Comment on few topic in this forum for Sur Kshetra - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

25

Views

4.5k

Users

15

Likes

63

Frequent Posters

-shabz- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#11
the creators of the show are using indo-pak rivalry as means to gain trps for their show...and guess what...they are succeeding...do we really think audience from both countries would tune in if the promos show the mentors and judges being all friendly and singing yeh dosti?

India and pakistan might be different in size but there is one thing in common, we are taught all our life to be a good host and a polite guest...so think for a moment...would atif do badtaameezi being a guest in India...would Asha ji and himesh be impolite host?...why would a channel allow a guest to come in their country and ridicule "their" legends?...no ...never...this is all part of the act...and we are taking it seriously...shows like sur kshetra and the politicians of both sides,live and thrive on this rivalry...they will never want peace,its againt their interests.




Rock-Star007 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#12
Muje to asha j ,atif and himesi tino pasand hai jisko jo kahana hai ,jo bolna hai bolo par mera manana hai singer ne acha gaya ya bura gaya is pe bolo na ki india & pak ko beech me le aao
desicrowd thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#13
Agree with a few points not all.. I think Atif Aslam is trying to crate drama here so he can be signed on a new reality show cos they need such personalities for te show... I do feel he is egoistic and ready to crate a war... He has no right to say a word against Ashaji, his knowledge about sur taal is nowhere near where the three respectable judges knowledge is... Infact Himesh who I disliked is more competent in this field than him... Not once has Atif praised any Indian contestant and is playing dirty... Also he has no right to tell any contestant to respect others when he himself doesnt respect te three legends who Re the judges... yiu command a respect dont demand it...Well I seriously don't understand why was he brought as a judge when the show is about Sur and taal.
-Alina- thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#14
😆

Originally posted by: patelcharu

Alina- I am not saying that Pakistan is not progressing but I am just saying what India is. People always compare Indian and Pak...but there is no comparison as India is large country compare to Pak, Bangladesh and Shri Lunka.

Here is the % of Religion in Pak and India

PAKISTAN:

Islam

Sunni: 80-95%

Shia: 5-20%[

Ahmadi: approx. 1.42% to 2.3%

Other religions

o Christians: approx. 1.6%

o Hindus: approx. 1.6%

o Bah's: 40,000 to 79,000

o Sikhs: 20,000[9]

o Zoroastrian/Parsis: 1,600 to 20,000

o Kalash: 3,000

INDIA:

Religious
group

Population
%

Hindu

80.46%

Muslim

13.43%

Christian

2.34%

Sikh

1.87%

Buddhist

0.77%

Animist, others

0.72%

Jain

0.41%

Yes, I notice that Pak has other religion but I would say India accept other religious people as President and Prime minister beside doctor, teacher, professor, business man, actor, singer, sports or Engineer. That is what India is.

Also, as you said above India give freedom to the people to live the life as they want. I would say many part of India is free and take part in all Talent like Dancing, Singing, sports, art, drama and beauty pageant ' many things.

About TV Drama, yes I will not denied the fact that Pak makes excellent Drama, but since last 10yrs India is not behind...Indian Drama has bit record world wide (In 24 or more country) and no comparison to Hollywood but they make excellent Dramas...such as BALIKA VADHU, Kashish, Udaan, Dooniya, Ba, Baby aur Bahu, Sasural Genda Phool, Kyuki Saas bhi Kabhi Bahu thi, Kasauti Jindgi Ki, Kahani Ghar Ghar Ki, Diya Aur Baati, Bade Achhe Lagate hai...and many more...yes I would say one this that now days Dramas' are run based on TRP..and that's the reason good TV drama end up with boring end because people love to watch them for long time...but there are lots good Dramas are made by India beside Movies.

About singer'I never said that Pak does not have good singers...yes Pak has some very excellent singer's as well, but I was only responding back to the one the commenter who try to make point like we Indian need Pak singer to run Bollywood...but that's not the case we respect the talent of PAK and may that's why Bollywood offer them to come to India and sing for Bollywood. But it does not mean India not have best singers...also India believe in giving chance to new comers.

I would say one thing'Rahat Fateh Ali Khan is my one of favorite Singer...he is also very down to earth man...very noble man, and I respect him as singer. Adman Swami is also wonderful singer and good human being. I like Atif's singing but not his attitude.

