In defense of Silsila - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

29

Views

4k

Users

25

Likes

233

Frequent Posters

sweet_tania thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: Terenaina

What is the meaning of ronandi?


Rondini = Rondu (cry baby ) + Nandini
potterhead14 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#12
I really don't think Silsila is the biggest risk...there were thousand of shows with bold concepts, I remember there was a show named maryada in Star plus with ridhi and Rakesh as leads and that show actually had a gay couple and that was in 2006 or 7 I guess I don't remember but yeah that was bold step. EMA was shown in many other shows too but the reason why Silsila is receiving such backlash is because the CVs couldn't handle the thing properly. They could have shown that Kunal is unhappy with Mauli and unknowingly falls in love with nandini but what they showed was nothing but lust...seriously which creeps checks out the wife's besty when she is dancing rain and that to like that🤬
Terenaina thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#13
I like watching BOLD shows, this show is not even bold, they didn't have show that much of that scene😆
1148967 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#14
Maryada what a amazing show
sha_rocks thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: ZoyaNation18

I see alot of backlash for the show, but in my opinion Silsila is one of the biggest risks Indian TV Shows has ever taken. For real, we've seen enough love/hate relationships and enough saas-bahu drama. I like the idea of Nandini being a sideline chick. I mean it has been done before, but not to this extent. And Mauli isn't all that innocent, she seems suffocating and Kunal is falling out of love with her, and it happens in real life. For crying out loud, it''s 2018. Who cares about EMA affairs being so taboo, it happens more than you think.

OT: I also think Mauli will team up with Rajdeep and become the antagonist. 😲


Kalyug hai...kalyug ..kuch bhi ho sakta hai...but then backlash is what which is not liked by audience and our audience have every right to speak what is right what is wrong?? Agreed it's a just a show and it happens more what we think but then audience cannot sit quite for wrong..people who like it will watch it ...people who don't they should not watch it..just like people who have every right to praise ...so like that every right to criticize...


In modern day and age, the stress on relationships is a lot more than what we had before. It has become far more common place for people to find emotional connect outside.Many are not even aware of that moment or phase where someone else takes over the place once proudly occupied by their spouses. On the name of EMA directors can not show anything which is unacceptable...

In this show nandini has been described as victim of harassment...attempt rape ... many more...do we all have any idea the people who go through how they feel??? Chances are some people will fight for the justice and some people become weak and some people end there life..

Directors focused on weaker part of a victim but then victim who go through such things does not fell in love next moment and are ready to take themself for next step ...majak hai Kya???

All i want to say let's just not hurt their feelings...
This s not showing any msg. . In fact be coming more controversial ..



Edited by sha_rocks - 7 years ago
PM1774 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#16
If love is suffocating ...then lust is justified...if it happens in some one s life in reality then the pain is immense...I feel bad for mauli...kunal and mandini it's lustful only...but yes the show is showing reality of today's fake world...where fake people win ...even fans like such lust stories...
Rosh4rose thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#17

Why don't say
This is the riskiest show in the entire universe
...can't stop
laughing reading articles in the forum.
Crazy .. Taking risk ...
They why the CVs are calling "baba , Kunnu's speech of faith , divine signs " every singke thing to justify
Makers and characters both lacks "courage "


Simple as it is " they can't touch it boldly so they are doing it" lust full body business with divine blessings "
Edited by Rosh4rose - 7 years ago
Padmajaan thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voice of India 2024 Participant Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#18
Reposting here.
Posts gets locked in this forum all the time. Hahahaha.

I am used to a different forum where people with different POVs discussed in a healthy manner and nothing was reported at the drop of a hat and locked.

I am also just an occasional visitor to this forum and am shocked by the sheer number of vituperative posts and simplistic branding of characters as good or evil with any shades inbetween totally lacking.

