You are not Raja Janak's biological daughter- Gargi to Sita - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

16

Views

5.7k

Users

9

Likes

98

Frequent Posters

deejagi thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#11
@ Shruthi, though it was taken with good grace by Sita about her birth secret or shall I say her adoption status, just imagine what would have happened if the girl was affected in the reverse way. Yes as Guru, gargi did a good job by revealing Sita's truth but at the same time, if The learned Rajashri Janak had kept that as a secret so far, there might have been a reason fro that right? So without his knowledge, revealing such a sensitive point to an adolescent girl was not so sensible. Now after realizing her truth, the first thing Sita did was to reveal that to her sisters in a different way, which was not normal for Sita the straight forward girl. She just asked what if she is not their own sister but a step sister and even if for joke, if one of them says, they will disown her, wont that little heart breakdown? wont that create a superficial cliff among the kids. They will not be their own self hereafter. For ever Sita will think she occupied most of what they deserved and whatever was their share (be it the love of their parents, the elder daughter status etc) and the other kids will always have to watch their words before uttering anything in front of their beloved sister hereafter feeling scared that what if their words hurt their sister.
If Janak felt himself incapable of informing Sita about her birth and it was equally important for her to know about the same at that given point of time, then the guru relating the situation would have been appropriate but at the moment I feel guru Gargi was in a haste to tell the truth, didn't thought of the repurcations. May be for this reason we have that say "Sathyam Bruyaath, priyam bruyaath, na bruyath bruyath satham apriyam." "Tell the truth, tell the good one or liked one and never tell the truth which is unliked or which may hurt the other".
Mano.M thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#12
Another lovely episode
With two beautiful moments
The Ram,Sita a connect and
Sita knowing about her birth
Enjoyed reading the discussions

I just have a request
I think at the end each episode they are sharing
some facts of Ramayan,if I am not wrong
It would be great if someone shares it on everyday basis

I actually don't know where to say this
Since most of us assemble in urs or Arshics thread
It would be great if one of u can do it😃

shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#13
@jaya my post if you read carefully had addressed the points you raised. Sita didn't get it from Janak, but from Gargi that too unexpected. So I am also curious to know how Janak will address it. Because adoption is a sensitive issue. Even if the child get to know it from parents still it takes time for the child to accept it( Tamil movie: Kannathil Muthamittal deals with the adoption. Beautiful movie by Mani Ratnam that sensitively addresses how the child feels when the truth of her adoption is told to her by her parents) . Ideally parents have to tell it. Here if you see Gargi told it in a positive way. But there are many cases where the truth comes out in child's front in a negative way. So before giving society a chance it is better for parents to tell such things and support the child to traverse the journey of this truth in a positive fashion.
@Mano I also see it. But on most occasions the moment SKR closes my mom changes the channel to some tamil soap so I misses out reading complete. Whenever I see I will put that in my thread.
ayushimehra thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: shruthiravi

There are some truths that alter your very existence. And always it is better that such truth comes from the right person. Today Sita heard such a truth. A truth which her father or mother should have told her, but she hears it from her Guru. The truth that she is not the biological daughter of her parents. If you look at an adoptive child it carries a lot of pressure on the child. There will be myriad of questions going in its mind when the truth is told that their parents are not biological. First and foremost being why did the parents who gave birth to me leave me. Who are they. Where are they. So am living in someone else's mercy, sympathy. Do I really belong here. Are these riches mine.

It is a very sensitive and psychological area as far as a child is concerned. And if you look Sita is a teenager and knowing this fact has affected her immensely. Yes she is able to connect now why she is able to talk the language of nature. Why nature understands her. But at the same time what she considers her home, her sisters, her parents have become distant to her. Her whole existence has Rajrishi Janak's daughter no longer holds true.

I am very happy that CVs have bought up this sensitive issue of adoption. Because it is a very emotional issue that needs to be dealt with a lot of empathy. I will be happy to see how Raja Janak is able to handle the questions of his daughter and the larger family about her origin.



Very nice, +effective post, Agree your every word.

Yes Sita Mind finding seeing every corner, after knowing From Gargi, she not biological daughter,
of Janak.

But which way Gargi Told Sita, or presented her talk, appriciable, She not used any nagaitve word or Aura, or told her, You also feel, own Unlimited sometime, Because you came from unlimited Nature
This line hinted us,;;;;;;;;;Sita, maybee janak suta, but her connection to nature or earth is Aseem.
So you Right lets see How Will Janak handle this senstive, point or satisfy Sita.

But Sita will also get many ans, after listening Gargi, When Gargi says you often feel your love for Nature, Nature hears your talk.

she was saying sisters, Why i too much love dears,;;;;;;so slowly slowly she will more to know her love for nature.

Edited by ayushimehra - 9 years ago
Mano.M thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: shruthiravi

@Mano I also see it. But on most occasions the moment SKR closes my mom changes the channel to some tamil soap so I misses out reading complete. Whenever I see I will put that in my thread.


Thank u😃
shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#16
yes Aayushi. This will lead Sita to the path of self-discovery. On her ability to raise Shiv Dhanush, the reason that Dhanush is kept as a challenge for her swayamvar and also her connect with that Raghuvansi.
Nonie12345 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#17
Amazing post Shruti didi😃

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".