Created

Last reply

Replies

637

Views

50.6k

Users

37

Likes

1.2k

Frequent Posters

SummerRain7 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: pamk06


@bold: I think it because of your demand. You have asked for it so many times that they finally relented and showing the conflicting emotions. 😆😆😆. Little late though.

I think we will be subjected to sweet romance between Mauli and Kunal and his push and pull. There is a possibility that Nandini might get pregnant and she will go away. I only want to see which Kunal is left behind. All I want her is to go away and become a strong woman on her own. I only hope that they show his journey through emotions and not through circumstances, where Nandini is in trouble and he keeps running to save her.

I agree, yesterday the whole divorce fiasco did prove, its Nandini that matters to him. Yes, he was shocked initially but at that moment I really wanted to ask him, ""Dude,do you know your wife? what did you expect?" On a serious note,and I am totally quoting you here, they did have a 7 year of happy marriage and in his own words, marriages are deep relationships and divorces are difficult so his shock and sadness was justified. What surprised me was, that the only flashback he had was of his mother and her asking him to step out. That was the reason for him to give "No objections" to the divorce, not Nandini. I did really liked that because it showed that he is blaming only himself for all the devastation that has been caused, not their marriage, nor Nandini. Else we would have seen a kind of resentment towards her which we have not and which is what happens generally.

No flashbacks of Mauli, his total focus on Nandini as soon as he hears she is in trouble, all indicates that its only Nandini for him at this moment. Now, the question is what is more important for him, Nandini or his family.


PS: Yesterday when Kunal came and told Mauli in that "bigi billi" voice that we need to talk, I was like, oh no no no, thats not going to work. We need Nandini's Kunal here who would have come and told her, "I cannot let you do this and I am not going to allow you to do this" which would have been so much more effective. There would have been some fight but atleast we could have got the talk that we were waiting for.

Second, when Mauli looked at Kunal and was expecting him to object, I really wanted to tell her, "Lady, do you know your husband? When has he said "No" to you? He is not going to object and he is going to relent to your wishes. Go talk to him, only then there will be chance to salvage this horrible situation". Well, I cannot complain as that is what makes them Mauli and Kunal.




Bold - 1 Hahaha ..Too late Baba.. Ab kya faayda. .

Bold - 2 I fail to understand this part. Let's say his mother hadn't asked him to get out or said anything harsh, then what objections would he have raised for the divorce? If he wants to be with Nandini why should he want to stay married to Mauli? Or is it the abruptness with which Mauli is going about it, that would make him raise objections? Something like, "you're going too fast Mauli, let me just sort out Nandini's issues first and then discuss the divorce with Dida and Mamma and let this news sink in first. Can you hold on till then? I mean, I don't know I fail to understand this. He sure as hell cannot stay married to Mauli and continue his relationship with Nandini, right?

Your PS - haha.. He does have two personalities, doesn't he? In fact I have observed his body language with both the women. With Nandini, his body posture itself is different, his spine a little more erect , head held high, voice a little more deeper. And the way he says, Nandini' jaise ki Maharaj abhi koyi aagya dene waale hai.

And with Mauli when he says her name, in invisible closed brackets I can hear " Don't scold me for this please, lekin aise aise huaa.. "

Anyways, now there is no point in the talk right? Going by yesterday's episode he has already made his choice. And with regards to Mauli's "why Kunal why I don't think Mauli or us, the audience, will get any answer.


Bold - 3 I think, that Kunal, who cared for Mauli's wishes no longer exists. If he cared, he wouldn't have done all this in the first place. This Kunal is torn between wanting to be with Nandini and at the same time trying to escape the guilt that he will have to suffer (hurting his family, becoming this man who left his wife for another woman), when he makes that choice.


