What is Shabbir Problem in Potryaing Dutta| VB Note p.5

Poll

What is the problem in Shabbir where he is unable to match MR???

Login To Vote
phaneeswar thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#1

I see some thing is missing in Shabbir in potraying Dutta, MR performed extremely well but Shabbir is not able to get into it...I feel that director is unable to extract skills in Shabbir, I think poor direction is playing a spoilsport...I think the director who had directed Dutta entry scene, he standards he maintained was simply superb. I think the director who directed earlier during MR entry should come and direct again so that Shabbir can potray well as Dutta.

Edited by phaneeswar - 14 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

36

Views

5.2k

Users

13

Likes

59

Frequent Posters

jagrutid thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
i don't know what it is exactly but something is surely missing, i would say its just that mishal raheja formed the image of dutta for us and to see him change all of a sudden is going to take time to get used to...
plus there is a lot of difference between the two of them..the whole dialogue delivery stands out to me..plus also the fact is the SA hasnt had much opportunity yet. I think after i see more of his acting as dutta i can't really say.
phaneeswar thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#3

@Jagrutid - the real problem lies in directing, the direction is very poor from past many episodes and adding to it the technical department is not performing upto the mark be it Cinematography, editing or mixing...technicians are not doing good job...I think production house need to rework some of the aspects...as in future the love track kick starts so PH and Channel need to really look into this aspect...

mnx12 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#4

while discussing about Datta, we should remember one thing, this character is played by 2 different actors, each one having their own different style & class, trying to find out the missing pts is not going to help, because what is missing will remain missing now till end. So accept SA the way he portrays Datta's character to enjoy this show, if you are watching. Old cast, director is not going to come back. Comparison will not yields anything but disappointment.

Edited by mnx12 - 14 years ago
Keva thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
For me the problem is he does not care for the character I mean it took him 3 months to realize that he is the lead of the show 😲 and hence he should be given importance. The new replaced dutta was a sidey character since his entry and now they are maybe giving importance to this character but the story has moved so far that it is impossible to watch this crap any longer. I think if they had smoothly transitioned from MR to SA then maybe SA would have worked as a good replacement but the transition was so pathetic that it is impossible to watch this show just coz the character of Dutta is back. This dingu dude was just so pathetic that I seriously do not want to even consider watching this show. On top of that the creatives refuse to kill dingu.😡
They have no story for the show and I watch shows for their stories and not just to see my favorite actors everyday. I mean if you do not have a story then even a fantastic actor cannot do much with his acting.
phaneeswar thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: mnx12

while discussing about Datta, we should remember one thing, this character is played by 2 different actors, each one having their own different style & class, trying to find out the missing pts is not going to help, because what is missing will remain missing now till end. So accept SA the way he portrays Datta's character to enjoy this show, if you are watching. Old cast, director is not going to come back. Comparison will not yields anything but disappointment.

I agree but something has to be done, otherwise the way they are showing some things are really poor, like Dutta meeting his family, Nakku in PN...Deegu revealing to himself that he was behind Dutta kidnap...direction part need to be reworked as the director has one of the best actors in TV industry on board...so they need to utilise them very well...
phaneeswar thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Keva

For me the problem is he does not care for the character I mean it took him 3 months to realize that he is the lead of the show 😲 and hence he should be given importance. The new replaced dutta was a sidey character since his entry and now they are maybe giving importance to this character but the story has moved so far that it is impossible to watch this crap any longer. I think if they had smoothly transitioned from MR to SA then maybe SA would have worked as a good replacement but the transition was so pathetic that it is impossible to watch this show just coz the character of Dutta is back. This dingu dude was just so pathetic that I seriously do not want to even consider watching this show. On top of that the creatives refuse to kill dingu.😡

They have no story for the show and I watch shows for their stories and not just to see my favorite actors everyday. I mean if you do not have a story then even a fantastic actor cannot do much with his acting.

I completely agree with you, script and good direction is key for show success, the standard of direction has fallen drastically. I don't know who is directing it he must be bumped off immediately. Giving much importance to that Deegu is irritating, the transition or MR to SA is totally not good. Initially Shabbir as Dutta has shown promise but I don't know who is spoiling his brilliant acting skills. I think BV serial like director should come on board because if you see in BV direction is really superb that even you can't miss one epi...Aadesh should quit off show immediately, I will be very very happy even if his character is spoiled..rather than other characters like Baaji or AS.
Keva thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: phaneeswar

I completely agree with you, script and good direction is key for show success, the standard of direction has fallen drastically. I don't know who is directing it he must be bumped off immediately. Giving much importance to that Deegu is irritating, the transition or MR to SA is totally not good. Initially Shabbir as Dutta has shown promise but I don't know who is spoiling his brilliant acting skills. I think BV serial like director should come on board because if you see in BV direction is really superb that even you can't miss one epi...Aadesh should quit off show immediately, I will be very very happy even if his character is spoiled..rather than other characters like Baaji or AS.

I have never watched BV coz I have no interest in child marriages and so I cannot say anything regarding the director of BV. According to me, the rest of the characters in the show have been brutally killed. I mean they just replace Dutta in 4 months with another guy that was really shocking I mean seriously how can you replace family members ever. On top of that they did not even bother to look for the guy when he was missing. That is a ridiculous story to begin with. I have no clue why anybody would watch this show. I truly believe that Dutta was better off dead than coming back to this ridiculous family.
phaneeswar thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Keva

Not only that now CV's are focussing on Dutta-Nakusha love track, instead I expected Dutta usual actions like Dokhebaaz, vanishing act, drinking and other stuff atleast for few more epi..so that members in PN can repent on what they have done from past couple of months. We must see how Dutta will react towards Deegu as he was behind of Dutta kidnap...how PN and other react to Deegu...that must be seen...

TheRager thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Keva

For me the problem is he does not care for the character I mean it took him 3 months to realize that he is the lead of the show 😲 and hence he should be given importance. The new replaced dutta was a sidey character since his entry and now they are maybe giving importance to this character but the story has moved so far that it is impossible to watch this crap any longer. I think if they had smoothly transitioned from MR to SA then maybe SA would have worked as a good replacement but the transition was so pathetic that it is impossible to watch this show just coz the character of Dutta is back. This dingu dude was just so pathetic that I seriously do not want to even consider watching this show. On top of that the creatives refuse to kill dingu.😡

They have no story for the show and I watch shows for their stories and not just to see my favorite actors everyday. I mean if you do not have a story then even a fantastic actor cannot do much with his acting.

I voted for 4. SA isnt as polished an actor as Mishal but I still give him the benefit of doubt since his character has hardly been the focus since he has entered. Why its so is anyone's guess. But I agree with Keva in general that after MR's exit they should have smoothly transitioned to SA and moved on with the original story instead of getting a new character as the male lead. Eve now they refuse to let go of him. If they are so desperate for a new character as the male lead they should have shut down LTL and got a new show altogether.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".