Ali Zafar would have been better judge...

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

-Alina-

@-Alina-

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#21

Originally posted by: Mia1love

Honestly the show still could have been different but with a Person like Gajendra Singh around things are Boomed. Music ka Maha . was the prime Example of How people can turn on each other. and they were all Indian Singers fighting like immature children . Not just Singers But WELL KNOWN in the Bollywood , Mika , Shaan , Himesh , Shankar and Mohit .the amount of ridiculous fights, They humiliated each other and degraded each other. Lord the amount of trash and demeaning remarks thrown at Mohit was heartbreaking ... So regardless what kind of show it is with any concept . this MAN brings out the worst in all.

See that's what I'm trying to say! It's not Atif's himesh's Abida Ji or Asha ji's fault, it's the format of the show which is making their bad side to co e in front of the audience ! I too remember that Maha mukabala ! It had some really well known personalities and to see all of them(even contestants) getting a bit loud, was really awful !

I wonder what trigger Gajendra to make such shows? Can't he see, it is really creating a bad impression about those stars who could be an inspiration for so many !

Quote

pakeezah

@pakeezah

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

#22

Gajendra must be devil in disguise...sent to turn otherwise good people evil and make them turn on each other.

Anyways, there must be at least 8 weeks more till finale...and pre recorded shows air...

Time enough for concerned folks to do damage control, be it Ashaji, ATif,ABida ma'am

Whoever, before finale, show each other and world they're not hating each other or country

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Nibelungenlied

@Nibelungenlied

Navigator

Posted: 12 years ago

#23

I think Atif and Himesh can handle each other alright. Anyone with a sweeter disposition would have been awkward, especially considering that the format of this show thrives on discord. They are abrasive because they are asked to be abrasive, or so at least I believe.

Of course, it would have been great to have Sonu and Rahat instead of Himesh and Atif. As I have read elsewhere in this forum today, the format of this show should have been different. It should have been about singers from both countries singing together, learning together, in teams that have both contestants. With mentors like Ghulam Ali ji, Asha ji etc. Challenging each other on the basis of merit. The experience for everyone would have been pleasant and not so aggressive-competitive just for the sake of competition. Music could have won and thrived with such skilled singers from both countries. Now it's more like war.