The least he can actually do now is liberate Mauli from this meaningless marriage. But going by the OLVs, we know that Kunal and Mauli both will cave in and decide to stay together. At this point, I don't know if it is just an act that they put or they will actually consider rebuilding their relationship? I don't think that the latter is even possible. They will just be two unhappy souls, trying to put on an act in front of Dida and outside world, while just suffocating and hurting internally. And the suffocation and hurt is primarily for Mauli. To see him everyday and to live with the knowledge that he is tied to her only due to circumstances and not because he loves her - that is real suffering. Kunal may be physically separted from Nandini, but he at least knows that there is someone out there who loves him wholeheartedly. Also, I am not sure whether he will cut off all means of communication with Nandini. I guess we have to wait and see how this will play out.

Edited by SummerRain7 - 7 years ago
ProfMcGonagall thumbnail
Deal or No Deal Thumbnail Hogwarts Championship 2025 Winning House Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: mango_pudding1

@whyhate, @pamk06 -- rather than morally right or wrong, my thought was that kunal is coming from a very different angle when he says "their love isn't wrong". now, we really need kunal's backstory but the way the CVs cut their scenes with the scenes at home was a bit strange because the mom's reaction stood out in super, stark contrast.

when mouli says divorce, the mom seems to not only expect such an action but she actually seems to silently approve it. there is no word to discourage her and neither is there any hurt or disappointment. instead, it is dadi who gives those reactions. then when dadi asks mouli to forgive kunal and give their marriage a second chance, kunal's mom looks like she wants to throw something. she is very disapproving, tsking, annoyed and gritting her teeth -- again, aren't those really strange reactions if she is his mom?

so that makes me think that kunal is rather referencing himself to his own parents situation. often our view of relationships is based on experience or what we observe at home. so in this case, what exactly did kunal observe and experience in his own parents relationship? think what he means by "they aren't wrong" is that they are willing to own their choices and take responsibility for their actions and therefore, this love is not tainted. he actually seems much more confident and very self-assured now with nandini like he knows exactly what he wants and what he is going to do. there is no second guessing himself.

also in the scene where he comforts nandini, wondered if it was more than instinct that he wasn't startled by nandini's meltdown. instead, he seemed very much in his comfort zone like he has seen this kind of behaviour before and knows exactly what to do...

so back to my theory, I am leaning more and more that kunal's mom is actually his stepmom and something happened with their marriage and his biological mother. he married mouli who is more like his stepmom but perhaps his biological mother may have been closer to nandini and hence, he knows exactly what to do to calm her down and also seems more confident and comfortable...

the CVs seem determined to give us clues in bits and pieces and so we might be really surprised when kunal's backstory comes out. perhaps, it will frame this affair far differently than how viewers read it...



That's true, but will the CVs show Kunal's story? Based on the promo just released it looks like they are now going ahead with bringing Kunal and Mauli back together so most likely Nandini will leave from their life.

Will they really spend some time to show Kunal's story? The perfect time would have been now. When Mauli is making decisions for them and he has promised to stay with Nandini, they could easily have shown Kunal reminiscing on his childhood and his life. Or they could show Yamini talking to Mauli and encouraging her that she is doing right and revealing her story there.

Now showing Kunal's back story only makes sense if he realizes that he loves Mauli and he wants to convince Mauli of the same so he uses his story to explain what happened.
pamk06 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: SummerRain7


Bold - 1 Hahaha ..Too late Baba.. Ab kya faayda. .

Bold - 2 I fail to understand this part. Let's say his mother hadn't asked him to get out or said anything harsh, then what objections would he have raised for the divorce? If he wants to be with Nandini why should he want to stay married to Mauli? Or is it the abruptness with which Mauli is going about it, that would make him raise objections? Something like, "you're going too fast Mauli, let me just sort out Nandini's issues first and then discuss the divorce with Dida and Mamma and let this news sink in first. Can you hold on till then? I mean, I don't know I fail to understand this. He sure as hell cannot stay married to Mauli and continue his relationship with Nandini, right?

Your PS - haha.. He does have two personalities, doesn't he? In fact I have observed his body language with both the women. With Nandini, his body posture itself is different, his spine a little more erect , head held high, voice a little more deeper. And the way he says, Nandini' jaise ki Maharaj abhi koyi aagya dene waale hai.

