring down your entire argument coz PPK doesn't even cover 0.00000001% of the complexity that GOT is.



Not aired in prime time but much more talked/discussed about around the Globe than some prime time show you are referring to. Do you filter the population that is getting engaged in these discussions? Have you seen teenagers nowadays who take proud in being bad-ass, villain, dark. Are you sure that after watching GOT every single person is driven towards what's right? How is showing crime as crime helping in anyway? There are people who take good lessons from it but there are also people who take bad lessons from it. Than why show such things at all? And to see you supporting it 😆
surabhi01 thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 0 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 0 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 6 years ago
so u want to say v r uncivilized if v watch this show

see
ErisedWitch45 thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: ..Khushi..


Not aired in prime time but much more talked/discussed about around the Globe than some prime time show you are referring to. Do you filter the population that is getting engaged in these discussions? Have you seen teenagers nowadays who take proud in being bad-ass, villain, dark. Are you sure that after watching GOT every single person is driven towards what's right? How is showing crime as crime helping in anyway? There are people who take good lessons from it but there are also people who take bad lessons from it. Than why show such things at all? And to see you supporting it 😆


Wait what? Showing crime as crime is not okay as per you? You seem to have taken a big shock from PPK news. Let me explain. Every hindi movie has a hero = who is good and a villain = who is bad. Villain does bad things and gets punished. Not only hindi movie but every movie and every serial shows this. Showing crime as crime is okay. Showing crime as cute and frienship is not. Do you comprehend now?
ErisedWitch45 thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: surabhi01

so u want to say v r uncivilized if v watch this show

see


Nope. read my comment again. I didnt say zilch about you. You were wondering what type of people know about child marriage being a crime. I answered that. Here is a refresher.

Originally posted by: ErisedWitch45

 

Nope. Any sane, civilised and educated person knows this.

..Khushi.. thumbnail
Anniversary 17 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: ErisedWitch45


@bold - That is for marriage. not child marriage. Marriage between 2 consenting adults who are deemed rational. That may work for some or may not work for some.

Physical age is not a marker for rationality.



A quick google search will show you how horrid child marriage is. Govt has made it illegal coz of the myriad problems - mental and physical associated with it. The laws in place are not just for fun. CM is a huge problem prevalent in India (esp North India) and has traumatised many kids. 
We all know the TRP audience in our country. If educated folks here (who can type in English, has laptop/internet) don't take a stand then all that education and civility is good for nothing. Small steps at a time :) 



INDIAN government has made it illegal because many Indians have turned it into something horrid. It's the people not the practice. It's legal in the US you see. Once educated folks gain enough sense to differentiate between what's real and what's fictional, they may go out and do some real service for good. If they themselves start regarding fiction as reality and jump to online sites as keyboard warriors saving a virtual world, than God save this country 😆