sara raza khan, atif, abida not fit for this show

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

kadami

@kadami

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

#51

One singer shouted that he is only singer in the world who was supported by woman Atif. Wow wow wow... I never heard in the history. Tansen wanted a singer who could sing better than him and baiju bawra could sing.
This pak guy has crossed all limits. It is very far to listen her bakwas songs. I can not open my TV to see their face. I would pray that such singer must be so sick that he would never be able to speak clearly.
Yash raj, I am proud of you. You did great reply to that singer.

Quote

Nibelungenlied

@Nibelungenlied

Navigator

Posted: 12 years ago

#52

I thought Sara has a really nice voice. The song she sang in the qualifying round was amazing. Yes, she sings the bollywood songs in her own style and sometimes the songs sound a little off in some places but overall I like the way she sounds.

I think all the singers are very good, especially Nabeel, Yashraj, Diljaan, Imraan, Aman and Sara.

Both Atif and Himesh are annoying at times but I guess this is the format that they are supposed to adhere to.

Asha ji is as dear to us Indians as Abida ji is to the Pakistanis. Calling one a name will surely rile the other side's feelings. There are biases on both sides, lets live and let live.

The show has been very nice for the last two episodes. I like having five judges.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

aartigoyal18

@aartigoyal18

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

#53

If show is scripted, even then, they had to keep in their mind feelings of audience because this show is for unity and not for fighting.
Reaction of audience is natural.
They could delete from video those parts which are annoying.

Quote

kashishdabest

@kashishdabest

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#54

Originally posted by: aartigoyal18
If show is scripted, even then, they had to keep in their mind feelings of audience because this show is for unity and not for fighting.
Reaction of audience is natural.
They could delete from video those parts which are annoying.

Dear that is upto the producers and editors of the team..they are purposefully using certain areas showing controversies as this in return is firing up viewers and adding to the trps...who would watch a peaceful non controversial show..thats the mindset they have

Quote

kashishdabest

@kashishdabest

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#55

Originally posted by: kadami
She is not godly lady. She is not close to god whatever she confirmed openly. Sufi songs are not her personal property. Her songs does not touch my heart but gulas ali ghazals touch my heart . Rahat f.ali khan is better than abida. She should stop saying that no body should sing her songs. who the hell is she to command. It is stupidity.

I find that comment offensive..it is wrong of you to bring religion into this and question an individuals beliefs..it is between god and an individual..no third person should be involved...and sufi songs may not be her personal property but the songs she has sang are..they belong to her..and she requested for the format to be changed..she wqsnt rude infact she was emotional and didnt want to keep giving 0 to the indian contestants..if she let them carry on then u all would point a finger at her saying she gave 0's to all indian contestants..try and respect others sentiments please and thats your personal opinion whose voice touches you and whose doesnt

Quote

aartigoyal18

@aartigoyal18

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

#56

This is second show when I saw contradiction. One was music ka maha mukabla wherein some problems were seen. All other shows were almost peaceful with the fact that all the time deserving winner could not win. There is really no need to do arguments in the show.

Quote

aartigoyal18

@aartigoyal18

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

#57

When one person opening bravely intensely insulting Ashaji, how the producers could tolerate that and how they are agree with the lot of insults of ashaji. It is unfair.

Quote

kashishdabest

@kashishdabest

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#58

Originally posted by: Saatschi
I thought Sara has a really nice voice. The song she sang in the qualifying round was amazing. Yes, she sings the bollywood songs in her own style and sometimes the songs sound a little off in some places but overall I like the way she sounds.
</div><div>
I think all the singers are very good, especially Nabeel, Yashraj, Diljaan, Imraan, Aman and Sara.

Both Atif and Himesh are annoying at times but I guess this is the format that they are supposed to adhere to.

Asha ji is as dear to us Indians as Abida ji is to the Pakistanis. Calling one a name will surely rile the other side's feelings. There are biases on both sides, lets live and let live.

The show has been very nice for the last two episodes. I like having five judges.

Brilliantly put..thats my whole point..live and let live..watch the show..express your opinions but in a way you dont offend others because it is upsetting

Quote

kashishdabest

@kashishdabest

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#59

Originally posted by: aartigoyal18
When one person opening bravely intensely insulting Ashaji, how the producers could tolerate that and how they are agree with the lot of insults of ashaji. It is unfair.

It is surprising isnt it..and the producers are indian not pakistani..you would think they would stop this or have the decency to edit these parts but they are openly showing these insulting segments..it is upsetting

Quote

Nibelungenlied

@Nibelungenlied

Navigator

Posted: 12 years ago

#60

@kashishdabest: Thank you. I agree with what you have been stating as well.

Asha ji is one of my favorite singers and it pains me to see her being hurt on the show. Similarly, I know that mean comments about Abida ji would be very upsetting for her fans. I think we should show respect to these icons of our countries, they are at a phase in their lives where they have reached after struggling and surpassing odds. We should let them be. They judge things like 'sur' and 'tone' and 'feeling' in a very different way from most of us. if a bias does sweep into their judgement, it is because they are also human. I have written elsewhere that perhaps they are not the best judges but they are and will remain icons to their fans. And I respect them both. Even if I do not agree with things they say or do in this show.

Lets just enjoy the singers and the experience. For me, I love the fact that we have this opportunity to meet and interact with our pakistani friends:)

Quote

1 ... 4 5 6 7 8 ... 12

sara raza khan, atif, abida not fit for this show - Page 6

Related Topics

Explore Topics