And with Mauli when he says her name, in invisible closed brackets I can hear " Don't scold me for this please, lekin aise aise huaa.. "

Anyways, now there is no point in the talk right? Going by yesterday's episode he has already made his choice. And with regards to Mauli's "why Kunal why I don't think Mauli or us, the audience, will get any answer.


Bold - 3 I think, that Kunal, who cared for Mauli's wishes no longer exists. If he cared, he wouldn't have done all this in the first place. This Kunal is torn between wanting to be with Nandini and at the same time trying to escape the guilt that he will have to suffer (hurting his family, becoming this man who left his wife for another woman), when he makes that choice.


The least he can actually do now is liberate Mauli from this meaningless marriage. But going by the OLVs, we know that Kunal and Mauli both will cave in and decide to stay together. At this point, I don't know if it is just an act that they put or they will actually consider rebuilding their relationship? I don't think that the latter is even possible. They will just be two unhappy souls, trying to put on an act in front of Dida and outside world, while just suffocating and hurting internally. And the suffocation and hurt is primarily for Mauli. To see him everyday and to live with the knowledge that he is tied to her only due to circumstances and not because he loves her - that is real suffering. Kunal may be physically separted from Nandini, but he at least knows that there is someone out there who loves him wholeheartedly. Also, I am not sure whether he will cut off all means of communication with Nandini. I guess we have to wait and see how this will play out.


@bold Well, I do not think it was his mother but more her words which were the person who is done an impure deed is responsible for it and he is the one who should pay for it. He knows that he is done a wrong and thus he would have never objected to the divorce. In fact, based on what he told Nandini, that was his intention all along. But I guess, it was the shock of it happening so soon. May be he wanted to put his side of things and also ensure that he is not estranged from his mother and Dida, before taking this step. He is not a headstrong person and he also understand that what he did was huge and it would take time for his family to adjust to it emotionally. So her decision so soon would have been a shock for him. I guess, his surprise also must be from the fact that his family is ready to throw him out of their life without giving him a chance to explain. (Remember they never asked him but just gave the judgement) and it might be his way of finding out if that route to his family is still open. Kind of bracing himself on all that he is giving up.

One thing is for sure, he would have not objected. Whatever she would have asked he would have given it to her and this is because of the guilt. I say this, because of my cousin's friend. He almost hates his wife, but he is agreeing to all her irrational wishes and demands. When asked, he just says he does not want to say "No" because he is guilty and he is wrong. He knows she wants them to get back together but he cannot do that, so he is compensating with all her other wishes. Similarly, Kunal is not Rajdeep, and keeping this EMA aside, he is a good person. He knows he has done wrong and recognizes it too. He also knows that he is her biggest culprit and he cannot give her what she actually wants but he can definitely give her everything else she wishes.

@bold 2: No, i think he still cares for her. That care does not change overnight but the nature of that care has changed. They were married for 7 years, so there is a relationship there. The base of those feelings have changed but the dynamics are still there which is the case with every divorce or break-up couple. If you have seen them conversing, what ever their feelings, the way they converse with each other or behave with each other never changes. Having said that, IMO, between Mauli and Nandini's happiness, Kunal will always choose Nandini. But between Mauli's happiness and the rest, he will choose her happiness. I do not know whether his family's happiness come before her or she comes before his family. So, I wish that they show us a conversation between them after Dida's request. If Kunal tells her, please do it for Dida's sake then his family happiness matters to him more but if he says, its your choice, then her happiness matters to him more.

@bold 3: No, that is not Kunal's right anymore nor his responsibility. I agree whatever happened in the past was because of him and he is responsible for it. Based on that, she filed for a divorce and he has agreed to give her freedom. So, whatever happens from this point forward, would be only Mauli's choice and Mauli's responsibility. If she decides to give in to Dida's request, its because she wants to. That is not circumstance, that is her choice. She is choosing to do it.
She currently has a 360 degree view of everything and even with that, at one month mark, if she decides to turn a blind eye and walk with Kunal, continue with the marriage, it will be totally on her head and the consequences of it (Good or Bad) her responsibility. As Kunal and Nandini had to take responsibility for their choices and their actions, similarly Mauli would have to take responsibility for her choices and actions from now on.

