Created

Last reply

Replies

40

Views

3.9k

Users

15

Likes

211

Frequent Posters

hotdogg thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#22
Arshi,

You said it right on Mumbai track...

I felt the same when it abruptly started...especially since my faith in the mediocricity of the current writers is more stronger than yours 😉...

...however there was so much excitement in the forum when this track started that I did not want to rain down on it...especially since I do not see the show nowadays...so why spoil the mood?

...considering the show is being shot in mumbai, shooting a show in a flat is much cheaper than:
- maintaining a huge set (physical infrastructure which will need maintenance even if it is a set),
- stylish costume inventory for the women in cast, especially for kumud
- shoot time (getting entire female cast ready with costumes, managing these during the shoot, waiting for the hairdo setting etc. etc.) ...

Now all kumud might need is to just put on a dress, blow dry her hair and you are ready to go...Noticed in the epis I watched yesterday that this anushka is also in a jeans and tshirt/dress all the time...real easy- weasy...😎

...Agree with you that the problem is on a more fundamental level - the creative story.

On one hand the writers seem to want to adhere to the essence of the source which is:
1) the travails of saraswatichandra (not kumud) and how it impacts everyone (especially seperation from kumud)...which would make this a male protagonist driven show
2) placed in a similar (and modern) cultural setting - the village of RN & Mumbai.

On the other hand TRPs dictate:
1) a women-centric show, complete with mundane stereotyped housewifey stuff like going to market, elaborate food making, hubby comes first etc.
2) dumbing down and negligible presence of the male in a modern setting ...this one has saras doing some 'important' stuff no one knows about (like in all those umpteen shows where the males are suited - booted and run some crores of buisness)
3) an external villian or villianess/vamp...
4) stupid younger siblings who provide 'comic' relief by trying to be 'endearing'.

Now, if the writers are the TRP show types, the center of gravity is shifting towards the 'other hand'...add the economic reason's, upcoming renewal date and they just cannot experiment with any meaningful or realistic adaption in the story...and so we are stuck with the lowest common denominator - just another TV soap...

...and that's a real problem due to the residual memory for some of us - the previous generation of fans - and we really can't do anything about it...

Na Biwi Na Bachha Na Baap Bada Na Maiyan
The Whole Thing Is That Ke Bhaiya Sabse Bada Rupaiya

p.s.
Lal04-
Like your posts...I guess would have loved to exchange notes if you had been around in the halcyon days where the story was prime, was real and drove some of us oldies nuts with its subtleties...






Edited by hotdogg - 11 years ago
Sadia_JenAm thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#23
Hgg and lal04
U guys r truly amazing...ur in-depth analysis is simply a treat to read...wish the show had the same charm as b4 so that we could get hotdogg ji posting regularly...but is in an abominable state now...this track may pull up trps somehow but its abhorring trust me...prashant's looks make me puke...yuck!
rosame thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: hotdogg

Arshi,

You said it right on Mumbai track...

I felt the same when it abruptly started...especially since my faith in the mediocricity of the current writers is more stronger than yours 😉...

...however there was so much excitement in the forum when this track started that I did not want to rain down on it...especially since I do not see the show nowadays...so why spoil the mood?

...considering the show is being shot in mumbai, shooting a show in a flat is much cheaper than:
- maintaining a huge set (physical infrastructure which will need maintenance even if it is a set),
- stylish costume inventory for the women in cast, especially for kumud
- shoot time (getting entire female cast ready with costumes, managing these during the shoot, waiting for the hairdo setting etc. etc.) ...

Now all kumud might need is to just put on a dress, blow dry her hair and you are ready to go...Noticed in the epis I watched yesterday that this anushka is also in a jeans and tshirt/dress all the time...real easy- weasy...😎

...Agree with you that the problem is on a more fundamental level - the creative story.

On one hand the writers seem to want to adhere to the essence of the source which is:
1) the travails of saraswatichandra (not kumud) and how it impacts everyone (especially seperation from kumud)...which would make this a male protagonist driven show
2) placed in a similar (and modern) cultural setting - the village of RN & Mumbai.

On the other hand TRPs dictate:
1) a women-centric show, complete with mundane stereotyped housewifey stuff like going to market, elaborate food making, hubby comes first etc.
2) dumbing down and negligible presence of the male in a modern setting ...this one has saras doing some 'important' stuff no one knows about (like in all those umpteen shows where the males are suited - booted and run some crores of buisness)
3) an external villian or villianess/vamp...
4) stupid younger siblings who provide 'comic' relief by trying to be 'endearing'.

Now, if the writers are the TRP show types, the center of gravity is shifting towards the 'other hand'...add the economic reason's, upcoming renewal date and they just cannot experiment with any meaningful or realistic adaption in the story...and so we are stuck with the lowest common denominator - just another TV soap...

...and that's a real problem due to the residual memory for some of us - the previous generation of fans - and we really can't do anything about it...

Na Biwi Na Bachha Na Baap Bada Na Maiyan
The Whole Thing Is That Ke Bhaiya Sabse Bada Rupaiya

p.s.
Lal04-
Like your posts...I guess would have loved to exchange notes if you had been around in the halcyon days where the story was prime, was real and drove some of us oldies nuts with its subtleties...