About Sur Kshetra...I have watch all the episode and as far as I have notice Atif is the one who started degrading comments on Himesh and good comments about His country and contestant so this makes Asha ji to response in favor of India.

Atif also made comment that Favoritism going on...that was not good comment...for him if Pak contestant does not sing well but still give them 10 that's fine but when Indian contestant sing well still he expect to give them 0...that's not right. And If Asha ji is bias than what about the other 2 jury member why they give good point to Indo contestant.

Sorry, as far as I notice Atif talk about Aman, Pyar but I would not able see the same thing in his eye, body language, or in his comment for Indian contestant.

I am saying same thing...Asha Ji is true Indian...she replying on behalf of her nation to Atif's comments.

I tell you if Adman Swami or Rahat will be captain than this situation will might not have come. Because they believe in aman and friendship not just talk about it.


God You really wanna go there?? India is much much bigger in population so obviously it would be having more people and more religions ! You can't compare Pakistan and India on the basis of Religion !

Second thing...its Adnan Sami😊😆...and if you are saying Asha ji is a true Indian as she is replying to Atif's comment then dear Atif is also a true Pakistani as he too is replying to asha Ji's n Himesh's comments ! So both of them are right on their places ! Its the Show which is messing up with everything !!

And to All those who thing World war 3 gonna start here...so dont worry it wont😃😆
larki_punjaban thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#15
this ''War' woudl never end

pakistani ppl will say atif right and indians wills a himmesh is not wrong

there is nothing to discuss abt it, qauz every of us each love our country and nobody will hear anything against our county nation ppl

anaad thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#16
i don't really see what's the fuss about who is right or wrong. I don't see anything wrong in atifs or himmesh attitude...I think the comment's are not bad,the background music makes them bad...anyways... what's the deal with that background music everytime someone says something...find it very irritating.
WindsOfHeaven thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Banner Contest Winner Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 13 years ago
#17
Great post buddy, I agree with each and every line.

I can't bear some people posting wrong against HR, anymore.

Thank you so much!
WindsOfHeaven thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Banner Contest Winner Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 13 years ago
#18
One more thing, someone is continuously posting nonsense comments about HR regarding this Jung thing. So let me remind that even atif uttered "Ye jung nahi aasaan". So does this term have a different meaning when he spells it.
s123vi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#19
well i hv been followin various posts on different forums on this show n still confused abt 1 thng.
can sm1 tell y pakistani ppl r bashin aman trikha? they r sayin ki he replied to atif ki"..agali baar vicks le kr aaunga!" whereas i didn't hear him sayin nythn lyk that on colors in india. he simply said " nxt tym dhyaan rakhunga!" to whch aatif got angry n said " thodi si bado ki izzat bhi kiya karo..!"
at that tym i thought he was pissed off coz he wantd him 2 silently listn n not explain anythng .thats it! i dont think he said smthng abt vicks n all or else himesh n asha ji would hv scolded him badly 4 misbehavin wid aatif ..i m pretty sure abt it.
donno ...does it mean show makrs r editin it for diff viewers 2 create more ruckus??
pathetic!!
anaad thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#20

In my opinion, the shows format should have been different…First of all, the captains should work more as a team, to enhance the singing quality of the contestants, instead of taking stands against each other. Secondly, I think the judges should only constrict to comments about the singing and not go in discussion with the captains about who has a bigger hart and who has a girlfriend (I am not trying to offend anyone with the comment)…they are not here to entertain us but to give constructive criticism to the contestant, based on their experience and level of expertise, so that the contestants can get an opportunity develop their skills further. Finally, the masala part of the show, I think it should have been left to the show hosts. I think the hosting would have been more balanced, if they had a Pakistani anchor co-presenting next to Aisha…Maybe Fawad Mustafa or someone else…I loved him in the Morning show...We could have get some cute bickering and backering…..maybe some jokes added to the mix….and then Aisha could have taking a stand for India instead of remaining natural. Actually I don't find Aisha a very good host , she isn't good at improvising or at starting a conversation….It would have been nice if we could have got someone like Jay Bhanushali…I love what he is doing with DID.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".