Originally posted by: aarfar
[ I will disagree to this. Saying that it is not CV's fault and it is only Vishal's fault ... is a bit harsh. I think the characterization of Vinay was hugely flawed. And coupled with it Vishal's inconsistency as an actor completely ruined Vinay's character and the couple Vindiya. Vishal has given good performances but not on a regular basis. There are lots of flaws in Vinay and Vishal. So, blaming only Vishal will not give the CV's a clean chit and likewise blaming only Vinay will not give Vishal the clean chit. .. I'm not a Vishal fan. I like him but not his fan. I'm a BVD and Bimz fan .... 😳
Agree with you that we can not blame Vinay/Vishal alone... but did he help in the cause? the answer is NO! Do you think if similar scenario had given to Bimz or even to Akki wouldnt they had improvised ? i don think so...he has not change a bit.Agree the transition part but if one lacks other should put their hands up and say ok I will do it..What you think Bindiya character is flawless? a girl who is educated..talented like her is tolerating everything if its only about her then we could have understood ,but how you can defend it when she did not utter a word when ppl used to insult his dad/bro/mom and sisters? so flaw is there as well even Bindiya's char transformed overnight..but didnt she perform?? 😊 so CV or no CV you should perfom under all circumstances and if you are not able to do so...then......nothing is left to be said😊
I agree with this ... but in defense I would like to say that there was no transition period from hatred to love for Vinay. They didn't show Vinay guilty for what he has done and they didn't even make him try to prove himself worthy of Bindiya. Directly SR .... how can an raw actor get in to the mould of a positive guy so soon when all along he has been grey. As far as the chemistry goes, I think it is the directors fault and also the editors .... I think he must be some "chui-mui" types who closes his eyes when such scenes happen out of shyness and so never asked for a retake. And how else can one explain the "bahon ke darmiya" song and dance .... it looked as if Vindiya were rehearsing for Nach Baliye ..
What ever you said is TRUE but applies on Bindiya as well .When on one hand an actor who is opposite him is getting nominations and on the other hand we are discussing what could be the root cause of not so successful jodi then blame will automatically come on the other half of the couple or lead😊 About teh song Bindiya was also the part of the scene she was present everywhere in each scene about which we are discussing that its CV's or Editors or Directors fault....so this is self explanatory!
Whatever they showed here, I think it was pretty much in Vinay's character ... totally immature ... for him finding a job was like having a cup of tea. I think Vishal did good acting while he was demonstrating as a salesman and even his outburst. If only they had not started the election track we could have seen Vinay and Vishal grow. Even the election track was good but the dance track totally ruined it. I hated the track ... it was totally uncalled for. But the only positive we got from this track was Vishal's performance. Vishal excelled in the scene where Vinay confronts Bindiya.
Well i can not argue there as i did not see it..but again..actor doesnt have any choice where they can say we will do good in so and so scene and cant do justice to so and so scene...hope you are getting my point of view...nothing against you or Vishal just that...for me he was not good enough! The serial suffered because of it for sure..as after getting a TRP of 3 something if you are not successful as a jodi then you should think about the reason as well ...there must be some..😊
I think this is it .... the TRP race ... its the main culprit ... the CV's don't get freedom to do as they want but have to twist and turn the stories to keep climbing the TRP ladder ....
Well If we talk about the plot, story ,timeslot and with new actors..then everything was against the show yet it has got the success..and like everything TRPs this all rat race has its positives and negatives both..IF BVD had scored high TRPs wouldn't we enjoyed it?? So why to curse it when we are not getting it
It shouldn't be like take it on your own whims and fancy. Accept it totally or discard it totally.
Like I said, Vishal has his flaws but Vinay's character is also flawed. Vinay had the worse styling, no career, no opinion, lazy, reading books and roaming around with friends, in short - idle mind devil's workshop ... Vishal's diction never improved, inconsistent acting, careless laid back attitude, lack of interest ...
Agree again...just again my two cents...If we noticed that his char styling everything was flawed then why the actor potraying the role couldnt see it?? 😊It means you are not aware or may be not interested or what ever the x..y.. z reason...
My opinion only .... 😊
Respect your opinion 😊
Kyunki Saas Bhi Kabhi Bahu Thi 2
