versatility thing

I am too tired of reading discussion that raja can only sing one type of songs where as aneek/amanat sing all kind of song

why did not they give same songs( belongs to diff diff genra) to all three participant ( they used to do that in old sa re ga ma show i remember) and then judge who sang it better..whose singing touched the heart

I would love to know other people opinion

Originally posted by: hirni

I am too tired of reading discussion that raja can only sing one type of songs where as aneek/amanat sing all kind of song

why did not they give same songs( belongs to diff diff genra) to all three participant ( they used to do that in old sa re ga ma show i remember) and then judge who sang it better..whose singing touched the heart

I would love to know other people opinion

First of all, the final performance is simply for entertainment and is not included in a contesttants evaluation. The votings will close before the final starts. its just a stage show, so showcasing talent now is gone,but yes, instead of repeat they could have tried something different.

I agree with Advil....and who care wether a singer can sing same genere or different...can Sonu Nigam sing sufi songs...Even if he did I wont like it coz I like his soft but mature tone...the same way I loved Mussarat for his unique tone of voice...just imagine him singing soft song...

Raja has tried all styles and sang nicely in all of them except pardesi. Anyways, no one can perfect all fields. Raja has perfected his style of singing, while others copy the original singer, and think that they are versatile, and will fall flat on face if asked to sing a new song.

yeah rakhi...thats what i was thinking..then why people are bashing raja that he can only sing one type of song so he does not deserve to win..whatever type of song he is singing ..is singing up to perfection..piya haji ali,ma tujhe salam,dard e disco,naina thage lenge omkara..etc..long list but all are soul touching...specially piya haji ali ..raja has given soul to this song..i had heard original before but never felt to listen to that song again and again but since raja sung this in his divine voice i listen to this song ten time a day..he sung it ten time better than the original one

See Hirni ...all mentors say they support all contestants equally but in heart in heart they want there candidate to win...they are humane...so nothing wrong...and they know Raja is way far good in singing and so the slightest opportunity they pull his leg...ID and HR work togatehr and above all HR knows Amanat will not win as he has no Fan following whereas Raja has a bigger fan following then HR himself...

All the non-raja fans are feeling insecure cuz of his massive fan following cuz he is really talented.

i dont understand raja bashing people..how do you get the big fan following cause more people like you than your competitors thats was the idea of public voting ..vote for who you like..so why those people are angry because raja has big fan following..

I think RAJA bashing is going on because most of RAJA fan are voting for free (FREE WEB SITE)while fan of amanat and aneek are spending money to vote

and this is not fair