Created

Last reply

Replies

57

Views

3.7k

Users

17

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

124014 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: RRulz1

Judges must be careful not to hype up any one kid. Previously, Sameer was so hyped up. As a result, better singers like Pawni and Abrokanti lost. Alka Yagnik had also mentioned that she had expected Pawni to be in the final three. well did you ever think that Diwakar didn't deserve to be in top 3??? dont you think he was hyped and came through cuz of sympathy? Sameer wasn't hyped at all!.. he came through for his pure performance and singing skills. if others had even 5% of his confidence for stage they would had been able to put up a fight. Anyhow raat gaee, baat gaee...BHOOL JAAO!😆 accept that sameer was the best😉😆

In this season, they are hyping up the boys more than girls, especially Aamir. He is not among the best singers, although he is so cute and has a great personality. During the "parents episode" they devoted so much time to showing his supporters / family from Bhopal. Yet, this was not done for the rest of the participants. Once, Sonu Nigam specifically requested all the viewers to vote for Aamir. They should not try to sway voters one way or the other. It is not fair to the other kids who are competing. Seeing everyone's reaction to that AV, do you think he will still get votes??? dont you think that they played it to get him eliminated?? plus he's a gr88888 singer and deserves to be hyped, which he hasn't been lately.... but aafter this episode, i wonder how long he'll last...

Also, Aamir is not the only "poor" contestant there, Rohit who was eliminated had a very sad family background too - his father was poor too and his father is the only one raising him. This was not brought out until his elimination. true but like Sonu said, as long as you have a roof over your head, you're not poor.😛 although i hadn't expected him to be eliminated. at least, not so early of this competition.

At one point for Aamir, they claimed that he had no family, yet we see his brother there every time. It's good that he is there to support his brother, but they should not try to mislead the viewers. PARENTS... his parents weren't there to support lke how everyone else's were... no matter what, siblings cant take the place of parents.

They are also very biased against the girls. They will always bring out their bad points. While, all the boys bad points are not mentioned even though they are also making several mistakes when singing and choosing easier songs. To Rohanpreet - Suresh Wadekar gave an A+ although he did not sing well. Sonu gave him a B+, and this was probably more accurate since Rohanpreet had selected a song Sonu sang and Sonu would be the best judge for that. The girls always get lower scores than they deserve. i agree w/ this, bechaari Smita. they always point out her mistake w/ that shocking background music which makes it sound worseeeeeeeee!

124014 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: AznDesi



I think we already established this fact right in the first post and all post following that not to mention also in various other threads. What is not established by a few is that he is a TOP 3 SINGER. Although majority of the people think so already!! So i am here to establish that fact.

Samjha mammu?

Samjha = understood.... just clearing it out for manikji😆😆😆

oh and if you didn't understand it, let us know... we know several ways to make one 'understand', right tote😆

RRulz1 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#13
Everybody is of course entitled to her/his opinion. However, I'm sure that there are several people who also believe that Aamir is not one of the best contestants ("one of the best" meaning, good enough to be in the top 8, but not top 3). All the kids in this season are amazing and the competition is strong. Aamir is not one of the strongest. Earlier he could barely remember his lines, and even now, he does not have the range of some of the other contestants. He seems like such a nice kid, laughing most of the time, but my point is that at this stage of the competition, judges shouldn't randomly hype up any one kid - and by that I mean *any* one not just Aamir. They should *all* be treated fairly.

It is still worth noting that judges are harsher on the girls than they are on the boys. Not just in this season but prior ones too. For example, they bring out every error Anamika/Smita make, but w/the boys they don't bring out their mistakes as often and are more lenient with grades.

Lil Champs (previous season)
Diwakar - actually I don't think he should've been in the top 3 either. Top 3 should've been Sanchita (still as a winner), Abrokanti, and Pawni. Alka Yagnik herself had said that Pawni should have been in the top 3.
RRulz1 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#14
Everybody is of course entitled to her/his opinion. However, I'm sure that there are several people who also believe that Aamir is not one of the best contestants ("one of the best" meaning, good enough to be in the top 8, but not top 3). All the kids in this season are amazing and the competition is strong. Aamir is not one of the strongest. Earlier he could barely remember his lines, and even now, he does not have the range of some of the other contestants. He seems like such a nice kid, laughing most of the time, but my point is that at this stage of the competition, judges shouldn't randomly hype up any one kid - and by that I mean *any* one not just Aamir. They should *all* be treated fairly.