You know, Mauli is not a person who digs deeper. She reacts based on the visual circumstances and decides on a course of action. May be that comes with being a doctor. So yesterday, she said that "in 7 years if he did not realize what he means to me and what is this one month going to do". Here, his feelings are not in the picture at all. So there is a very strong chance, that if Kunal comes back to her, she might not dig deeper. She will takes his words on face value and just be happy with the fact that he is with her. I hope not though.




Edited by pamk06 - 7 years ago
pamk06 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: mango_pudding1



yea you are right, he said it before and at the time, thought the CVs were coming from a "all is fair in love and war" kind of thinking but it seems like that actually wasn't that they meant. this time, he gave a whole list of negatives about their relationship but again he insists that their love isn't dirty and they aren't wrong and no one has the right to judge them.

@whyhate, @pamk06 -- rather than morally right or wrong, my thought was that kunal is coming from a very different angle when he says "their love isn't wrong". now, we really need kunal's backstory but the way the CVs cut their scenes with the scenes at home was a bit strange because the mom's reaction stood out in super, stark contrast.

when mouli says divorce, the mom seems to not only expect such an action but she actually seems to silently approve it. there is no word to discourage her and neither is there any hurt or disappointment. instead, it is dadi who gives those reactions. then when dadi asks mouli to forgive kunal and give their marriage a second chance, kunal's mom looks like she wants to throw something. she is very disapproving, tsking, annoyed and gritting her teeth -- again, aren't those really strange reactions if she is his mom?

so that makes me think that kunal is rather referencing himself to his own parents situation. often our view of relationships is based on experience or what we observe at home. so in this case, what exactly did kunal observe and experience in his own parents relationship? think what he means by "they aren't wrong" is that they are willing to own their choices and take responsibility for their actions and therefore, this love is not tainted. he actually seems much more confident and very self-assured now with nandini like he knows exactly what he wants and what he is going to do. there is no second guessing himself.

also in the scene where he comforts nandini, wondered if it was more than instinct that he wasn't startled by nandini's meltdown. instead, he seemed very much in his comfort zone like he has seen this kind of behaviour before and knows exactly what to do...

so back to my theory, I am leaning more and more that kunal's mom is actually his stepmom and something happened with their marriage and his biological mother. he married mouli who is more like his stepmom but perhaps his biological mother may have been closer to nandini and hence, he knows exactly what to do to calm her down and also seems more confident and comfortable...

the CVs seem determined to give us clues in bits and pieces and so we might be really surprised when kunal's backstory comes out. perhaps, it will frame this affair far differently than how viewers read it...


Hmm... it did not think it that way. There is definetely a backstory there and if it was only betrayal by his father they would have brought it up now as a reference. Like father like son.

You are also bang on on his mother's reaction. Very surprising. So may be when this must have happened, Dida must have asked Yamini for the same thing but she might have flatly refused and hence the rift between them. If there is a story, and now would be the time to bring it out to explain the contrast between the two decision on how it shaped their lives.

f she is actually his stepmom, and she took him in at a young age, then we might see Nandini pregnancy track which they would use to explain, how he came to live with Yamini.

@bold:So, his reaction might be on what you are saying or else it can also be from the fact that he is suppose to be one of the best child specialists according to Mauli and very good with children. Hence, the instinctual response on how to calm and comfort her.



SummerRain7 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
Pamk06 - Sorry, I still do not see it the way you do. I think we can agree to disagree. If Kunal wanted time to brace himself and deal with his family he should have started talking long back. His lack of reaction may have been due to shock, but my point is that there is pretty much nothing he can say either ways, because he has made up his mind to choose to be with Nandini. So him not saying anything is not something I would give him credit for. Separating from Mauli would have happened sooner or later, only in this case it is not him choosing the time and announcing the decision.
I understand that the dynamics of the relationship doesn't change overnight , because one cannot simply undo everything that happened in so many years and suddenly go back to being strangers. But he had crossed that line to being Nandini's Kunal now, so nothing he does will actually compensate for that. That is the reason why I said that the least he can do is liberate Mauli from this marriage, legally. I don't understand how that is NOT his responsibility? He may not be SOLELY responsible for it, because Mauli also has to say no to it. But I would really really appreciate if he puts his foot down for something. If he doesn't, then it would amount to him taking advantage of Mauli' 's love for Dida and also depriving her of a chance to move on in life and get over him. I am saying all this based on the assumption that he has firmly affixed Nandini in his heart and mind.

