BarkhaSingh123 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
Hi friends pls don't bash be but honestly tell me am I the only one who thinks ki today's episode was not that bad..
Matlab I read 2 posts .. where people said it was a sort of not acceptable for sanskaar to say ki agar tum ragini ki jagha hoti toh.. n so on..
Guys I think ki sanskaar somewhat knew the situation .. n he was at that time too broken his own life was no less than a hell.. his own swara accused him of being a murderer n all so he did not concentrate much on shomi n also I think Raglak did not try to drag him much in the situation because they too knew his condition...
Sanskaar n infact Raglaktried their best to make people understand ki it is no problem if shomi is pregnant but even after like two or three efforts(as shown ) no one seems to understand their point..
Also I found Ragini's dialogues so much justified.. she never said she was correct but instead she agreed she was wrong n she too agreed that she chose a coward's way.. I don't think it anyhow justified ragini's FP.
Also the dialogue in which ragini stated ki swara is brave enough to fight this world but ragini herself accepted that she lacks those guys .. does this justify the FP like really.. I don't think so..
I think it just discribes ragini's situationas per her character..
Next problematic thing was ki the comparative dialogue b/w swaragini. .. wasn't that true.. ki if swara was in same situation she could have handled it better n it's so much true but ragini didn't justify her act there too.. she didn't say the way she chose was r8 or the FP was justified but simply accepted her fault...

N last but not the least was swara saying I am sorry or something to ragini.. u don't think it was an apology on serious note I think elder bro or sis sometimes say such things to comfort their siblings(like I also say ki sorry Bhai Teri side nahi LI par tune galti ki.. isn't it similar to that).. huh.. idk guys I am r8 or wrong may be I am wrong but pls Don't bash me instead leave ur replys so that I can correct myself...

In short I think the whole hall scene didn't justify fp or ragini n neither it justified using a wrong path ... But it was just a short convo clearing about the conditions Raglak faced n their lack of courage to fight for the truth.. which simply says ki Bhai kam galat tha par intension acha tha...

Pks pls pls no bashing.. apni choti Behan samjhk pyar se.smajhado ki y u feel that I am wrong...
The purpose of the post is not to justify rags or do but to discuss y u all felt that dialogues n scene was justifying things unnecessarily...
Edited by harshitaloomba1 - 9 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

8

Views

786

Users

7

Likes

26

Frequent Posters

Mike13 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
I too think the same

Ragini didnt justify FP

rather she admitted tht she is wrong stating her situation

she couldnt fight against society when someone inside her family (DADI) was against it

moreover Sujata would never agree to it even if AP would

she had to take an underhand way to tackle it

I admit Swara would not have done the same bt remember Swara is not Ragini jst as the way Ragini said

Sanky's dialouge...well I dont know about it bt I think he only wanted to justify Ragini's situation n motive for FP

thts all I think

Edited by Michael13 - 9 years ago
Nupur_5 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
You found Ragini's dialogues justified?
I didn't! Bcoz she was continuously defending her doing & was not ready to accept that she did wrong by choosing a cowardly manner!
She only accepted she was coward & did wrong after Sanskaar said those words!
And that's why I think Sanskaar was using reverse psychology so that Ragini understand that even if Swara was in her place still she wouldn't have choose this cowardice manner!
Sanskaar was not supporting this FP & neither he was thinking that Raglak didn't drag him in this bcoz of his situations or neither he was thinking about Swara's accusation during ML!
And one more thing what Ragini & Laksh did was absolutely WRONG!
They only tried to manao AP & Sujju once properly & that time DP & Sanskaar was with them! And with DP & Sanskaar on their side their half battle was already won bcoz they could have manage AP & Sujju!
And today's epi was total crap!
tiny15 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Nupur_5

You found Ragini's dialogues justified?

I didn't! Bcoz she was continuously defending her doing & was not ready to accept that she did wrong by choosing a cowardly manner!
She only accepted she was coward & did wrong after Sanskaar said those words!
And that's why I think Sanskaar was using reverse psychology so that Ragini understand that even if Swara was in her place still she wouldn't have choose this cowardice manner!
Sanskaar was not supporting this FP & neither he was thinking that Raglak didn't drag him in this bcoz of his situations or neither he was thinking about Swara's accusation during ML!
And one more thing what Ragini & Laksh did was absolutely WRONG!
They only tried to manao AP & Sujju once properly & that time DP & Sanskaar was with them! And with DP & Sanskaar on their side their half battle was already won bcoz they could have manage AP & Sujju!
And today's epi was total crap!

agree wid u . all in the epi ragz was trying 2 justify herself. and yes its only after sanskar asked that question that she accepted that shes a coward & chose wrong way.
and i agree they din't put much effort in making all understand.wen ragz cud stand 2 baadi ppl asking them 2 shut up & also 2 daadi telling her shes wrong initially then why all this FP?? AP wud'd understood if raglak both'd tried as AP is biased 2wards raglak.thatswhy she 4gave both of them 4 their numerous sins instantly but both swasan had 2 earn all this.
and sujju she follows her jiji & sanky is her weakness so she wa s also manageable.

2days epi wud'd been gud if only they din't do this.i also nowhere found ragz FP 2 b justified & made swara asking 4giveness & sanky asking that question.
nupur i agree sanky mite 'd don that but after that maalkin track i m not trusting CVs.
BarkhaSingh123 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Nupur_5

You found Ragini's dialogues justified?

