Show's weakest aspect

Page

Next Last

Nu_Adu

@Nu_Adu

Navigator

Posted: 13 years ago

So the worst thing the makers have shown in the 90 or so episodes of Madhubala, according to me, is RK's background.

First problem is the logic they are using to justify his character. He was very close to his dad. One day the father dies, leaving him shocked and shattered. His mother remarries for his sake...so? How does that give him any reason to hate his mom for life? Or to turn into a heartless monster?

Second problem is the mom's entry. A police case is filed against RK. The police come to his house to escort him to jail for 4 days. He repeatedly tries to bribe victim's family to save his own self. He makes his master plan to manipulate Madhu's life, buys Mukund's mom, uses Trishna/Roma as pawns, and arranges the engagement. Madhu and Malik visit him at home to call press conference. His love announcements on tv. The photos in the paper. News reports. SO MUCH happens and his 'mom', step father and brother are not in the picture???? How realistic is that?? And then he beats life out of Malik, leading up to the dhamakedaar wedding...and all of a sudden a heavy lady in traditional sari is standing at the doorway! 😕

Just to make things a tiny bit realistic they could've shown that his family doesn't live with him. And why does he live with his mom if he hates her so much??? I have no clue.

And third problem is his mom's character/appearance. Why does she look like a typical housewife in heavy sari and jewelry?? Does a superstar's mom and wife of a producer REALLY look like that? 😳

And she also makes sabzi in the kitchen for a son who doesn't even acknowledge her as mother...what was she expecting??? RK will come and eat from her hands and then kiss her goodbye??

Very poor logic used by creatives. I feel this aspect has hurt the story quite a bit.

Edited by Nu_Adu - 13 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

bussbuzz

@bussbuzz

Explorer

Posted: 13 years ago

the first two logics of urs are 100 PERCENT TRUE!!! i mean sslly ... silly logics of the CVs ... but about the mother thingy , i think shes wearing normal clothes , shes not into showbiz , doesnt live with her son all the time and neither she is in the media so why not dress normal ? and even superstar's moms can be smartly dressed all the time , thats her personal style and about the sabzi thingy .. she didnt know rk wud see and a mother is a mother after all ... but then again the major drawback is rks BG ... to complete it they need a girl who broke his heart kinda thing .. then it might be balanced a bit...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

FireSafireFire (Marvelousfire)

@FireSafireFiree

Sparkler

+ 8

Posted: 13 years ago

Agree in some aspect, however we dont know the full story...

Lets see.. Was rk tortured by his step dad?

If this is added and explained little more than i can see why he is like that...nif he went through violent past... Maybe little flashback of that.. Again.. We dont know yet.. Maybe more to be reviled later.

Mother- we still don't know the reason behind her remarriage... Was it for RK.. Or was she forced?

Kuku ji was in bankok.. So can understand that... Mother... Rk did mention... 'there are some pain that you have to keep close by... Otherwise pain it self can be forgotten'

I agree they have spend so much time on rks chracter .. That they have completly forgotten his family.. I think well there are still posibility for the writer to build rks family members chracter little more to give us clear photo.. And to feel the deep impact on his life.

However so far i think they have done great..

I hope they include those above point slowly maybe bcs if they show rks past little by little like they r doing now.. I think later there will be greater impact on audiance.

So i am still waiting for rks family to build up like madhus have.

Edited by FIRESafiReFIRE - 13 years ago

Quote

Anuradha

@rasika123

Beginner

Posted: 13 years ago

I agree. They should have shown some strong reason for him being a heartless ...with this BG even I couldn't sympathize/justfy his behavior with Madhu. Instead if he loves his father so much ...he shouldn't torture Madhu's father ... he should respect every father figure then. They haven't built RK's current character with any strong basis ...finally truth reamins same ...watch serial wothout any brains 😆 and enjoy if could.

Quote

nitya

@nitya

Navigator

Posted: 13 years ago

Well all i wud say is raj zusti said makers have done some changes in d track resently and wen there's sudden change in plan minor discripencies r bound 2 happen. It better 2 ignour small things in name of creative liberty and enjoy d bigger picture.

