Smita's elimination was unfair - Page 4

Smita used to sing better than Anamika when the competition began. Then Suresh deliberately broke her morale by unfairly giving her low grades and criticizing her all the time - when finally Smita reached a point when she just gave up. She was also suffering from toncilitis, so her vocal was not supporting her either.

Inspite of her weak performances of late, she definitely did not deserve to go out so early on.

The judges seem to look away when others make mistake. A glaring example is Amir Hafiz. I have nothing against him and wish him all the best but he simply does not deserve to be in the show. He makes mistakes after mistakes on each show - can not remember lines - made a terrible rendering of
Jiya Dhadak something from his own genre - and yet Suresh smiles benevolently upon him. When he sings he is never with the song - totally lacks concentration. He is still there while Rohit and Vibhore are gone ? - can't accept it. Rohit had a real classical base and Vibhore had true potential.

Another example is Vaishali - she is a spoilt brat and very irritating - don't know why Zee kept her in the show for so long - she deserves to go next round.

I would not say her elimination was unfair, but , definitely this little girl was treated unfairly when she was in the show.

Originally posted by: holymary

Smita used to sing better than Anamika when the competition began. Then Suresh deliberately broke her morale by unfairly giving her low grades and criticizing her all the time - when finally Smita reached a point when she just gave up. She was also suffering from toncilitis, so her vocal was not supporting her either.

Inspite of her weak performances of late, she definitely did not deserve to go out so early on.

The judges seem to look away when others make mistake. A glaring example is Amir Hafiz. I have nothing against him and wish him all the best but he simply does not deserve to be in the show. He makes mistakes after mistakes on each show - can not remember lines - made a terrible rendering of
Jiya Dhadak something from his own genre - and yet Suresh smiles benevolently upon him. When he sings he is never with the song - totally lacks concentration. He is still there while Rohit and Vibhore are gone ? - can't accept it. Rohit had a real classical base and Vibhore had true potential.

Another example is Vaishali - she is a spoilt brat and very irritating - don't know why Zee kept her in the show for so long - she deserves to go next round.

Thank you so much for explaining the dellema surrounding Smita so well and so appropriatelly with examples. 👏

Bootom line is , Lil Champs is following some biased critera and controvercies to hype this show to raise TRP for the channel.

Originally posted by: Manik_mia

You are right on this. I think it was effecting her confidence and ultimately lost faith on herself.

Hey Manik! Glad u feel the same!!!!!😃

Smita was definitely treated unfairly ...If judges were not so harsh on her and treated her like others who were besura at times I wouldn't have bothered that she left before Vaishali and rohanpreet.....

But the way she was treated with stern faces was sad..where as for others it was like "ha app ne antara achha nahi gaya" or "aapke sur idhar udhar hile the lekin aapki aadaye achhi thi" 😲 ....

I really felt bad for this budding talent ...I just wish her all the best !!!

when I hear her songs without listening to judges comments , they simply sound awesome ....I loved the way she sang Morni baaga maa..it's such a tough song to sing with different voice modulations .....

I agree with Ajab-si-music and holy mary. She was definitely treated unfairly by the judges and lost all her confidence. She had the potential to become the winner. Another big loss was Vibhore. Amir has loads of talent, but lacks sincerity. I agree with holy mary on her points about him. Now the most deserving candidate is Anamika.

Originally posted by: bambooshoot

I agree with Ajab-si-music and holy mary. She was definitely treated unfairly by the judges and lost all her confidence. She had the potential to become the winner. Another big loss was Vibhore. Amir has loads of talent, but lacks sincerity. I agree with holy mary on her points about him. Now the most deserving candidate is Anamika.

Now Sonu is doing the same thing what he did to Smita episode after episode. We should not loose Anamika; then nothing will be left in the show.

Originally posted by: Manik_mia

Now Sonu is doing the same thing what he did to Smita episode after episode. We should not loose Anamika; then nothing will be left in the show.

Says Who??? like you said to Naani! maybe nothing for you hehe. Lekin for the rest of us Aamir and Tanmay will be there! Good enuff! 😆

Originally posted by: AznDesi

Says Who??? like you said to Naani! maybe nothing for you hehe. Lekin for the rest of us Aamir and Tanmay will be there! Good enuff! 😆

At this moment Anamika is the Jewel of the show.

Originally posted by: holymary

Smita used to sing better than Anamika when the competition began. Then Suresh deliberately broke her morale by unfairly giving her low grades and criticizing her all the time - when finally Smita reached a point when she just gave up. She was also suffering from toncilitis, so her vocal was not supporting her either.

Inspite of her weak performances of late, she definitely did not deserve to go out so early on.

The judges seem to look away when others make mistake. A glaring example is Amir Hafiz. I have nothing against him and wish him all the best but he simply does not deserve to be in the show. He makes mistakes after mistakes on each show - can not remember lines - made a terrible rendering of
Jiya Dhadak something from his own genre - and yet Suresh smiles benevolently upon him. When he sings he is never with the song - totally lacks concentration. He is still there while Rohit and Vibhore are gone ? - can't accept it. Rohit had a real classical base and Vibhore had true potential.

Another example is Vaishali - she is a spoilt brat and very irritating - don't know why Zee kept her in the show for so long - she deserves to go next round.

You may have some basis but not many will agree other than to your last point, which may find some support.