Nabeel from Pakistan won Sur Kshetra [DT Note: 10,15] - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

122

Views

18.4k

Users

46

Likes

232

Frequent Posters

Mrs-Sahil thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#51
That's it for me, not watching the finale. What a disappointment, I expected Mulazem or Yashraj to come out as winner. Thanks for the spoiler guys and congrats to team Pakistan. :)
Mrs-Sahil thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#52
Diljan was a great singer but singing Punjabi songs every time made me lose interest.
April2007 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#53

Originally posted by: Mrs-Sahil

That's it for me, not watching the finale. What a disappointment, I expected Mulazem or Yashraj to come out as winner. Thanks for the spoiler guys and congrats to team Pakistan. :)



Still wondering why would Himesh tweet the name of winner. I think their is some code of conduct..something is surely doesn't add up.
vkaur125 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#54

Originally posted by: 13-old



I avoided as much as I could. Members were blaming Sara regarding hiding age. Many people hide their age. Their one member was 34 in 2005 and that member is still 34 in 2012. Therefor, they had not to raise finger about age. Age is a number. Healthy person looks younger and sick person or weak person looks older. I came only here to repeat my statement. My ID was 13 in 2010 but still looks 13.
No body should tolerate any abuse. I dont tolerate. At least, in public, if I dislike any thing, my face can show anger..

I have written about root. Folk songs are roots of classical songs and Pakistan is one of the best in folk songs.
I equally love India but when no choice is left, and circumstances force us, then, we are helpless to write similar comments. We know and we felt our PAKISTAN IS SWEET LOVELY AND GREAT.



Oh, she lied about her age? I didn't know that. Why did she? But regardless of her age, she is still a great singer. And that's what matters. I actually didn't get to see much of her singing, I only started watching when there were only 4 singers left from each side, and Mulazzum and Sara were already sitting. So missed out on her better performances.

Yes, that was my point as well. I personally feel people shouldn't abuse. Especially over something like this show, it's really silly. There is never anything wrong with constructive criticism, but arguing is a no-no. Yes, I do agree with the fact that the folk songs are great. I, myself am Punjabi, so we share a common culture. That's why I loved Diljaan, he was so good with singing them.

Honestly, I never meant to offend anyone and I hope you understand. =)
vkaur125 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#55

Originally posted by: April2007



Still wondering why would Himesh tweet the name of winner. I think their is some code of conduct..something is surely doesn't add up.


That isn't Himesh's twitter account. It's a fan-based account.
vkaur125 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#56

Originally posted by: pakeezah


vkaurji

this is the first time im seeing you post here and its nice to read that you would
like peace and hv many friends of all religions.

however, pls do go through ALL the posts since beginning of show on india
forums and tell me WHO you find doing the abusing.

there were handful of pakistanis and from them too some were neutral and
unbiased. there were some one or two indians who commented on show as
whole and didnt hate.

but towards end most neutral ones left. i think they got put off by the tone
of the posts here.

there were even some really weird characters who posted abusive posts
coming in multiple ids abusing pakistani captain and supporters of that
team and the mods very rightly banned them and removed those posts.

as for show i speak for myself. if more talent and fresh voices like
nabeel mulazim and imraans can be found, i would definitely watch another
sur kshetra. it was wonderful to listen to them just as it was diljaan, aman.

my opinion of ashaji has never been good and it went even further down
watching her behaviour on this show.

i know the fact that this show was held in dubai and not india affected the
kind of guests on the show- they couldnt get big movie stars to promote their
show like sa re ga ma pa and so lowered the visibility of show but mulazim
imraan/diljaan/etc and indeed himeshji, atif and sometimes jury made it entertaining
even without big stars making appearance.

i agree the fighting atmosphere was really off putting especially in beginning
but i think inspite of that, sur kshetra was a very worthwhile journey. there
were warm moments between the participants and the contestants seem
to have cherished their time on the show.

i hope it has given music industry of both countries some new superstars.

and yes, nabeels win sort of proves that an indian produced show can
award a pakistani the prize. how they decided, who who voted for nabeel
is yet to be seen, since episode is yet to be shown.



Yes, hi, I don't really post much. More of a silent reader, that too once in a while. I didn't go through all the topics/threads, but I got a sense of the whole "situation" from a few. Hating from both sides.

I do love these sort of shows as well, but I didn't like the whole concept of "India Vs. Pakistan". You can see the result of it and the result is far from "Aman ki Asha". I just see more hatred. I don't know much about Asha Bholse except the fact that she's been in the business for quite the time and that she's a great singer. I rather have a show that doesn't focus on the countries, rather they should focus on the singers, if you get what I mean.

I always felt that Mulazim had a very unique voice. Some songs suited him and some songs didn't. Yes, it's important to be versatile. But I also agree with what Himesh had said, you want the singer to be good at what he does, he doesn't need to sing 20 different kinds of songs. I just hope they all succeed, they're all so good.

As for who voted for who, that all depends on person to person. Some like gulab jamuns, some like ras gullas. That doesn't change the fact that they're both yummy. Haha, sorry, what a horrible comparison. Out of the Pakistan team, I liked Nabeel over Mulazim and I liked both Diljaan and Yashraj. That doesn't change the fact that Mulazim, Sara, Aman, etc. are good singers as well.


51559 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#57

Originally posted by: April2007



Yup..


Stay on your side of the border. No more Aman ki Asha..no more calling Indian names ..remember your two nation theory..we cannot live together, this show and Atif, Abida and Gulam's behavior has proved this..

My dear y so jealousy?? please accept Nabeel as a winner! 😆 😆And we are stay at our side ! no need to tell us! 🤣 well i guess u r not accepting Nabeel as a winner rite.. Ager Diljaan jeet jaata tou aman ki asha ki baat nhi ki jaati na? Grow up and face the reality..! 🤣
April2007 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#58

Originally posted by: Pentaminous.

My dear y so jealousy?? please accept Nabeel as a winner! 😆 😆And we are stay at our side ! no need to tell us! 🤣 well i guess u r not accepting Nabeel as a winner rite.. Ager Diljaan jeet jaata tou aman ki asha ki baat nhi ki jaati na? Grow up and face the reality..! 🤣


You are talking nonsense and becoming personal.

Actually may favourite is Aman. Loved his unique voice. I didn't liked the way Atif, Abida and Gulam Ali behaved and also don't like the way Ashaji was abused on this forum and on the show. It really doesn't matter who won..I hate the way thread after thread was opened on this forum insulting Ashaji.

I think if anybody that needs to grow up it is you..your use of emotions shows your immaturity and childishness.
13-old thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#59

Originally posted by: April2007


You are talking nonsense and becoming personal.

Actually may favourite is Aman. Loved his unique voice. I didn't liked the way Atif, Abida and Gulam Ali behaved and also don't like the way Ashaji was abused on this forum and on the show. It really doesn't matter who won..I hate the way thread after thread was opened on this forum insulting Ashaji.

I think if anybody that needs to grow up it is you..your use of emotions shows your immaturity and childishness.


Pakistan has great singers which you dont. Aman is below average singers. All our above mentioned singers are unique and nobody is better than them in the world.
You should stop your non-sense. First of all you people started abusing, then, we did.
desicrowd thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#60
No tweet from Nabeel this time about how unfair this show is????

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".