Comment on few topic in this forum for Sur Kshetra - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

25

Views

4.5k

Users

15

Likes

63

Frequent Posters

April2007 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: anaad

In my opinion, the shows format should have been different'First of all, the captains should work more as a team, to enhance the singing quality of the contestants, instead of taking stands against each other. Secondly, I think the judges should only constrict to comments about the singing and not go in discussion with the captains about who has a bigger hart and who has a girlfriend (I am not trying to offend anyone with the comment)'they are not here to entertain us but to give constructive criticism to the contestant, based on their experience and level of expertise, so that the contestants can get an opportunity develop their skills further. Finally, the masala part of the show, I think it should have been left to the show hosts. I think the hosting would have been more balanced, if they had a Pakistani anchor co-presenting next to Aisha'Maybe Fawad Mustafa or someone else'I loved him in the Morning show...We could have get some cute bickering and backering'..maybe some jokes added to the mix'.and then Aisha could have taking a stand for India instead of remaining natural. Actually I don't find Aisha a very good host , she isn't good at improvising or at starting a conversation'.It would have been nice if we could have got someone like Jay Bhanushali'I love what he is doing with DID.



So no freedom of speech for judges..they should be totally controlled I don't think any successful Indian singer or music director will like to part .they don't need this kind of cesorship.

I have a better suggestion...scrap the show..we may be able to do this in next 10 or 20 years..If things remain positive, no use pretending that we are friends..btw no stupid bickering nonsense..it is very very childish.
Edited by April2007 - 13 years ago
anaad thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#22

I didn't want to hurt anyone with the comment, I don't really see why you overreacting...in every post you are always searching for something negative. Those people are there to give their opinion about the singing, they are getting paid therefore'not for their views on other stuff. And the music singers and directors aren't their either to make unnecessary drama on request of the producers of the show...However,that doesn't mean i think they said something wrong,i just don't like the background music that is given to create the drama. I am just saying if the producers want drama, they should make use of the host for that. And what's wrong with pretending to be friends, just because you hate Pakistani people doesn't mean everyone in India does to.

Edited by anaad - 13 years ago
-shabz- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: anaad

I didn't want to hurt anyone with the comment, I don't really see why you overreacting...in every post you are always searching for something negative. Those people are there to give their opinion about the singing, they are getting paid therefore'not for their views on other stuff. And the music singers and directors aren't their either to make unnecessary drama on request of the producers of the show...However,that doesn't mean i think they said something wrong,i just don't like the background music that is given to create the drama. I am just saying if the producers want drama, they should make use of the host for that. And what's wrong with pretending to be friends, just because you hate Pakistani people doesn't mean everyone in India does to.

👏 standing ovation buddy...you know i read a review by an indian about a pakistani act, it is totally unrelated to this show,but relevant to this discussion...he said, he doesnt know how to praise because he has been programmed to hate pakistani all his life...no offense to anyone...just wanted to share.
sreevask thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#24
Have it light... Emotional element is quite common 4 realty shows... Just 4 trps...real talent requires no applause...
s123vi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#25
i used 2 criticize aatif whenever my sister would praise his voice.
i missed d 1st episode n watched 2nd in which pakistani judges had 2 choose final 6. my sister n i both felt that aatif was acting like a snob. throughout d episode, he was behaving like a superstar.
well we disliked him that time but couldn't stop ourselves admiring him in d following episodes.
he is a good captain n doing his duty well.
i wanted 2 watch sur kshetra only 4 ashaji bt now aatif is also a reason 4 me.
i like his style, attitude n personality. he seems 2 b good person.
both asha ji n aatif rock!!
patelcharu thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: -Alina-

😆


God You really wanna go there?? India is much much bigger in population so obviously it would be having more people and more religions ! You can't compare Pakistan and India on the basis of Religion !

Second thing...its Adnan Sami😊😆...and if you are saying Asha ji is a true Indian as she is replying to Atif's comment then dear Atif is also a true Pakistani as he too is replying to asha Ji's n Himesh's comments ! So both of them are right on their places ! Its the Show which is messing up with everything !!

And to All those who thing World war 3 gonna start here...so dont worry it wont😃😆

Alina- First of all stop saying GOD I really want to go there? Where?...I am only replying your post.
You need to read my and yours first post...In my first post I have only talk about India but you in your post start compairing that "We Pak has many religion as well" Yes you do have...and I found the ratio between both country. India Is large coundtry but it gives fair chance to all religious people in talent or politics. And I don't need to compare India with Pak. India is India...Its has his own identity.
Let me make it clear one thing...In small country easy to give chance to other religious people to be part of politics, president, prime minister or in any talent compare to large country like India.
Why not this happening in your Pakistan? You are comparing Pak with India...Not me.
See you...how you think...what if I wrote "ADNAN SWAMI" or "ADNAN SAMI"...you got hurt just between "SWAMI and Sami" but you didn't able to understand that I like his singing and he is wounderful human being...and you are laughing on what I said...but if you interpret "SWAMI" you will know how respectful word SWAMI is.
Yes ASHIJi is True Indian, and Singing legend...and She is not the one commmenting on PAK but she replying Atif's Comment like AMAN, PYAR...and Favoritism...
Anyway no point to explain anything to you...I know what India is and I am very much proud to be part of My beloved Country India.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".