Vaishali paid for Loria - Page 2

Originally posted by: SAnode

You are forgetting their age differences. Loria is 12yrs old but comparing to the other kids of her age her singing is quite ordinary. In that aspect Vaishali is way better than her. Loria's voice trembles too much. It became very evident when she sang 'katra katra' and Sonu pointed out it. She has proved that at 12, she's as bright as a 17yr old(she's passed 12th). But i should say that she doesnt have that much talent in singing.

I agree that their age differences are huge and during this period a difference of 2-3 yrs is a lot..Vaishali is 10 and Loria is maybe,13.Keeping the age factor in mind,Vaishali is way better and when Vaishali is 13,she cld beat Loria hollow....

But unfortunately,currently,the competition format doesn't differentiate between age groups...All kids,aged 7-14 come under this category..When they have been put under one category,they will have to be judged equally...We shld presume,that we dn't know the age/face of these kids and only listen to their songs...On that basis,Loria was better.For eg)when Loria passed her 12th coz she was good,not becoz she was a 12 yr old competing with 17 yr olds....Hence age,unfortunately,is not a criteria here as per the rules of the competition. 😊

Viashali's elimination was definitely unfair.. It had to be Loria this week.. What I dont like abt Loria is that she sings all the songs in her own style and most often looses the entire soul of the song... She has hardly shown any versatility as well!

You are right. Unfortunately the whole idea of a show where a 10yr old is made to compete with a 13 or 14yr old is absolutely wrong. Just like the other competitions where girls and boys are put in the same race and girls always loose. There is a basic principle they always forget. Comparisons sholud be done b/n similar groups.You can see that in children's school level competitions they categorise them as primary,upper primary,high school etc. There's no comparison b/n a 10 yr old and a 15yr old or b/n a boy and a girl.

i agree..i don't like Loria at all, she really has no singing ability..i am sorry to be this harsh but i don't hear any sur or taal in her singing, she needs to be out!

Both Vishali was one of my favs (including Vasundhara, Tanmay and Amir) 😭
I was so sad in seeing her eliminated!1 😭 😭

I agree that Loria is not veryy versatile...esp for her age,she sticks to a genre mostly....But at the risk of sounding repetitive,I'd still add that her sense of sur is way better than Vaishali.Vaishali's aur goes for toss most of the time 😊 ,But I guess the junta is in favour of Vaishali,good for Vaishali,she'll certainly do very well 😊

I think that this decision was also based on the fact that Loria's voice is a lot more mature, due to the age difference. Keeping that in mind, Loria's voice has a lot more potential in the current situation. Vaishali's voice still needs a few more years to improve, even for a kid's competition. But I don't question the judges' decision, they have been very sound in there past judgments, decisions, and comments, and they probably had a fine reason behind Vaishali's elimination. And honestly, Vaishali had to go some time soon. But I do feel that Loria's elimination is looming sometime in the near future.

Originally posted by: *Woh Ajnabee*

I think that this decision was also based on the fact that Loria's voice is a lot more mature, due to the age difference. Keeping that in mind, Loria's voice has a lot more potential in the current situation. Vaishali's voice still needs a few more years to improve, even for a kid's competition. But I don't question the judges' decision, they have been very sound in there past judgments, decisions, and comments, and they probably had a fine reason behind Vaishali's elimination. And honestly, Vaishali had to go some time soon. But I do feel that Loria's elimination is looming sometime in the near future.

agreed...The axe will mostly fall on Loria next

True. Loria shud had been out in place of Vaishaali!

Originally posted by: rock&roll

agreed...The axe will mostly fall on Loria next

ooh cant wait for it to...😃😆