Originally posted by: fizzles
@ Rox: Just wanted to bring up Rain Man, since you mentioned it :)
That's gotta be one of my fav films. Dustin Hoffman received a well deserved Oscar for playing the role of an autistic man so well. And he was wonderfully supported by Tom Cruise. I loved the chemistry between the two brothers and how the nature of their relationship changes over time. They begin to develop such a strong connection. And Charlie can see what Ray is capable of, sadly the law doesn't work that way and doesn't feel emotions.
Rain Man was subtle, sincere and touched me in a way that it left me with tears in my eyes. The scenes esp. towards the end of the film between the two brothers were not only wonderfully acted out, the script was very simple yet had the ability to stir emotions within you.
Needless to say, Rain Man is one of my absolute favorite films of all time, putting my obvious bias aside, of course. Dustin Hoffman's performance is one of such unmatched strength and brilliance that we often feel that we are really watching an autistic man on screen. His Autistic, unlike Anil Kapoor's copy, is never annoying or obnoxious, and you always feel for him. Raymond's vacant stare, the monotone voice, the screaming, it was unbelievable. He's nothing less than flat out mesmerizing and his extensive research into autism clearly showing through his impeccably crafted characterization. Seriously....Dustin fearlessly shouldered the emotional center of the story with a character unable to fathom emotions - the fact that he remains endearing, lovable and incessantly credible throughout is a testament to Dustin Hoffman easily deserving every last bit of recognition for such a superb feat. And of course, Tom Cruise equally proves his merit... to morph his arrogant, self-serving yuppie Charlie from a despicably manipulative character to a surprisingly sympathetic man exercising his inner turmoil in a refreshingly fluid and convincing fashion. Like you said, the scene towards the end of the film will make even the most macho of men shed tears.
Now compare this work of art to it's Bollywood rip off, Yuvraaj, and you'll want to shed tears for the intolerable torture of watching Anil Kapoor act like a 6 year old idiot and Salman Khan act as Salman Khan, completely mutating the original Rain Man characters (that they ripped off) beyond the point of recognition.
As for my name is Khan, I don't want to comment on the film too much, since it hasn't released yet. So I cannot make an accurate assessment of the film before I have even seen it. To me, the plus point of the film seems to be the chemistry between SRK and Kajol. As always, they look great together. However, if we look at previous films by Johar, they may have been BO hits but IMO all those films have had fluff but lacked real substance. Hope I don't offend fans of KJo but this is just my personal view.Well, I too love SRK and Kajols' couple, but it seems sort of ridiculous to couple a man, suffering from a disease that makes it impractical for him to know what love is, with the 'love' of his life.
I don't think he is capable of making a film on such a sensitive subject. The chances are that the film will be a success due to the jodi of SRK and Kajol. But whether or not the film will give a correct portrayal of autism, is questionable. For such a subject you need a director that has the capability of directing a film that will not simply "showcase" a disease or mentally challenged individual. The director needs to have vision and needs to do his homework properly. But I have my doubts with Johar, whom I believe is all fluff and candy floss. Exactly, and it's not simply about showcasing a disease or mentally challenged individual. You might as well produce an educational movie on the subject, but the film needs to explore the depths of such individuals.
But not just Karan Johar, there are many directors in Bollywood that make films on sensitive issues but only on a superficial level and don't have it in them to bring real life emotions and circumstances to the big screen. Most are incapable of giving us a film that makes you forget that you're watching a film. Instead, you are constantly reminded that it's just a flick, due to the larger than life appeal of it. It is very important to stick to reality and real emotions, esp. when your film is on a sensitive subject.
44