This show is about EMA and EMA is what you are getting and whether you like it or not such things do happen, very nice people both and very much in love at one stage do either fall out of love or grow distant with time for no fault of either of the two partners, some compromise and live in a loveless relationship for the rest of their lives, others call it a day and either move on or fail to move on, some find love or attraction or lust outside of the marriage and so on. EMA is a very uncomfortable subject, and wreaks havoc all around but shit does happen in life don;t you all agree? Of course we would all love a good love story and a they lived happily ever after as the end but such is unfortunately not the case for several hundreds of thousands of people around the world.

Mauli is an awesome person. So is Kunal. They have a lovely family and everything was going hunky dory apparently but obviously there was a mismatch somewhere along the way and nandini in her sheer feminine avatar and in how soft she is, in fact she is the opposite of Mauli, she is demure, she seems like someone who really needs to be protected, she has gone through indescribable horrors at the hands of a brute, does correspond more to how Kunal has been depicted right from the beginning. And all this happens at a time when their marriage has already been on for a while and Mauli is extremely busy generally handling the various relations in her personal life and other pressing matters professionally including bringing Kunal's pet project to fruition.

Therefore yes it's extremely sad to see the bubble burst and all of us are and should feel extremely sad for mauli but also for kunal and nandini because they find themselves in a real mess and Mauli is indeed the hapless victim.

However it is so simplistic to paint Nandini as a lustful woman armed with the singular purpose of bedding her best friend's husband and betraying her trust. Kunal just happened to be around when she was at her most vulnerable and the mutual attraction they feel for each other is one of the inexplicable things that does happen even if unfortunately so.

I am sure they are both feeling shitty about it but they are also revelling in the sudden happiness they have found. Yes this is indeed possible. If you are dispassionate about it you will probably see that Kunal and Nandini do complete one another more than Mauli and Kunal.

Let me also admit that I have recently started watching this show and am expressing my opinion only based on the limited viewing and after visiting the forum and reading quite a few vituperative posts.

Another thing that bothers me is the take on this forum on what amounts to being unfaithful. I even read one post where the poster says that lying to one's partner is OK it's not a crime, but having sex with another woman is not OK and is a crime, but honestly is only consummation and just the physical act tantamount to cheating? What about mental, spiritual and psychological straying? Is it OK if your Boyfriend or Husband thinking of another woman constantly, is lying to you and is still sleeping with you while thinking of her? Isn't that cheating enough already? The physical act is just the culmination of all this isn't it and not as a big deal as you are all making it out to be as I see how much the consummation track has freaked everyone out here. Kunal has been cheating Mauli for quite a while already in his mind and nandini too.

I know how much EMA hurts, how uncomfortable the issue is but I really think it's too simplistic to brand someone a scheming evil homebreaker and all. Mauli's home is already broken from the time Kunal is no longer with her in heart.

Well I have rambled enough and will just shut up now.

The makers are trying to show us the journey of the characters over such a thorny issue in whichever way they think fit and in my opinion we should be dispassionate and see how things unravel and not fill the forum with so much negativity and say so many horrible things.
PM1774 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#19
Moral policing is not permitted...in this forum even if ...I speak my mind...most treads are getting locked...May be most indian viewer like lust dil stories...cannot say anything...on top of that justifying...sad reality of fake world
Bat1 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#20
The only problem with Silsila is the treatment there are other serials don't want to name them but makers can handle it the way they want but in silsila the subject is close to reality that is the reason audience expect it to be handled carefully being realistic it is much talked about as people have seen the same things around them the main problem here is Nandini is shown as cry baby and too good in the beginning no girl who has ethics ruins her friend who gave her new life.nandini falling for Kunal is understandable but she should have controlled her feelings thereby proving her initial characterisation.coming to Mauli she is shown as a good wife whom even Kunal loves initially. agree that people move from wife to other girl but Kunal shouldn't have loved Mauli initially so much then it looks like pure lust story .if it is lust story show it as it is y show it as pure love story.makers are confused how it should be treated and after Mauli knowing truth if Nandini leaves it is again a major blunder in real life nobody does that.it can take 2 possible routes Nandini marrying Kunal Sridevi story wife Mauli suffering or Kunal leaving Nandini for Mauli other women suffering Rekha case But makers won't show anything of that sort wen the subject is realistic the treatment should be realistic as well

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".