@hotdogg
Very well written post. You said it right. The writers don't know whether to continue with " the travails of saraswatichandra (not kumud)...which would make this a male protagonist driven show "
Or follow TRP driven women-centric serial . In this confusion they have screwed up the beautiful show. Dil ki suno ya dimag ki ya phir TRP ki suno.
_OrChiD_ thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#25
The writer wants TRP, right? And it has proven that SaMUD romance can pull TRP, the pre wedding track had been gotten TRP. There was no need to show that SaMUD going to pras house, they could show pras plan has been spoiled and SaMUD managed to live at home without electricity, huge chance to show samud romance and on the other hand they could show pras furious act as plan get spoiled. They could use a party for at least 1 week. Unfortunately the party place was even so narrow that it looked like a room. Haven't ever realized that a PH can't even manage a party place.
If rumor to be believed then pras character for 4/5 months, so if they doing all this initially what they will show in the coming episode?
Are they going to show Pra locked kumud in his house and Saras is searching, searching, searching searching for months, wonder how it can pull TRP, This writer not even able to write dream sequence properly.


I guess I am done with ranting, sorry Arshi di.
Edited by Linda25 - 11 years ago
jyo_loveurlife thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#26
Hello Arshiji... 😃same complaints from my side too...😭 why why why are Saras-Kumud sooo dumb...🤢 humare yaha neighbors kaun hai pata nahi hota hai 😆(i'm sure yehi haal hai saare bade shehar ka 😆) n here he's acting over friendly n offering bedroom on powercut..😲 even if we justify here saying they r new to Mumbai..😆 they dont know how ppl are in big city n they r thinking ppl are friendly like in RN...😲 🤣 wt abt Saras!!???😲 he is Harvard return.. lived in Dubai!! isse kya hua hai???😡 Kumud ke saat rehte rehte he's become more dumb!! 😕 uper se Pra's acting so chipko to Kumud...😡 kha gayi kumud ki detectivegiri... 😕 atleast cant she sense something fishy about Pra!! ittu sa bhi doubt nahi on Pra!!!???🤢 looks like dimaag kaam karna bandh kardiya hai shayad... 😕 disgusting!! 😕 🤢

And di heard Ghumaan's coming back!! 😲 to take revenge on all including Danny!!! 🤪 pata nahi iski kya zaroot hai... cvs are already taking revenge on us by these senseless tracks... 🤣 yeh aakar kya karegi!! 😆
Arshics thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#27
Waise, I would be extremely suspicious and scared of a guy who lit romantic candles in his bedroom every night, kyon ki khushiyan kabhi bhi aa sakti hai!
I mean its the bachelor pad of a single guy living alone and he, every night creates this romantic ambience, in the off chance that khushiyan ( a girl to sleep in his bed? ) will walk in kabhi bhi? is just weird, and khatre ki ghanti

and when he invites the young neighboring couple to come and sleep in that bed,

without even knowing them well - double weird! And khatre ki double ghanti.

remember Saras's bedroom in Dubai - functional, modern, tasteful yet manly! Yahan toh itna iska bedroom bahut made for a romantic couple tha!

That guy is screaming loud and clear, look at me, I am a pervert, and our dobos are deaf and blind
Edited by Arshics - 11 years ago
hotdogg thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: Arshics

Waise, I would be extremely suspicious and scared of a guy who lit romantic candles in his bedroom every night, kyon ki khushiyan kabhi bhi aa sakti hai!

I mean its the bachelor pad of a single guy living alone and he, every night creates this romantic ambience, in the off chance that khushiyan ( a girl to sleep in his bed? ) will walk in kabhi bhi? is just weird, and khatre ki ghanti

and when he invites the young neighboring couple to come and sleep in that bed,

without even knowing them well - double weird! And khatre ki double ghanti.

remember Saras's bedroom in Dubai - functional, modern, tasteful yet manly! Yahan toh itna iska bedroom bahut made for a romantic couple tha!

That guy is screaming loud and clear, look at me, I am a pervert, and our dobos are deaf and blind



And then you had kumud roaming around all alone, in a stranger's unfamiliar house, in her nightdress, in the middle of the night, after hearing a breaking / strange sound...which woman does that?...






Arshics thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: hotdogg



And then you had kumud roaming around all alone, in a stranger's unfamiliar house, in her nightdress, in the middle of the night, after hearing a breaking / strange sound...which woman does that?...




Hgg, kya sawaal poocha hai!

The very same woman, who goes off to a red light area without telling her family about her whereabouts

Also the same one who walks off in a huff becos hubby dear wasn't an obedient boy in London, even though she did not have a phone, and they were in a foreign country

Our Prashant seems to done his research well and knows that this dobo sundari will walk into all his traps happily, and poor Saras will be caught unawares !

Fools go where angels fear to tread!
ShanUlas thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#30
frankly speaking i am not at all hating this track . It very realistic for me

kusum and anushka r very reall girls and i really see many such items and what say i was one of them once...rofl

and for kumud well , being teacher really kills many of ur senses as u really r so nerdy about things . But yaar all ladies have sixth sense in such case which kumud absolutely lacks. Well, she always lacks ,don't we all know that !!

hope saras ghanti bajing tan tan tan ...coz he was always a common guy in love while kumud ji was a devi maiyya
Edited by ShanUlas - 11 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".