Originally posted by: RonnySingh
Good Morning All, I am still here (app ke aas paas) Me little late...due to time zone difference. Thanks for sharing all your information. Reema salute to you and your talent. You seems to be quite dedicated, although we have not listen to your sitar performance in the Live concert (we believe you). I will introduce my self little later.
You guys seems to be highly dedicated HRs Chelis. …J
Coming back to the original point…You were comparing Sonu v/s Aneek in "Tumko Paya Hai To" song from Om-Shanti-Om. But sorry to say, Aneek is not even close to what Sonu has recorded. If you guys listen carefully, the FEEL of the entire song is missing. It may be possible due to Studio – Stage situation. Moreover, Sonu is double the age and far more experienced than Aneek. So there is no comparison. Yes…Aneek did a remarkable job in the given situation for the song….VERY TRUE. He is very good artist and singer "for sure". Is he better then Raja ?……hhhhmmmmmmmm "NO".
In the little champs intro, Sonu presented this song with little different style…Aur wo to Shakal–Akal se bahut Garam Hai….Tumhe Kahan se Thunda Lag gaya.
I know Sonu since my childhood….so no worries….He is THE BEST.
Chalo Ek Baar Phir Se Suno…
Sonu: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g4haKk 691BA
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pqIs-bk23rY
Aneek: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KK0T2MhmNfE
Regards: Ronny
😉
Mr. Singh Saab, if you say Sonu is the best I will agree with you and I have no favourites and love them all. Sonu is an established brand name, and I am sure he did not reach there by accident.
But I enjoy Aneek's singing and next of course is my favourite Amanat who is unbeatable in Sentimental numbers. The truth is I love Amanat's "hungama" even better than Ghulam Ali too. May be I am biased, but we should stick to what we like. A mother thinks that her own child is the best singer and no amount of argument can change the mother's mind.
When I listened to Sonu sing, there was no "feeling" and he did it so mechanically as if performing just another chore. May be this indifferent attitude is good for certain songs.
Raja is good but his voice has no "metash" or "sweetness." He has a lot of "bhava" though and also energy.
But one man's meat is another man's poison. It is pointless to argue till the cows come home because we all have preconceived ideas which we are going to carry to our graves.😉