Main Bhi 'A' Dheta Hun...

Oki...umm...no offense is meant to anyone.

I'm confused with the Judges and their comments and grading.

Why is it that every single contestent is getting A's? I mean they point stuff out and say oh it wasnt that great or it wasn't as good as it could've been etc but they still end up giving A's. They over look things like the kid's singing flat and are too picky on other contestents. They change the rules in the middle of the show to save contestents that they dont want leaving. They gave Rohan (who i think is great) an A even when Sameer told the truth and said that he was flat in places. Even Vasundra was flat in places but that was never mentioned. They never commented on Tanmay's scale mistake.

Anamika sang beautifully and yet she didn't get A+s...Amir sang well and yet he was picked in every performance.😕

Do you guys see this stuff? I mean it's hard not to see some sort of partaility...

Originally posted by: IBserenity

Oki...umm...no offense is meant to anyone.

I'm confused with the Judges and their comments and grading.

Why is it that every single contestent is getting A's? I mean they point stuff out and say oh it wasnt that great or it wasn't as good as it could've been etc but they still end up giving A's. They over look things like the kid's singing flat and are too picky on other contestents. They change the rules in the middle of the show to save contestents that they dont want leaving. They gave Rohan (who i think is great) an A even when Sameer told the truth and said that he was flat in places. Even Vasundra was flat in places but that was never mentioned. They never commented on Tanmay's scale mistake.

Anamika sang beautifully and yet she didn't get A+s...Amir sang well and yet he was picked in every performance.😕

Do you guys see this stuff? I mean it's hard not to see some sort of partaility...

just to point out, Tanmay didn't have a scale mistake he purposely took it 1 note lower cause otherwise his voice was cracking. just pointing that out. i don't think there is much partiality. i think we have all developed our favorites and thus cannot see others singing well. also, how much knowledge do we have of music anyways?

Originally posted by: ts9787

just to point out, Tanmay didn't have a scale mistake he purposely took it 1 note lower cause otherwise his voice was cracking. just pointing that out. i don't think there is much partiality. i think we have all developed our favorites and thus cannot see others singing well. also, how much knowledge do we have of music anyways?

my dad has been in the music field for more than 25 years. So yes i know wht i'm talking about...