Let's discuss Pink - Spoilers alert

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

-Abhiya-

@-Abhiya-

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 8 years ago

#61

They didn't took any money

Falak accepted out of desperation and out of heat moment

they never took any money

She had a valid point there

She said what if they took money No means No

when Meenal said No Rajbeer shouldn't touch her

This is the msg of the movie

NO WOULD MEAN NO INSPITE OF ANY OTHER HINTS GUYS ASSUME

Quote

-Abhiya-

@-Abhiya-

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 8 years ago

#62

I wanted to love Tapasee as Meenal but I loved Falak and Andrea more

Specially Falak that girl was flawless

Also the judge did an awesome job

And Angad Bedi was also gud

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Don't worry, be happy.

@Ranbirrocks

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 8 years ago

#63

Originally posted by: -Abhiya-
I wanted to love Tapasee as Meenal but I loved Falak and Andrea more
Specially Falak that girl was flawless
Also the judge did an awesome job
And Angad Bedi was also gud

Judge was great. SHO woman also played her part very well. Poor lady had to act in front of Mr B!!

Quote

-Abhiya-

@-Abhiya-

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 8 years ago

#64

Originally posted by: Ranbirrocks

Judge was great. SHO woman also played her part very well. Poor lady had to act in front of Mr B!!

oh yes I forgot her that woman was awesome goli ki speed se jeep bhagayi maine😆

Quote

blue-ice.

@blue-ice.

Achiever

+ 4

Posted: 8 years ago

#65

Originally posted by: Ranbirrocks
If you haven't seen the moive , please don't read ahead. It'll spoil your movie experience .

I am still under spell of movie !!
One thing was not clear . Did girls go to resort for money? Did the Falak crack a deal and Minal changed her mind? Why did she accept that she took money?
Or was she so exasperated by questioning that she decided to own it and end her misery .
I thought she just wanted to get out of her misery but a few friends are saying that it was cleverly left out for interpretation.

Also, that scene in car with Minal 🤢 . They didn't show anything but I was harrowed by last bit 🤢

ETA
Found tweets of KRK. He is such a douche

The way they have unfolded story, I think 99% ppl didn't understand that those 3girls go for money n that's why ppl have sympathy for them.
Makers of #PINK should be very happy that ppl don't understand the film so ppl think, girls are Shareef n innocent so all sympathy with If I will die without food still I will not allow my daughter to stay alone little far away from house to earn extra money by wrong doing.

Thanks for this thread RR...a thread for discussion was very much needed as I don't want the review thread to be cluttered...I had opened one but looks like it got merged😆

No the girls did not take money or made a deal...even Deepak Saigal made it clear...she just said it because so much emphasis was being put on taking the money and they were totally missing the point of CONSENT...so ahe said it to get it out of their way.

Quote

1011128

Suspended

Posted: 8 years ago

#66

Thank God this is not

Lets discuss Pak

lol

Quote

Fantasia.

@Fantasia.

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 8 years ago

#67

I think Meenal took money .. bcz the way Meenal slaps falak and she says i am sorry .. i think she used to take money but that night she didnt ..

what a brilliant movie!

Quote

Fantasia.

@Fantasia.

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 8 years ago

#68

Finsihed PINK.

Beautiful, brilliant and brilliant - that is the only word.

The movie was brilliant because it moved around a single point - NO MEANS A NO.

Piase liye hain ya nahi liye hain, sharaab pi hai ya nahi pi hai .. biwi hai ya jism bechne wali hai .. NO MEANS NO, and the BOYS need to understand THIS.

Its not the question of a good or a bad girl, a pious or a lose character girl, a muslim, hindu or a christian girl - its about a NO. A NO. If she says NO, she means NO and the man bloody needs to step BACK.

The movie had some extra ordinary scenes - the virginity scene - EXCELLENT. The cross questioning about consensual and forced sex was brilliant.

The cross questioning of Lawyer Prashant and Falak - where she admits about taking money! EXCELLENT! Where she looks at the judge, "paise liye your honour but she withdrew her consent!", i had goose bumps at the dialogue!

Rajbir and Amitabh cross questioning - excellent, the seething anger and how Amitabh slowly uncovered his mysoginy was brilliant.

I loved how they used reverse physchology to highlight how girls were harassed with simple gestures - hans k baat mat karo, akele mat jao , - the whole idea of the rule book for girls safety was excellent.

i LOVED the movie, it was gripping it was suspense, it was intriguing and most importantly it left a mysetery.

Did Falak take money or not? Did Meenal take money or not? Bcz the way meenal slaps falak, that made me think maybe meenal took money ..

WHat was amitabh's past story? What happened with him that he was so affulent about a NO?

What happened to his wife?

A brilliant movie with the PERFECT casting right from the female SHO to the prosecution lawyer to the boys and the girls and ofcourse Amitabh Bachchan!!

Recently reading news that he is not supportive of Ash and wants a grandson and crap made me dislike him but i see his calibre and i am in love with him all over again. I have no concern whatever he does in hsi personal life because lets admit no one has a proof that he is a douche bag, what i have a proof of is that he is a brilliant performer and seeing him is a magnificent experience.

A MUST MUST watch! The movie should be a super hit!

Quote

chachichampa

@chachichampa

Voyager

+ 4

Posted: 8 years ago

#69

No they didnt take the money. However the lawyer was harping on and on about how they took the money which is why she said Yes I took the money but then I returned it and said no and they still tried to rape me. That was to prove the point that there was no consent. She was trying to make the point that money or no money there should be consent. She just wanted the took money point out of the equation and show that it wasnt the crux of the matter. They didnt actually take the money - they wanted to make the strong point that without consent in any case it is rape. She just wanted him to stop harping on about the money as that was his main point of attacking them - so she got that out of the way.

Quote

TheRager

@TheRager

Achiever

+ 4

Posted: 8 years ago

#70

Few things that struck me:

Earlier in some articles I had read Big B has bipolar disorder but nothing was shown except he was taking some medication and acted weird.

The SHO who registered a false FIR-When it was proved that it was fake she should have been punished too

The SHO said they were searching for Meenal for a week when Meenal was going on with her usual routine activities. They should have proved that she was lying.

There is a point where Meenal's father wants her to return home. She even packs and leaves but is back at her friend's house in the next scene.

I loved it when Big B shows Rajbir that even his sister drinks when Rajbir questions the character of the girls because they drink.