Also, Mauli may not be the one who digs deeper but after being deceived like this by her own husband and best friend, I do not think she would trust again easily. Even if Kunal were to genuinely come back to her, I don't think she would trust him easily, going by her own words.


SummerRain7 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago

Thoughts after watching yesterday's episode.

I am again unable to understand Nandini. The very pertinent questions that Mauli asked her (without resorting to abuse or name calling) failed to make any impact on her. Of course there was momentary regret, but it never made any impact. But a bunch of stranger women mudslinging at her made her want to push Kunal away. Now , I am not undermining her trauma, because that shaming was nothing but plain abuse in full public view and it is bound to affect even those who haven't really done anything wrong. So maybe her reacting to Kunal in that way, was just something that she did in trauma. And the situation was probably created , so that Kunal can mouth those controversial lines - humara pyaar ganda nahi hai.. Galat Nahin.. Etc.


But what still irks me is that the words of those women who called her a homewrecker and worse made her feel guilty and dirty. But why does she not feel guilty and dirty when she reflects upon her own actions. She cheated her best friend who has always wanted the best for her, who went out of her way to make her life comfortable and safe, knowing that Kunal meant the world to her. How is it that Mauli's questions never affected her to the point of wanting to push Kunal away??


When Kunal first confessed his love to her, the first thing that I actually expected, rather wanted her to ask was, "Mauli ka kya? But the silence between them on that subject stretched on forever. That coffee shop convo made us feel as though they knew and have accepted that they will have to hurt Mauli, but then later she gets shocked when Mauli breaks all ties with her. And now Kunal has made a promise to her and will probably in today's episode tell her about Rajdeep signing the divorce papers. Will she then, at least out of curiosity, ask him what will happen to his marriage?


I just find this so hard to stomach. It makes me feel as though she is unable to asses a situation on her own and that she is still not in a state of mind to have a healthy relationship. Understanding how her actions and decisions can affect the people around her is still not her cup of tea. And since she pretty much does not have a life outside of this relationship, we really don't know what her state of mind is or how effectively she can manage life outside of her relationship with Kunal. Hell, we don't even know whether her relationship with even Kunal is healthy or not? They hardly talk and whenever they do she is very accepting of things he says and does. So far, her rejecting Rajdeep and his abuse is the only thing that can be called as an improvement in her character. Baaki, I just cannot understand her.


Now, isn't it odd that Deeda didn't suffer a stroke hearing about her grandson's infidelity? But the D' word, tauba tauba is the end of the world Half of the marriages on Indian telly happen or survive because of this emotional blackmailling. And I just happened to read on the forum that Kunal will continue meeting with Nandini. So no going away??? I hope Mauli uses her brain cells and get out of this marriage before it shatters her self-esteem completely. She may not be able to get over him easily, but she can at least save her dignity.


And I think I agree with mango_pudding about Kunal being the step son of Yamini. She was struggling not to burst out when Dida was speaking to Mauli.

pamk06 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: SummerRain7

Pamk06 - Sorry, I still do not see it the way you do. I think we can agree to disagree. If Kunal wanted time to brace himself and deal with his family he should have started talking long back. His lack of reaction may have been due to shock, but my point is that there is pretty much nothing he can say either ways, because he has made up his mind to choose to be with Nandini. So him not saying anything is not something I would give him credit for. Separating from Mauli would have happened sooner or later, only in this case it is not him choosing the time and announcing the decision.