I didn't! Bcoz she was continuously defending her doing & was not ready to accept that she did wrong by choosing a cowardly manner!
She only accepted she was coward & did wrong after Sanskaar said those words!
And that's why I think Sanskaar was using reverse psychology so that Ragini understand that even if Swara was in her place still she wouldn't have choose this cowardice manner!
Sanskaar was not supporting this FP & neither he was thinking that Raglak didn't drag him in this bcoz of his situations or neither he was thinking about Swara's accusation during ML!
And one more thing what Ragini & Laksh did was absolutely WRONG!
They only tried to manao AP & Sujju once properly & that time DP & Sanskaar was with them! And with DP & Sanskaar on their side their half battle was already won bcoz they could have manage AP & Sujju!
And today's epi was total crap!

@bold...
I
1) hmm so yes I found them genuine.. well here I didn't feel ki she said I am r8 but she said .. I know I was wrong.. I should have tried to tackle the matter better but at that time what could she do was this ...
2) buddy it's not about what sanskaar was thinking or not thinking.. today but it's about y couldn't Raglak take much help from their more sane n samajhte Bhai sanskaar... It just described the conditions...
3) I agree what all Raglak did is absolutely wrong but the only thing is ki they didn't directly jumped upon telling lies 2ndly I hope u all remembered Suomi's condition she was extremely broken by what all mm people said.. the way they badly taunted her...n then was sujata or ap listening to what do or sanskaar were saying only it was so in the end who declared ki let it be sharmisht's personal decision.. n sujata had left stamping her feet n ap nodes her head .. indicating she too wanted abortion...



Nupur_5 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: harshitaloomba1

@bold...
I
1) hmm so yes I found them genuine.. well here I didn't feel ki she said I am r8 but she said .. I know I was wrong.. I should have tried to tackle the matter better but at that time what could she do was this ...
2) buddy it's not about what sanskaar was thinking or not thinking.. today but it's about y couldn't Raglak take much help from their more sane n samajhte Bhai sanskaar... It just described the conditions...
3) I agree what all Raglak did is absolutely wrong but the only thing is ki they didn't directly jumped upon telling lies 2ndly I hope u all remembered Suomi's condition she was extremely broken by what all mm people said.. the way they badly taunted her...n then was sujata or ap listening to what do or sanskaar were saying only it was so in the end who declared ki let it be sharmisht's personal decision.. n sujata had left stamping her feet n ap nodes her head .. indicating she too wanted abortion...



About 1: Yes she accepted BUT only after Sanskaar presented a situation where if Swara was at her place then...
And then Raginiji understood even then Swara wouldn't have done that! Bt before she was continuously justifying her doing!
2 is the answer of your some lines so check clearly!
About 3: I think I clearly stated the fact in my previous post!
Raglak didn't try much to manao AP & Sujju & Dadi.
Okay Shomi was broken bt that doesn't mean they had to lie!
They could have manao them with samaj as well.
As I said with DP & Sanskaar with their side, managing AP & Sujju would not have been hard!
If you want to justify Ragini, you can! After all it's your choice!
Bt to me whatever she did was absolutely WRONG!
Lumos-Maxima thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
Nope don't agree with you. Because somewhere I felt she was defending herself saying samaj and parivar ki izzat. Both Ragini and Laksh had enough time and chances to take a mature action. Only once they tried to convince family and that time DP clearly told everyone not to interfere in that matter. After that they didn't try to convince others. I don't believe FP was only option. I never felt situation was that bad that she had to take such stupid step. Dadi was the only problem. She needed to be punished for her crime.But in SR criminals never got punished. They could have stayed away from that horrible old lady. Didn't see samaj people tried to harm shomi or baby. And Shomi has turned into a spineless woman suddenly. A woman who raised her daughter and played the role of single mother so efficiently has suddenly become an abla nari who can't protect her unborn. Ridiculous. They couldn't handle the issue properly. Moreover FP plan and those justification in the name of samaj & blah blah made it even more annoying and illogical.
xsumi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
i liked the episodes and i liked the scene
i said from beginning if i had to save a unborn childs life then im ready to take a risk, why should a child suffer and die just because of societies thoughts

i liked the episodes and ragini did accept that she may be weak... ofcourse swara didnt agree with what she did but im happy she was being supportive and always with ragini

i liked how ragini felt bad about playing with AP feelings and family, she accepted her mistake and i just hope they forgive her soon
loved the cute swasan hug scene i liked it...

hopefully more good episodes to come

sky_fighter thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
i completely agree with your post. Ragini is a normal human being she does what she thinks is right she was a super evil person at times and i think she has been punished for that enough, coming to the current scenario again i would say she is normal person and not a saint like the other lead they show on the tv. ragini is bound to make mistakes but her intentions were not to hurt people on the contrary she wanted to do something right by her family and it did back fire because frankly it was a stupid plan to begin with, none the less she did what she thought was right on her part. she might not be as strong as the saint people compare her with but she is not supposed to be that strong she is supposed to make mistakes and is trying to rectify herself but i think thats also not going to be easy as she is constantly compared to her sister. all in all i would say i understand why she did what she did
and regarding sanskars comment all i would say is the dude was trying to show his wife the POV of her sister if people think that is wrong then i dont know what is right

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".