Quote

Nu_Adu

@Nu_Adu

Navigator

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: rasika123
I agree. They should have shown some strong reason for him being a heartless ...with this BG even I couldn't sympathize/justfy his behavior with Madhu. Instead if he loves his father so much ...he shouldn't torture Madhu's father ... he should respect every father figure then. They haven't built RK's current character with any strong basis ...finally truth reamins same ...watch serial wothout any brains 😆 and enjoy if could.

That is right. What RK did to Malik is unforgivable. Madhu should not forgive him for that as long as she lives.

In fact, Padmini and Madhu's life is FAR MORE tragic than RK's silly childhood excuse. So how come Madhu didn't become a beast like RK? Madhu should confront RK and ask him this question!

Quote

TheBlackJaguar

@TheBlackJaguar

Trailblazer

+ 5

Posted: 13 years ago

Completely disagree.

1. You can never predict how any human mind is going to react to a certain situation or how it is going to shape them as an individual. Rishabh has been shown as a hypersensitive 12 year old whose father's death's mystery is yet to be revealed - as his mom has mentioned ' that one super traumatic night' . He could not accept his mother's second marriage , had a terrible relationship with his step relatives and he became alienated. So, what you have today is basically a frustoo lost 12 year old locked in past. Besides , who knows Rishabh's whole story? Nobody. You have only seen it in bits and parts.

2. Rishabh is living in his house , his father's house as Kukku Bhatia mentioned. Why should he go anywhere? Its his house and he is putting up with them because of his mother. He is just paying back the blood bond.

3. Yes, numerous industry wives move around like Rishabh's mom. And no, am not talking about immediate Bollywood.

4. Creatives never justify Rishabh's behaviour - they just tell you where he is coming from and that his problem is a troubled lonely childhood.

5. When Rishabh was in jail, the casting and the story points had not been locked, except Razaa Muraad. That is why you got the Bangkok excuse.

The logics of the creatives are totally in place - its just that you perceive the situation with a different POV.

Edited by TheBlackJaguar - 13 years ago

Quote

FireSafireFire (Marvelousfire)

@FireSafireFiree

Sparkler

+ 8

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: Nu_Adu

That is right. What RK did to Malik is unforgivable. Madhu should not forgive him for that as long as she lives.

In fact, Padmini and Madhu's life is FAR MORE tragic than RK's silly childhood excuse. So how come Madhu didn't become a beast like RK? Madhu should confront RK and ask him this question!

i think this question will be asked later.. To be honest if she ask him this now..i hink it will be too soon...

Madhu have no clue about his past you have to understand that. She knows only wha we know..

There still lot to come.

Quote

Nu_Adu

@Nu_Adu

Navigator

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: nitya
Well all i wud say is raj zusti said makers have done some changes in d track resently and wen there's sudden change in plan minor discripencies r bound 2 happen. It better 2 ignour small things in name of creative liberty and enjoy d bigger picture.

I wouldn't be complaining if his mom, dad and brother fit into the picture. I just can't accept them yet. They look so out of place in this show. They needed to cast stronger actors/actresses to play RK's parents and family I think.

Quote

FireSafireFire (Marvelousfire)

@FireSafireFiree

Sparkler

+ 8

Posted: 13 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: TheBlackJaguar
Completely disagree.

1. You can never predict how any human mind is going to react to a certain situation or how it is going to shape them as an individual. Rishabh has been shown as a hypersensitive 12 year old whose father's death's mystery is yet to be revealed - as his mom has mentioned ' that one super traumatic night' . He could not accept his mother's second marriage , had a terrible relationship with his step relatives and he became alienated. So, what you have today is basically a frustoo lost 12 year old locked in past.

2. Rishabh is living in his house , his father's house as Kukku Bhatia mentioned. Why should he go anywhere? Its his house and he is putting up with them because of his mother. He is just paying back the blood bond.

3. Yes, numerous industry wives move around like Rishabh's mom. And no, am not talking about immediate Bollywood.

4. Creatives never justify Rishabh's behaviour - they just tell you where he is coming from and that his problem is a troubled lonely childhood.

5. When Rishabh was in jail, the casting and the story points had not been locked, except Razaa Muraad. That is why you got the Bangkok excuse.

The logics of the creatives are totally in place - its just that you perceive the situation with a different POV.

I completly agree.. There still lot to come out.. And i so dont want tjis to go in super light speed. Is not a film. Its a daily show.

Quote

1 2 3 4 5 6

Show's weakest aspect

Related Topics

Explore Topics