I understand that the dynamics of the relationship doesn't change overnight , because one cannot simply undo everything that happened in so many years and suddenly go back to being strangers. But he had crossed that line to being Nandini's Kunal now, so nothing he does will actually compensate for that. That is the reason why I said that the least he can do is liberate Mauli from this marriage, legally. I don't understand how that is NOT his responsibility? He may not be SOLELY responsible for it, because Mauli also has to say no to it. But I would really really appreciate if he puts his foot down for something. If he doesn't, then it would amount to him taking advantage of Mauli' 's love for Dida and also depriving her of a chance to move on in life and get over him. I am saying all this based on the assumption that he has firmly affixed Nandini in his heart and mind.

Also, Mauli may not be the one who digs deeper but after being deceived like this by her own husband and best friend, I do not think she would trust again easily. Even if Kunal were to genuinely come back to her, I don't think she would trust him easily, going by her own words.



But didnt he already do that? He is already agreed to a divorce. I agree that he can put his foot down and say, no its not possible but we already saw Mauli agreeing to Dida's request. She is ready to give their marriage a second chance. For her one side was self-respect and on the other Dida. She choosed Dida. That was her choice. Kunal himself will be in dilemma because on one side he has Nandini and the other side Dida. He will choose Dida too. That's his choice.

I really hope we see a conversation between them after Dida makes a request and that will actually tell us whats going on in their head or why they are agreeing to it. If,in that, he says that please do it for Dida's sake then I totally agree with the @bold. But if they make that choice individually without consulting the other, then we can agree to disagree. IMO, right now, the only person responsible for her not moving on with her life is Dida or more appropriately her love for Dida.


pamk06 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
Question for you ladies:
It seems like Dida is very serious about reuniting Mauli and Kunal.

Mauli does not know about all the promises that Kunal is making Nandini nor does she has the verbal confirmation from him about that. Marriage is generally a huge deal for us women and after sometime it almost becomes like a habit. Given a chance, most women would prefer to keep their marriage intact and try to make it successful. Based on this, do you think Mauli should accept Kunal and give him second chance? What would be your advice to Mauli?


pamk06 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: mango_pudding1

re: the question on what kunal would do next?
from all indications it looks like nandini is still the woman for him. like @pamk06 put it and there seems to be no change in that stance. he doesn't seem to resent nandini which is key. he is regretting hurting dadi and his mom because that wasn't part of his calculations whereas mouli is more like collateral damage that he had planned for. would like to know whether his mom is actually his mom because her reactions are really strange.

as for the dadi asking him to give another chance in the promo, if they take it up, can see them faking it to please others. however, I hope the CVs use dadi as a kind of sounding board where kunal gets to voice his views honestly. obviously with mauli, he can't do that but with dadi who doesn't seem to think less of him for having an affair, he might be more comfortable explaining himself.

in masala anti-hero movies, there is always this scene where the anti-hero's friend or well-wisher confronts him and the anti-hero gives his thinking and we get insight into why he feels this way and why he feels like the wrong method is acceptable. so if used well, dadi could be that kind of sounding board and gives us viewers a better peek into kunal's head.


So dadi is finally acting like the matriarch of the family. She is ready to go to any lengths to unite them. She does not blame Kunal for the affair and may be she might not blame Nandini too. She has asked Kunal not to meet Nandini but she does not know her grandson. Do you think when she realizes that she will try to pressurize Nandini and be the main reason for her to decide to leave.

Right now, Nandini does not have anybody, other than Kunal so she believes him totally and thinks they are right. But may be Dadi words would open her eyes to a different perspective and come out similar to her own Mom who always told her that marriages are for ever. This might thus turn into the reason for her to start thinking of moving away from Kunal. Thus, do you see her as turning a sounding board for Nandini instead of Kunal. Thoughts???
Edited by pamk06 - 7 years ago
Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 7 years ago
Its her personal choice but i wanted mauli to give kuna a second chance out of her own will and not dida or anybodys wish ..but before that kunal must repent , which he will not ..he seeks forgiveness but to remove his guilt , so that he and nandu can move on
Edited by _charu_ - 7 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".