Ismail Darbar cries out foul - Page 12

Originally posted by: Iloveapu

None of the participants who came to particpate here were suprised by adds-on or deletes from the existing format.
If Amanat and Mauli ventured to join this contest, they knew very well what to except.
They knew they would face strong & stiff competition from the local participants.
And yet they all came.....why????
Coz they knew the benefits of performing on such a big platform....knew the perks of being here......
Each and every participant who came has befitted hugely, be it Amanat, Mauli or Juniad....!
Clearly showing that none was on a samaj-seva mission....
All elimination so far was perfect. If Mauli was not as good as Sumedha or Poonam, then Mauli DID get eliminated before.
When all three were in finals, I remember reading from these holy-then-thou zillion memebers saying "oh all three are great singers, it does not matter who wins!!!!"
and now Aneek wins...and it's all foul play.....wah kya baat hai!!!

i totally agree..well said👏👏

i persoanlly think ID is just giving statements to gain publicity..persoanlly i am his big fan, i hope he stops now caz i want to see him in C2008!

plus..Zee changed the results to make HR happy is such a baseless comment! they didn't change results in C2005 when clearly Vinit was more deserving and they only had like 5000 votes different, then why would they change the results now??
SRGMP has become a strong institution and HR exit won't really effect it that much! Like someone pointed..it has survived all the up-downs from Sonu to Shaan' exit!
So just guys..and relax! 😳

Originally posted by: piya_y116

i persoanlly think ID is just giving statements to gain publicity..persoanlly i am his big fan, i hope he stops now caz i want to see him in C2008!

plus..Zee changed the results to make HR happy is such a baseless comment! they didn't change results in C2005 when clearly Vinit was more deserving and they only had like 5000 votes different, then why would they change the results now??
SRGMP has become a strong institution and HR exit won't really effect it that much! Like someone pointed..it has survived all the up-downs from Sonu to Shaan' exit!
So just guys..and relax! 😳

Very Good Point....

Originally posted by: mojazwal

Well, for whatever reason, it may have been in Zee's business interests to keep HR happy. I am not saying it is the case. Just that it is not outside the realm of possibility.

And what would Zee gain by keeping HR happy? Zee has a foothold where it can afford to call the shots, why would it simply want to pamper HR? He has been adequately compensated with the remuneration package.Mind you HR was a force to reckon with in C2005 also, but he lost the finals to ID.

Many are saying that Aneek jumped intot he train mid way.Well, on the very first episode of the very first day, this format was told to us by Aditya that the winners of Maratahi and Bangla contest would join in theAgniparisksha round. That was the reward for those two winners.Why hadn't anyone objected then?

Till 12th all were magnanimous that "whoever wins is OK,as all 3 of them are the best" .Today by the same format by the same mandate Aneek won, then why cry foul?

Mr Besharam has shown his clout by changing the results. No question about that

While I think that Aneek is a deserving winner, I too am suspicious of the
results. IF HR was not Aneek's guru, I would probably be ess suspicious
but he taints everything, I am sorry to say.

But I think that really we should be wishing all of the finalists well instead
of being angry. If Raja had won, people would be complaining that the
other 2 singers were technically better.

It's a reality show with SMS voting - -frankly it is a miracle that Amanat
has been in it this long. Not because he is not good - -IMO he is the
most technical singer and I love him. It's just that in a popuarity contest,
non singing factors come into play. In fact, Amanat is lucky that they
groomed him into a pop star, Mohd Vakil is still more talented than him
but has limited recognition.

I mean forget Amanat being a foreigner, Hemanchandra was treated to
the same fate just by being from the South.

At least this year, the final three were probably the best singers of the
bunch (well maybe I would swap in Poonam for Raja).. In C2005, it was
not so good. This show is still 1 crore times better than II and sorry to say
even SVOI.

I think that they need to cash in ASAP and get albums out with their
songs.

MOST i*iot** Topic ever. It Shows your supporting Aneek winning because of region. AMANAT ALI IS BETTER AND WILL BE THE BEST IN THOSE TOP 3. IsmaliDji is out of work does not mean he's not good as a MD.

YOUR TOPIC-👎🏼

It's also bad that ID has made that statement

I don't know what ID will gain by making such a statement....It is being given a big coverage on news channels ....it is coming right now on Aaj Tak ...only thing which ID did not say was that it was HR who was involved it...channel had set the result beforehand....
this is a big allegation ...there can not be smoke without fire ... 😡

Originally posted by: Theatre

MOST i*iot** Topic ever. It Shows your supporting Aneek winning because of region. AMANAT ALI IS BETTER AND WILL BE THE BEST IN THOSE TOP 3. IsmaliDji is out of work does not mean he's not good as a MD.

YOUR TOPIC-👎🏼

Theatre...that was a personal attack. You may have your opinion , others may have theirs too and you simply cant decide for others or their actions by making such statements. 😊

Originally posted by: tindrum

who was involved it...channel had set the result beforehand....
this is a big allegation ...there can not be smoke without fire ... 😡

You know something, had Raja won, someone else perhaps HR would be making this accusation, Had Amanat won, who knows who would be making this accusation. In a real world it is impossible to make all happy. In a contest there will be only one winner and two runners up. it could be anyone.So, such type of reactions or behaviour is not unexpected and neither will it cease. But a person can still handle things ina dignified way.

See Raja the way he took his position. Poeple will always remember Raja's conduct.