I wrote this on another post but seems to fit in better here; I agree that a little tension, hardship and intensity between the main leads is great; it leads to dramatic scenes and emotions but the separation track can't go on indefinitely. This isn't a 3 hour movie, this is a series and the audience will tune out if the "break-up" lasts too long, after all, how many months of that can keep the audience interested?
I think people have to give the show and the CV's some creative leeway to change from the book or story, if you already know how the show is and will end, that's no fun, its already pre-determined. The difficulty in adapting books to movies is obvious, the books are always better so the movies that succeed use the source book as inspiration, touch on the main points but allow the series to grow beyond the book. So what if its a little different, its no disrespect to the original story, that's a classic and always will be, but adapting it to the tastes of the modern audience will allow the series to last for a few yrs.
Have the tension and heartache of separation, have the moments of true love and passion, have the plot thicken with the addition of the new family and parallel lead but also use the supporting cast and develop a few of their own storylines, albeit in the background. Have the Danny/KumarI story parallel for a little while and then have a storyline with Kusum, the actress is good, pretty, so allow her some moments in the series to grow, and no, not just have her wind up being with Saras just because the original story says so.
Anyways, everyone has their opinions, none are right or wrong, just coming from a practical TV modern audience member, a series that lasts has to adapt and change in accordance to the times, blindly following a pre-scripted novel will not make the series last for 2 yrs.
P.S. If the show carries through with Kumud marrying someone else just because the original book says so, the series will lose a large amount of viewers because although it sounds very noble and romantic to still be in love with Saras while being married to someone else, lusting for somebody else is wrong, no matter the circumstances and to me, the love story between Samud will be tainted. A tragedy can work in a movie, not a TV series that expects to run for a few yrs at least.
Edited by Spartan187 - 12 years ago
Itti Si Khushi Sab TV
Anupamaa
Love Friendship Dating and Relationships
Hindi TV Shows
