Doubt regarding transgender........If Soumya is really? - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

26

Views

6.1k

Users

15

Likes

75

Frequent Posters

madhvi97 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#21
Assuming that Soumya is not a transgender but actually has some anatomy disorder, I doubt how feasible is it that she is not aware of it? šŸ˜•

Even if she has been kept isolated from outer world, she had a sister along her side all these years, and other ladies in the house.. She couldn't differentiate there was something not normal with her, compared to other ladies? There are some visible symptoms like getting menses which would distinguish her from her sister (this is what I could conclude about IS disorders, from wiki and other sources, please correct me if it is wrong)
Sannu_4 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: madhvi97

Assuming that Soumya is not a transgender but actually has some anatomy disorder, I doubt how feasible is it that she is not aware of it? šŸ˜•

Even if she has been kept isolated from outer world, she had a sister along her side all these years, and other ladies in the house.. She couldn't differentiate there was something not normal with her, compared to other ladies? There are some visible symptoms like getting menses which would distinguish her from her sister (this is what I could conclude about IS disorders, from wiki and other sources, please correct me if it is wrong)


Yes. If she has turners syndrome she would not menstruate so obviously voh ma nahi ban sakthi..then how can she not know this before..? Not only this there r many other symptoms which suggest she is not normal..if she really is affected by a chromosomal disorder
arshi8927 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#23

Hey bhagwan...

Confusion hi confusion hai

rnm_83 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#24
i guess she does not get menses and since the people in village are not much educated they termed it as transgender...this might be possibility ...i just hope they handle the topic properly...😲 god knows how harman is going to react ..already poor soumya has so much pressure ...her truth,preeto ki zidd,pati frustrated because of incomplete Sr,maninder hate,and icing on the cake is her mother hide the truth from her 😭😭😭 so much for the innocent girl to dealšŸ˜•
madhvi97 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: rnm_83

i guess she does not get menses and since the people in village are not much educated they termed it as transgender...this might be possibility ...i just hope they handle the topic properly...😲 god knows how harman is going to react ..already poor soumya has so much pressure ...her truth,preeto ki zidd,pati frustrated because of incomplete Sr,maninder hate,and icing on the cake is her mother hide the truth from her😭😭😭 so much for the innocent girl to dealšŸ˜•



In that case her problem will be visible at a much later stage after she reaches puberty.. In this case Maninder hated her and wanted to kill her right from the time she was born.. So she clearly had some external problems like underdeveloped or ambiguous external organs, maybe along with menstruation problem as well šŸ˜•
madhvi97 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: Sukor_fan


Yes. If she has turners syndrome she would not menstruate so obviously voh ma nahi ban sakthi..then how can she not know this before..? Not only this there r many other symptoms which suggest she is not normal..if she really is affected by a chromosomal disorder



In Soumya's case she clearly had some deformed external organs right at the time of birth that's why her father wanted to get rid of her. If she has underdeveloped or ambiguous external body parts, then she most probably won't menstruate. It is pretty common for two sisters to discuss among themselves about their period problems!! So it seems unbelievable that Soumya had no idea at all about her problem.. And if she has a normal menstruation cycle, then she has fully developed female organs, external as well as internal, isn't that so? This all is quite confusing šŸ˜•
Anurulz thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#27
I don't follow the show but i am a psychiatrist and I hope this information helps the fans of the show who are unable to understand the character and the concept.. (judging from the tellybuzz article from where I am copy pasting my post).. not my intention to offend anyone..
nobody is born a "transgender", one grows up to identify more with the opposite gender and dislikes own gender..there is no way physically to know that one is a transgender unless one chooses to dress up and behave like the opposite gender and is unable to do so completely..which is why there are sex-change treatments and surgeries..so this particular character cannot be a "transgender" and be unaware of it while her parents know it..
"Intersex" on the other hand is an anatomical issue..medically speaking, from what I understood from this article, this character probably suffers from a "mullerian duct anomoly".. her ovaries are fine, which is why she has normal female hormones and characteristics, but her external genitalia is underdeveloped..she probably has an inadequate uterus due to which there might be fertility issues.. all of which MAYBE surgically corrected, tho the extent of it will depend on the level of anomoly..there is no question of her being pretty or attracted to her husband coz she is a female, genetically and psychologically..
And also for everybody's information, it doesn't mean that all intersex disorders cause the patient to look abnormal..there is something called "testicular feminization disorder" where a genetical male has no receptors for action of testosterone and can look like the world's most beautiful woman!! Coz all the testosterone is converted to estrogen..the human body is fascinating and compensates as much as it can..let us move beyond the societal barriers..
I hope this show doesn't make a joke of a serious medical problem to gain trps off it..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".