Amanat was better than Anup Ghoshal - Page 3

Originally posted by: ChameliKaYaar

Comparing the wine with grape is not the most prudent thing to do, Ashish. They both taste good but different. I disagree that Sameer's song brought tears to eyes purely because of the circumstance as you state above. He sang with soul. A lot of not-so-Sameer-fans of this forum also testified to that. Do not compare the voice quality of the two. You are comparing the voice of a mature trainer 20 years old voice with a immature not-even-in-his-teen kid.

Sorry yaar. I was never a big fan of Samir and even when he sang 'Tujhse Naaraaz', I did not find him that great . Too many technical flaws in his singing. Thank God, Sanchita won there. She and Abhro were the best among the lil champs. I digress.

Originally posted by: anarvekar

Sorry yaar. I was never a big fan of Samir and even when he sang 'Tujhse Naaraaz', I did not find him that great . Too many technical flaws in his singing. Thank God, Sanchita won there. She and Abhro were the best among the lil champs. I digress.

Agree..Not talking of 'Tujhse naraaz', but in general, Sameer had many flaws in his singing and he was getting votes for his attitude/style more than his singing..more than him I liked the girl Neha who was eliminated too earlier in the show..Sanchita and Abhro were the best among the lil champs, no doubt.

i definitely agree with you........i didnt like the original rendition done by anup ghoshal........it was really lacking something and he seemed like he was not a professional singer if you know what i mean.......lataji's version however was awesome......but amanat was amazing.......i have to agree though that the lyrics are such that you will just cry but you cant have anyone sing it and then bring that emotional impact........amanat obviously has to be given that credit.....i absolutely love the song......naina

Originally posted by: ChameliKaYaar

Ditto Pradarshak....

and Aneek is the best....😃...His rendition of Ya Ali sounded better than Zubin as well..😛

Let Aneek wait for each song first to be sung by Zubin and later perform it better than Zubin throught his life ?

I think the lyrics rule in this song. 😃

Originally posted by: punjini

I think the lyrics rule in this song. 😃

bingo!

Just now I sang the song to myself and I got tears in my eyes!

Originally posted by: punjini

I think the lyrics rule in this song. 😃

If Himesh sings this, will it still move you?😳

Originally posted by: advil

If Himesh sings this, will it still move you?😳

I think a good singer (and there are many of them) should be able to sing this song well and have a good impact because of the powerful lyrics.

Would I call Himesh a singer? No.

Originally posted by: punjini

Just now I sang the song to myself and I got tears in my eyes!

My god. How were you able to sing that song at all in that case ? I remember that you said you did not get tears flowing down at Amanat's rendition of the same!!😃