Is rajinder's decision correct?

Anuuradha thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
Hello,I'm a new viewer of KarolB. I have been watching KB since pretty long.I saw today RSethi creates his will where he gives his house to his 3 daughters totally depriving his son. Agree that his son had done wrong but was rajinder's decision right? I'm a parent myself and children do make mistakes,even BIG mistakes and parents show them the right way,not kick hin out of the house for ever and leave him alone.. he could have given his son a strict warning or asked him to return the money or ordered him to ask for maafi but rajinder sethi seems to be an over impulsive parent to me.in this way he will not only lose his son but also destro anuj who could be brought to right ways by his parents. what r ur views?
Edited by Anuuradha - 15 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

20

Views

1.8k

Users

12

Likes

14

Frequent Posters

Laila2009 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: Anuuradha

Hello,I'm a new viewer of KarolB. I have been watching KB since pretty long.I saw today RSethi creates his will where he gives his house to his 3 daughters totally depriving his son. Agree that his son had done wrong but was rajinder's decision right? I myself have 2 grown up sons and children do make mistakes,even BIG mistakes and parents show them the right way,not kick hin out of the house and leave their son like rsethi. he could have given his son a strict warning or asked him to return the money or ordered him to ask for maafi but rajinder sethi seems to be an over impulsive parent to me.in this way he will not only lose his son but also destro anuj who could be brought to right ways by his parents. what r ur views?

When an adult son fails to behave in a responsible manner and also steals money from the house, and then fails to admit the wrong doing of his actions, and then hits his sister on top of it when she confronts him (the primary reason he threw him out of the house), then NO, that son does not deserve to have a home.
Here the son is doing something with the full knowledge of what he is doing. It was planned; it was not an impulsive decision. He's also an adult.
A son who has stolen his father's retirement and is intending to steal his house that should in part go his sisters too, then he truly deserves nothing but a swift kick up the rear. Yes, he could ask for the money but that does not mean the son is not held accountable for his actions. What if Abhi had not caught them in the act, then how would the father have asked for the money back?
Anuj is a spoilt brat and the person to blame is his mother who fails to hold him accountable for anything. Simi is also to blame as she keeps shielding her brother, rescuing him and then taking his verbal abuse.
Edited by Laila2009 - 15 years ago
shanti05 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#3
Anuj was also told clearly by his dad Tum Maag lethey paise would'nt I have given you !!

Children make mistakes and parents do forgive them and want all the happiness for their children but Anuj as an adult has done whatever he has done with full knowledge as to what he is doing is never somthing RS would think of forgiving !!
He dose'nt deserve the house or anything to do with RS's propertly unless he comes and apologizes and repents for what he has done!!

At an age where parents see some hope in their children and espically the Son of the house if he does somthing to hurt them then they will be hurt for the rest of the ir life atealst RS
ramas thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#4
RS is correct in his decision as there is no telling what AA will do to get hold of hi property. This way Anuj will know that he is disown by his dad for his wrong doing. and may be he will learn lesson. RS is not completely disowning him he is giving him a shop. So he is right in his decison as anuj is not worthy of getting anything but few slaps and kicks from both parents.
Anuuradha thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#5
Yes,it's Important that Anuj comes and begs for forgiveness BUT I'm not sure what Rajinder will say;I believe that parents have a much greater role than children in the Parent-Children relationship. Like the saying goes You are what you eat,so it is with the parents & their children.How the children have been brought up depends on parents. I found Rsethi to be partial with Anuj, Manju is wrong but she was also shocked to hear her son had stolen,Manju only wanted to stop anuj from leaving 12/24 Karol Bagh. I wish RSethi had shown some more love & confidence towards anuj like he does with simi and mili(again,Neetu is going the wrong way as she feels less loved by her parents and taunted as jhalli ) if there was a strong father-son 'bonding' then anuj wouldn't have felt insecurev and haven't heard to his wife about stealing his parents' money!
And it's not right that because anuj is an adult he cannot be forgiven as he knew what he was doing;if this was right then no adult in this world would make mistakes. that's why it's called mistake.
and if anuj had raised his hand on his sister that was in a moment of anger.in which house don't the brothers and sisters not fight?we used to fight a lot! fights happen in every familiy but does that mean family members who fight do not care about each other?. i wonder how many of u supporting rsethi would do the same if yoyr kids make the same 'mistake'?
It is a different issue that anuj is scheming with his wife to grab the property all for themselves.
but if anuj & anita were not conspiring,was rajinder's decision right?
Edited by Anuuradha - 15 years ago
bobbiedhillon thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#6
I think RS is right.
He forgave Anuj for stealing but the reason why he kicked him out of the house is because Anuj raised his hand on this sister. Anuj is completely wrong in all this. Just because he is a son does not mean he gets the property and not care about his sisters.
He is a selfish so and so. I would have done the same think if it was my son behaving in the same mannter. I think Manju needs to be more supportive of RS than Anuj but I think she is in for a lesson of her life. I hope she goes and lives with Anuj and Anita and finds out just how selfish these two really are.
380701 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#7
Its so simple and doesnt need any explanation. YES RS is right throwing that dirt bag and young witch out of 12/24.
Rumii thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#8
I had a somewhat same view that Rajinder's beahaviour including taunting his son was resposible for Anuj's weak character. even when anuj tried to help his papaJi Rajinder has always taunted him referring to Anuj as ManjuJi's beta😳
It's true that how children turn out to be depends a lot on parenting. I

If a child lives with ridicule, He learns to be shy.

If a child lives with shame, He learns to feel guilty.

Isn't that what Anuj is? Manju Ji is not right in taunting her daughters,similarly Rajinder has also done a lot of harm to Anuj's character by continuous taunting.After all Parenting is Not easy!
Gur.N.cool thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 4 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 15 years ago
#9
I agree with you, it's a big step, and he is only isolating him further. Afterall Anuj is his son, and not a tranger, for how long can he stay away from him. He has over reacted.

I agree Anuj is wrong big time but he wasn't like that always, once Anita came he got bad ideas from her. So he should be given one more chance, if that doesn't work either, then he can give all his property to his daughters.
navtour thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: iamindian

I had a somewhat same view that Rajinder's beahaviour including taunting his son was resposible for Anuj's weak character. even when anuj tried to help his papaJi Rajinder has always taunted him referring to Anuj as ManjuJi's beta😳

It's true that how children turn out to be depends a lot on parenting. I

If a child lives with ridicule, He learns to be shy.

If a child lives with shame, He learns to feel guilty.

Isn't that what Anuj is? Manju Ji is not right in taunting her daughters,similarly Rajinder has also done a lot of harm to Anuj's character by continuous taunting.After all Parenting is Not easy!

I DO NOT AGREE TO THIS.
First of all, u only TAUNT someone if he or she is WRONG.
ANUJ has always been WRONG. He is so SELFISH and STUPID.
So RS was right all through out about him.
now about MANJU, she always TAUNT Simi for no reason at all.
and that makes her so UNFAIR.
and still SIMI loves her unlike ANUJ, he just hates his father.
I strongly believe that RS made the best decision.
this will b a lesson for everyone who gives more IMPORTANCE TO THEIR SONS THAN THEIR DAUGHTERS.
Parents give their 100 percent trust to their siblings.
and STEALING from your PARENTS is UNACCEPTABLE.
no one can ACCEPT THAT. not even GOD. so why should RS let go of it.
RS is the best interpretationl of being a FATHER.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".