It is still worth noting that judges are harsher on the girls than they are on the boys. Not just in this season but prior ones too. For example, they bring out every error Anamika/Smita make, but w/the boys they don't bring out their mistakes as often and are more lenient with grades.

Lil Champs (previous season)
Diwakar - actually I don't think he should've been in the top 3 either. Top 3 should've been Sanchita (still as a winner), Abrokanti, and Pawni. Alka Yagnik herself had said that Pawni should have been in the top 3.
RRulz1 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#15
Sorry that last reply showed up twice, not sure why it did that and don't know how to delete the double entry.
rock&roll thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#16

hahaha...some discussion going here.....Dia and Ron actually agreeing and supporting each other on some topic...wow!!isn't that an achievement of sorts? 😉 😆 😆
Ok ,here's my opinion.....I believe Amir is among the top 3 singers this time.....yes,his poverty issue(so called) is being hyped...after all he is not poor ....It is just that on a monetary basis he is relatively poorer than the rest.....Amir 's dad may not be present to support him onstage but he at least has a father & mother....so he is very lucky....If u ask me who is the poorest(unluckiest) contestant,I'd say it was Rohit...coz he doesn't have a mother and that loss cann't be filled......his father is(and has been )out of jobs..so i guess he isn't very rich either.....But Rohit never seemed to feel any overwhelming sense of sympathy for himself(whic is very good)....and I don't think Amir wanted to harp on this poverty issue either..I'm sure it is Zee's strategy....I guess Amir is feeling bad abt it but can't do anything..caught in a catch 22. So it is not Amir's fault in any way....and being a good singer he doesn't need sympathy(but wait....... am i being idealistic..after all Rohit is out)

as for judges hyping kids...Sonu goes overborad in his praise of Amir pretty often.😉.Sureshji is more balanced....though he too has a soft corner for Rohanpreet.....Sonu's mimicry of Smita was(i thought) a li'l harsh...otherwise I don't judges are hyping anyone.Zee hypes Tanmay & vaishali by givng them too much airtime and scope for funny/cute dialogues.😉

Edited by rock&roll - 17 years ago
Summer3 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#17

Hey my Rohanpreet the Prince of Patiala is very good and has a fantastic voice. So he is not overhyped at all.😕

I like Aamir very much too.

Vaishali is also overhyped but Anamika and Smita are pretty good too.

These are all real singers.

rock&roll thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: Summer3

Hey my Rohanpreet the Prince of Patiala is very good and has a fantastic voice. So he is not overhyped at all.😕

I like Aamir very much too.

Vaishali is also overhyped but Anamika and Smita are pretty good too.

These are all real singers.

I don't think Sureshji hypes Rohanpreet...Sureshji is very sparing with his words.....,to hype ka sawaal hi nahin uthta....but i do i he has a slight bias towards the prince of Patiala...I maybe wrong😉....Amir is very good too...but I think Sonu has a soft spot for him...which makes Sonu a little xtra lenient with him😉..again purely my opinion..kya hai ki Dia aur Ron ke saath baat karke mera IQ aur EQ dono kum ho gaye hain...to kabhi kabhi baat samajhne mein galti ho jaati hai 😉.....so give huge discount for my IQ and EQ😉

Edited by rock&roll - 17 years ago
Summer3 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: rock&roll

I don't think Sureshji hypes Rohanpreet...Sureshji is very sparing with his words.....,to hype ka sawaal hi nahin uthta....but i do i he has a slight bias towards the prince of Patiala...I maybe wrong😉....Amir is very good too...but I think Sonu has a soft spot for him...which makes Sonu a little xtra lenient with him😉..again purely my opinion..kya hai ki Dia aur Ron ke saath baat karke mera IQ aur EQ dono kum ho gaye hain...to kabhi kabhi baat samajhne mein galti ho jaati hai 😉.....so give huge discount for my IQ and EQ😉

Ho Ho Ho !😆

But they may not catch u.

Rasny thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: rock&roll

I don't think Sureshji hypes Rohanpreet...Sureshji is very sparing with his words.....,to hype ka sawaal hi nahin uthta....but i do i he has a slight bias towards the prince of Patiala(correct)...I maybe wrong😉(U r not)...Amir is very good too...but I think Sonu has a soft spot for him...which makes Sonu a little xtra lenient with him😉( yes)..again purely my opinion(Mine too)..kya hai ki Dia aur Ron ke saath baat karke mera IQ aur EQ dono kum ho gaye hain...to kabhi kabhi baat samajhne mein galti ho jaati hai 😉.....so give huge discount for my IQ and EQ😉( no idea abt it😆)

u r a good analyzer😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".